I used to eat here all the time and the service is awful. They are rude and not helpful. There is always a problem when calling to place an order. We keep trying them and it never changes. Will NEVER go there again!!
Sandra Hodge
Pizza is always great, wings were amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Canadian Bacon Giant Pizza Slice, Wings, Pie
Fred Schwager
Awesome
BMP
This has become our go-to carry-out pizza place. In a few occasions they remade the pizza without me asking because they weren't happy with the end product. That tells me they take great pride in their work.I highly recommend getting the cheesey/garlic bread. It's a big hit with both the adults and kids.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Sticks, Garlic Knots
Miriam Sandria
It was so so yummy! The pizza was fresh and warm and they were huge slices. The wings were also so wonderful and really good flavor! The customer service was also really nice and welcoming and so was the atmosphere. I definitely recommend eating here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Jennifer Sandria
The pizza is absolutely delicious! The wings are big and juicy! We have definitely found our family spot when in town!We ordered an xl pepperoni and 20 wings! For 1 adult, 3 teens, and 1 10 yr boy! And we have 3 slices leftover.Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Charles Fuerbringer
Very good food and service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Classic New York Pizza
Adam Lewis
The pizza was outstanding. The ingredients were fresh and perfectly balanced. Authentic New York Style pizza and I lived in Brooklyn Heights as a child and later years in New England. We ordered wings and fries too. The wings were crispy and perfectly seasoned. French fries were excellent: crunchy and lightly salted. We had the food delivered to our home and the delivery man was pleasant and right on time.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Pie
Chuck Whitacre
Great pizza! The pizza was perfectly prepared and much larger than we expected. We're very happy that we chose Brooklyn Pie Company for supper tonight.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Small Pizza
Angela Smith
We had a delivery order. It took almost an hour so order promptly. But the single pizza price is huge! The wings were ok. I wish I had gotten a spicy sauce or Tabasco with my order, I did not get celery with my order so the menu may need updating. The chocolate cake was large but kind of dry. Get the cheesecake!
Great pizza however it was the service that will bring me back. They were very busy (I’m guessing that’s the usual activity for this establishment) and McKayla was AWESOME!!! She was getting things done, multitasking over load and keeping everything running smoothly. All with a beautiful smile and professionalism that is hard to find these days, with an “I’ve got this under control” can do attitude of just “get it done”. I’ll be back for sure next beach trip around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Sticks, Classic New York Pizza
steven porter
This local pizza place is a true standout. The exceptional customer service, including offering a military discount without prompting, is a testament to their commitment to the community. It's the best pizza on the island, hands down. The crust is perfectly crispy, and the toppings are fresh. But what truly sets them apart is their remarkable staff. They make you feel like a regular, whether it's your first visit or hundredth. Their warmth and dedication to ensuring your dining experience is stellar is outstanding. It's safe to say this place is a slice of pizza paradise with unbeatable service, military support, great prices, and the island's finest pizza. Don't miss it!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Maegan Johnson
This was our third visit to Brooklyn Pie after several years away and it was just as good as the first time. The pizza was delicious, the cheese sticks are mysteriously good, and the service was impeccable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Sticks, Classic New York Pizza
Alice Guajardo
We had the Supreme and Brooklyn meat pizzas. Crust was on point for both, but the Supreme was watery i guess because of all the veggies. Still was a great pizza but that was my only criticism! Staff was friendly and greeted you as you walk in! Definitely will come back and
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Jacob Hernandez
Just moved to CC, and I was stoked about visiting this place since it said NY style pizza. One thing is for sure, this ain't NY style pizza (or maybe just that day wasn't ??)I ordered two slices to go, 1 cheese and 1 pepe. This was at 3:10pm. Thirty (30) minutes later, I got my slices. WoW!!! 30 minutes for two slices, and the worst part of it was a couple that came in 15 minutes later, ordered a whole pie, and had gotten the pie before I got my slices.Now, the cashier (which was nice) comes to me and says, "I'm sorry, the pizza manager didn't realize that there were no more slices. Ok! I told her this was going to be a bad review cause this is what I do (check out my food reviews at gorditos4eva on Instagram). With that being said, I was like, let me see how the slices come out, and maybe that will help the review be better than bad. Mine you, the place was not packed ??But NOOOOO!! The pizza was HORRIBLE! Look at the picture. Let's start with the cheese slice. It was burnt underneath but not crispy. The pizza was cold, and the cheese was dry and stale. The sauce tasted like like tomato paste straight from the can, lacking taste. So, I can imagine that slice was reheated so many times and just left out for me to get ?The pepe, this one was a bit more fresh. But the undercarriage also burnt. The cheese and sauce had no taste, but the pepe was alright. The crust was a bit better than the cheese ?The atmosphere was alright, good space, just hot as ??? parking is good.With that being said. It's not worth the time, the drive, or the money. I'm very disappointed!!! Supposedly Brooklyn Pie Co. comes from a long line tradition of great pizza. This was not the case here. I had high expectations, and you guys killed it.Do not come here!!!
I used to eat here all the time and the service is awful. They are rude and not helpful. There is always a problem when calling to place an order. We keep trying them and it never changes. Will NEVER go there again!!
Pizza is always great, wings were amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Canadian Bacon Giant Pizza Slice, Wings, Pie
Awesome
This has become our go-to carry-out pizza place. In a few occasions they remade the pizza without me asking because they weren't happy with the end product. That tells me they take great pride in their work.I highly recommend getting the cheesey/garlic bread. It's a big hit with both the adults and kids.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Sticks, Garlic Knots
It was so so yummy! The pizza was fresh and warm and they were huge slices. The wings were also so wonderful and really good flavor! The customer service was also really nice and welcoming and so was the atmosphere. I definitely recommend eating here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
The pizza is absolutely delicious! The wings are big and juicy! We have definitely found our family spot when in town!We ordered an xl pepperoni and 20 wings! For 1 adult, 3 teens, and 1 10 yr boy! And we have 3 slices leftover.Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very good food and service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Classic New York Pizza
The pizza was outstanding. The ingredients were fresh and perfectly balanced. Authentic New York Style pizza and I lived in Brooklyn Heights as a child and later years in New England. We ordered wings and fries too. The wings were crispy and perfectly seasoned. French fries were excellent: crunchy and lightly salted. We had the food delivered to our home and the delivery man was pleasant and right on time.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Pie
Great pizza! The pizza was perfectly prepared and much larger than we expected. We're very happy that we chose Brooklyn Pie Company for supper tonight.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Small Pizza
We had a delivery order. It took almost an hour so order promptly. But the single pizza price is huge! The wings were ok. I wish I had gotten a spicy sauce or Tabasco with my order, I did not get celery with my order so the menu may need updating. The chocolate cake was large but kind of dry. Get the cheesecake!
Food: 4
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Great pizza however it was the service that will bring me back. They were very busy (I’m guessing that’s the usual activity for this establishment) and McKayla was AWESOME!!! She was getting things done, multitasking over load and keeping everything running smoothly. All with a beautiful smile and professionalism that is hard to find these days, with an “I’ve got this under control” can do attitude of just “get it done”. I’ll be back for sure next beach trip around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Sticks, Classic New York Pizza
This local pizza place is a true standout. The exceptional customer service, including offering a military discount without prompting, is a testament to their commitment to the community. It's the best pizza on the island, hands down. The crust is perfectly crispy, and the toppings are fresh. But what truly sets them apart is their remarkable staff. They make you feel like a regular, whether it's your first visit or hundredth. Their warmth and dedication to ensuring your dining experience is stellar is outstanding. It's safe to say this place is a slice of pizza paradise with unbeatable service, military support, great prices, and the island's finest pizza. Don't miss it!
Food: 5
Service: 5
This was our third visit to Brooklyn Pie after several years away and it was just as good as the first time. The pizza was delicious, the cheese sticks are mysteriously good, and the service was impeccable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Sticks, Classic New York Pizza
We had the Supreme and Brooklyn meat pizzas. Crust was on point for both, but the Supreme was watery i guess because of all the veggies. Still was a great pizza but that was my only criticism! Staff was friendly and greeted you as you walk in! Definitely will come back and
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Just moved to CC, and I was stoked about visiting this place since it said NY style pizza. One thing is for sure, this ain't NY style pizza (or maybe just that day wasn't ??)I ordered two slices to go, 1 cheese and 1 pepe. This was at 3:10pm. Thirty (30) minutes later, I got my slices. WoW!!! 30 minutes for two slices, and the worst part of it was a couple that came in 15 minutes later, ordered a whole pie, and had gotten the pie before I got my slices.Now, the cashier (which was nice) comes to me and says, "I'm sorry, the pizza manager didn't realize that there were no more slices. Ok! I told her this was going to be a bad review cause this is what I do (check out my food reviews at gorditos4eva on Instagram). With that being said, I was like, let me see how the slices come out, and maybe that will help the review be better than bad. Mine you, the place was not packed ??But NOOOOO!! The pizza was HORRIBLE! Look at the picture. Let's start with the cheese slice. It was burnt underneath but not crispy. The pizza was cold, and the cheese was dry and stale. The sauce tasted like like tomato paste straight from the can, lacking taste. So, I can imagine that slice was reheated so many times and just left out for me to get ?The pepe, this one was a bit more fresh. But the undercarriage also burnt. The cheese and sauce had no taste, but the pepe was alright. The crust was a bit better than the cheese ?The atmosphere was alright, good space, just hot as ??? parking is good.With that being said. It's not worth the time, the drive, or the money. I'm very disappointed!!! Supposedly Brooklyn Pie Co. comes from a long line tradition of great pizza. This was not the case here. I had high expectations, and you guys killed it.Do not come here!!!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2