Just passing through town and we decided to try this spot based on its rating online. We split a small Goodfella. It was well constructed and baked to perfection. Tasty toppings and crispy outer crust giving way to a pleasant chew inside. Added ranch and hot honey and I was very surprised at how good it really was. Given the chance I'd definitely come back to see what more they have to offer.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Katie Olson
Really good food but probably the worst service/rudest servers I’ve ever encountered!! I would recommend ordering out at this
Love this place so beautiful inside and the pizza is wonderful. I had the Sinatra special and can’t wait to try another special pizza next time my friends both got the Green Chile Pasta and they LOVED IT we will be back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vickie Mika
This was absolutely the worst pizza we have ever had. It wasn't finished when my husband went to pick it up so it definitely went into the box hot and our hotel was only 4 minutes away. So I give it a 1 for the food experience.My overall rating is higher because of the service. 1. When the pizza wasn't ready, the lady offered my husband a free drink while he waited. 2. I immediately sent a message through the contact us email telling them the situation and how unhappy we were. I got an immediate response and apology and an offer of a refund. There was continued correspondence about the concern through 2 other emails. We declined the refund offer and the owner ( or manager) assured us they would be looking into the situation to see what happened. Customer Service is important and I was pleased with their efforts to address our concerns so I bumped up their rating foe that reason.
Food: 1
Service: 5
Artimus Protensor
I googled "best pizza in Amarillo", and this is the first thing that popped up. Unfortunately, while the restaurant definitely had its strong points, the pizza wasn't one of them.The first thing that arrived was the drink. They have an interesting selection of drinks that I've never seen in restaurants before. Then came my appetizer, which they just called 'cheese curds'. This was the high point of the meal; the batter was zesty and well seasoned, and it complemented the hint of jalapeno in the cheese perfectly. I was stoked! What would the main course be like?But then the pizza came.I kept it simple and ordered a pepperoni pizza, and they kept it simple and gave me something that would have been an embarrassment even for the big delivery chains. I know I asked for a 'traditional pizza' but come on, I still expected something good. What I got was mundane and honestly kind of unpleasant-looking. There were a couple of burnt-black bubbles on top, the bottom of the crust was definitely somewhat burnt, and yet the parts that weren't burnt somehow gave off the impression of being undercooked. I saw nothing to redeem this poor sad pizza. In fact I'm afraid I have to go to somewhat of an extreme and say 'the pizza was so lame that the burnt part was actually an improvement.'So, this is definitely not the best pizza I've had in Amarillo. In fact, it's close to the bottom of the barrel. I may come back for those cheese curds though.
Seems weird for this to be on the back side of a strip center, but you wouldn't know it from inside the restaurant. Pizza crust is perhaps the best we've had in our travels. Great service. I would definitely consider coming back the next time we come through town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Pizza
Erin Howard
We had dinner here on a friday night recently. Food was good, honestly not out of this world, but still good- excellent service. The Caprese salad & Lasagna were both good. While we did not have any, I noticed they seemed to have a good selection on wines and ipa's. We are planning on going back to try the brunch!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Lasagna
Laurie Moreau
An absolutely wonderful server, Wonderful food and a nice atmosphere. I'll definitely be going back with my husband next time we're in town.Dietary restrictions: They were great to work with me on dietary restrictions.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Pizza
Gabrielle G
I enjoyed the Caprese Salad and The Wiseguy pizza. Soooo good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dan
The pizza is good, but every time I've ordered to go the pizza is cold when we get home, even though it's stored in a warming bag when my wife gets there to pick it up.The calamari should be removed from the menu. Clearly previously frozen garbage. Should not be served. Rubbery and inedible.
Great food and atmosphere. The owner is great, and he loves his place.
Great service and foor was
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sweet Potato Fries, Pepperoni Pizza
Just passing through town and we decided to try this spot based on its rating online. We split a small Goodfella. It was well constructed and baked to perfection. Tasty toppings and crispy outer crust giving way to a pleasant chew inside. Added ranch and hot honey and I was very surprised at how good it really was. Given the chance I'd definitely come back to see what more they have to offer.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Really good food but probably the worst service/rudest servers I’ve ever encountered!! I would recommend ordering out at this
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 1
Best in town by far.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lasagna, Bread Pudding, Pepperoni Pizza
Love spending time there with my friends!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Love this place so beautiful inside and the pizza is wonderful. I had the Sinatra special and can’t wait to try another special pizza next time my friends both got the Green Chile Pasta and they LOVED IT we will be back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This was absolutely the worst pizza we have ever had. It wasn't finished when my husband went to pick it up so it definitely went into the box hot and our hotel was only 4 minutes away. So I give it a 1 for the food experience.My overall rating is higher because of the service. 1. When the pizza wasn't ready, the lady offered my husband a free drink while he waited. 2. I immediately sent a message through the contact us email telling them the situation and how unhappy we were. I got an immediate response and apology and an offer of a refund. There was continued correspondence about the concern through 2 other emails. We declined the refund offer and the owner ( or manager) assured us they would be looking into the situation to see what happened. Customer Service is important and I was pleased with their efforts to address our concerns so I bumped up their rating foe that reason.
Food: 1
Service: 5
I googled "best pizza in Amarillo", and this is the first thing that popped up. Unfortunately, while the restaurant definitely had its strong points, the pizza wasn't one of them.The first thing that arrived was the drink. They have an interesting selection of drinks that I've never seen in restaurants before. Then came my appetizer, which they just called 'cheese curds'. This was the high point of the meal; the batter was zesty and well seasoned, and it complemented the hint of jalapeno in the cheese perfectly. I was stoked! What would the main course be like?But then the pizza came.I kept it simple and ordered a pepperoni pizza, and they kept it simple and gave me something that would have been an embarrassment even for the big delivery chains. I know I asked for a 'traditional pizza' but come on, I still expected something good. What I got was mundane and honestly kind of unpleasant-looking. There were a couple of burnt-black bubbles on top, the bottom of the crust was definitely somewhat burnt, and yet the parts that weren't burnt somehow gave off the impression of being undercooked. I saw nothing to redeem this poor sad pizza. In fact I'm afraid I have to go to somewhat of an extreme and say 'the pizza was so lame that the burnt part was actually an improvement.'So, this is definitely not the best pizza I've had in Amarillo. In fact, it's close to the bottom of the barrel. I may come back for those cheese curds though.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
The waiter was great and the food was wonderful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Seems weird for this to be on the back side of a strip center, but you wouldn't know it from inside the restaurant. Pizza crust is perhaps the best we've had in our travels. Great service. I would definitely consider coming back the next time we come through town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Pizza
We had dinner here on a friday night recently. Food was good, honestly not out of this world, but still good- excellent service. The Caprese salad & Lasagna were both good. While we did not have any, I noticed they seemed to have a good selection on wines and ipa's. We are planning on going back to try the brunch!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Lasagna
An absolutely wonderful server, Wonderful food and a nice atmosphere. I'll definitely be going back with my husband next time we're in town.Dietary restrictions: They were great to work with me on dietary restrictions.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Pizza
I enjoyed the Caprese Salad and The Wiseguy pizza. Soooo good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza is good, but every time I've ordered to go the pizza is cold when we get home, even though it's stored in a warming bag when my wife gets there to pick it up.The calamari should be removed from the menu. Clearly previously frozen garbage. Should not be served. Rubbery and inedible.