Old Chicago Pizza & Taproom

1400 North 795 East, Logan
(435) 774-0008

Recent Reviews

Tim Gardner

Great fast service. Thin crust is terrible. It may be homemade but it tastes and has the mouth feel of a frozen, pre-made crust. I ordered the Supreme Individual pizza for dinner. It is supposed to have 6 toppings. It had 6 different toppings but they gave 1/6 portion of each. This was the thinnest "Supreme" pizza I've had in my life.

Jaden Johnson

I was disappointed. Pizza wasn't cut throughly ended up ripping the pizza. A little more on the bland side of taste. Might try again since it was a take out order.

Jeanette Kincheloe

The staff went out of their way to take care of me on the day of my fathers passing. Great personalities and kind. I highly suggest the spicy fried pickles and order all the sauces to dip. You won't regret coming here. The bartender with long dark brown and phenomenal eye makeup was the angel I needed that day. I think her name starts with an A. God bless you lady. Thanks for the hug.

MelaRae Big

25 cent beer shot tasters, awesome. Tara has been our server twice now and she is attentive to keeping our waters filled and our beers coming. She is knowledgeable with the menu selections and gives great suggestions. She also knows her beers and mixed drinks, so she is helpful with suggestions in choosing what kind of cocktail or beer your are to enjoy with your meal. And with the 25 cent tasters you might just find a new favorite brew. Hoppy beers to ya!

Ben C.

I wanted to like this place. To get inside it can be congested and not very convenient. We were greeted warmly and being a Friday night we were sat quickly. There are plenty of televisions if you want to watch a game. It is a very noisy environment and it wasn't too packed. We waited a little bit to get served but he did show up. Took our order and it didn't take long for it to arrive. I started with a short order of wings in buffalo sauce. The chicken was good but not enough crunch I like in a wing. The sauce was average and normal buffalo sauce. The ranch was very runny. I ordered the hangover burger medium rare. I am not a huge fan of the charcoal after taste which was the first thing I tasted. The meat was hefty. The flavors seemed to go well and the bun wasn't soggy. It was just too much meat. It is a very messy burger. The waffle fries were good but I couldn't eat all due to the extra meat.

Mike C.

The food here is pretty good, but you will have to wait on it. I would not suggest calling in. I waited an hour after it was supposed to be ready (which was an hour after the call in). So we get some food that is cold some that is just finished but mainly just not good.

Brandon Donivan

Amazing place to eat and drink. Italian nachos are my favorite here. No other place comes close.

Josh Vollmer

With my lifestyle change of eating healthier they've got great salads to choose from!!! My favorite is the Sweet Thai Chicken but everything I've seen from the burgers to pizza look amazing as well and my cohorts/lunch mates have nothing but good things to say. Highly recommend!

Kari P.

I love this place. Great servers. Great Calzone! It seems it is always busy. I've never had a bad meal. I love their onion rings but they have not had them the last 2 times I visited. Which breaks my heart.

Ryan Esco

First visit, had great experience. Great sports bar vibe. Food was very good, especially the artichoke dip appetizer. Nice menu selection, wide variety. Great service by all! Definitely recommend!

Joshua S.

The food has always been fine. The major downside of this location is ever Monday night the students athletes from Utah State get free meals from here and it is just crazy! Additionally they do not do take-out or online orders because of the Athletes. Aka do not go here or try to order from here and n Monday's.

Frederick W.

I was lucky to have a reason to visit Logan from the east coast and was looking for a great sandwich and beer and stumbled across this place. In short, the sandwich was awesome, the service was great, and the whole operation seemed like you could just come in for a meal or to watch a game (the best of all possible worlds). If you come to Logan and want a range of options, this is a great place to start. (Note: I almost never give five stars; if you see me give four stars, it's the top of most people's ratings; a restaurant has to surprise and blow me away to get five stars, so four stars is very strong.)

Teresa Hart

I love the manicotti at this place and the Ceasar salad is divine!! No matter when I go, the food is perfection! I had a Gnome Eggnog this time as well and it was delish!!

Sean M.

OCP was a welcome addition to Logan's generally 'dry' dining climate, and just OK (for a college town) choice of eats. I've eaten there 4-5x, last night being the latest...and final time (if I'm paying). Why? High prices for mediocre pizza and burgers, kitchen staff that think it's ok to send the crumble/dregs from the fryer and call them fries/appetizers, and a pint of beer just shy of a 6-pack $ at Winco...all topped off by a corporate take on ambiance. Diners can do better even in our town. Morty's hamburger, for instance. Or Jack's pizza on jazz night. True locals may give it 4 stars, but consider the source when reading reviews. I'm not rating it a 1 star because that's just false. But it's no 4 star, let alone 5.

Jasper C.

They got rid of two of the special pizzas that I loved from the menu, so I had to take a risk with Thai. Still really nice.

Load More