This place is a hidden gem. My husband and I originally planned to go for a late breakfast at eggexpectations when we pulled up and saw that they were no longer in business and had closed! What’s up with that? This place was always busy every time we went. So being somewhat new to the area, I did a search for restaurants near me. Brooklyn Brothers showed up right next-door and they had good reviews. So we said , why not?We went in and a pretty young lady greeted us and sat us at a booth. We were the only ones there, but it was after the lunchtime rush would’ve been. We were promptly served drinks but it took us a while to decide what we wanted to order because there were so many things on the menu that sounded really good. We ended up ordering their signature, Brooklyn Brothers pizza to share, and my husband ordered a regular salad and I ordered a modified house salad(added feta and olives, sort of like a Greek salad). The salad greens were fresh and it included roasted peppers, fresh red onions and cucumbers and cheese. It was a very nice sized helping. When the pizza came, my husband and I looked at each other - if it tasted half as good as it looked, we would be happy. Well, I have got to tell you, it is some of the best crust I have had in years, and I am Italian! Plenty of meat toppings and nice and cheesy. My husband commented that it’s one of the best pizzas he has ever had in his life and he is 66 years old… Lol We couldn’t believe we had lived in the area almost 7 years and had never come to this place. We asked how long they had been in the area, 16 years!Anyway, sorry for the long review. The food selection is numerous, the prices were fair, the atmosphere is nice and clean, and the staff was attentive . I can tell you now it will become one of our regular places to eat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Greek Salad, Brooklyn Brothers Special Pizza 16
Angela spilman
We ordered a steak n cheese and this is what it had. Barely any meat and all lettuce. Very disappointed as this wasn't cheap either.
Food: 1
William Hope
This is a great pizza place. It's my go to place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brooklyn Brothers Special Pizza 16
Holy “Yum Yummy” Yum
It's a restaurant that residents like in a small town. However, food quality was not good for the price.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Jason Guy
Fast and friendly service. They treat customers well and work hard and I can tell it's a great team behind the counter.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Traci Dove
Best club sandwich in the area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shawn Bunner
I don’t often post negative reviews, but felt strongly about this isolated experience. We have dined in and gotten take out on a consistent basis since Brooklyn Brothers opened. Tonight we ordered pizza and my son ordered Spaghetti and Meatballs. The pizza was excellent, but the pasta barely had any sauce. I spoke to the server about it and she brought a small ramekin of sauce. When we got our bill, I found she charged us 85 cents for the sauce. It’s not the 85 cents, it’s the principle. I’m disappointed our server didn’t discuss this with me. I would have gladly taken this up with the manager had I been informed. I normally tip 25-30% of the taxes total. I was not as generous this evening and Brooklyn Brothers has lost a consistent customer over 85 cents.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Joshua Vanderplate
Really good quality. Dough was delish and service was kind and attentive.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ian Keyser
We've been going to BBP for a few years now. I love pizza. I grew up in an Italian pizzeria in the nnk called Ninos where I learned the art of pizza making from nino himself. Once i moved to Northern Va, i searched and searched for great pizza, and I just never could find that authentic taste. Then I discovered BBP. BEST PIZZA for miles IMO. We don't live anywhere near there but when it's pizza night it's BROOKLYN BROS for the win????????
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kelly Chrisman
Inside the restaurant looks appealing. Like a pizza restaurant should look like. The food is top notch. We had the Brooklyn Supreme which was amazing.
Place honestly just isn't good, all the food wasn't hot, it was luke warm, the pizzas tasted like they were sitting out for like 20 minutes, there was no cheese pull, the taste wasn't bad but pizza should be hot and fresh when eaten like everything, I don't pay for a pizza that has been sitting out that's not hot. The chicken tenders were pretty good, hot and fresh, honestly, some of the best I've ever had. The Calzone was the worst Calzone I've ever had, we got the basic calzone, cheese and rigolta, aka (ricotta) it was like 90 percent cheese, the cheese was so tough and dry, it was almost like eating gum, when the calzone first came out it wasn't hot either. Food is meant to be hot and fresh when eaten. People don't pay for food to be old and not hot. Everything was pretty bad. The service was pretty good. I guess nothing exceptional, no complaints, though. The atmosphere is terrible. They had weird old guy walking all around the restaurant, like he was having a panic attack, he was doing weird movements , tlaking weird, acting very intense, he was just really weird and making my family uncomfortable. They had a Pac-Man machine, but it didn't even work. The place is clean though, mainly the old guy just made it feel weird, I think he may have been on some type of drugs or was drinking I don't know, but he was weird. Prices also just aren't worth the terrible food and risking your life around some crazy weird old man that might just snap. NEVER COMING BACK.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 4
Michael A. Wightman (Son of Deseret)
You can never go wrong going to Brooklyn Brothers Pizza! Everything is great. Servers could be more attentive, (slow) but nothing that would prevent me from returning.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
ANK
Cozy place to try out pizza. The place reminds you of the old restaurant that was built back in the days. A nice place to eat and drink!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anirudh Kodumuri
Cozy place to try out pizza. The place reminds you of the old restaurant that was built back in the days. A nice place to eat and drink!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael A. Wightman
You can never go wrong going to Brooklyn Brothers Pizza! Everything is great. Servers could be more attentive, (slow) but nothing that would prevent me from returning.
This place is a hidden gem. My husband and I originally planned to go for a late breakfast at eggexpectations when we pulled up and saw that they were no longer in business and had closed! What’s up with that? This place was always busy every time we went. So being somewhat new to the area, I did a search for restaurants near me. Brooklyn Brothers showed up right next-door and they had good reviews. So we said , why not?We went in and a pretty young lady greeted us and sat us at a booth. We were the only ones there, but it was after the lunchtime rush would’ve been. We were promptly served drinks but it took us a while to decide what we wanted to order because there were so many things on the menu that sounded really good. We ended up ordering their signature, Brooklyn Brothers pizza to share, and my husband ordered a regular salad and I ordered a modified house salad(added feta and olives, sort of like a Greek salad). The salad greens were fresh and it included roasted peppers, fresh red onions and cucumbers and cheese. It was a very nice sized helping. When the pizza came, my husband and I looked at each other - if it tasted half as good as it looked, we would be happy. Well, I have got to tell you, it is some of the best crust I have had in years, and I am Italian! Plenty of meat toppings and nice and cheesy. My husband commented that it’s one of the best pizzas he has ever had in his life and he is 66 years old… Lol We couldn’t believe we had lived in the area almost 7 years and had never come to this place. We asked how long they had been in the area, 16 years!Anyway, sorry for the long review. The food selection is numerous, the prices were fair, the atmosphere is nice and clean, and the staff was attentive . I can tell you now it will become one of our regular places to eat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Greek Salad, Brooklyn Brothers Special Pizza 16
We ordered a steak n cheese and this is what it had. Barely any meat and all lettuce. Very disappointed as this wasn't cheap either.
Food: 1
This is a great pizza place. It's my go to place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brooklyn Brothers Special Pizza 16
It's a restaurant that residents like in a small town. However, food quality was not good for the price.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Fast and friendly service. They treat customers well and work hard and I can tell it's a great team behind the counter.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best club sandwich in the area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I don’t often post negative reviews, but felt strongly about this isolated experience. We have dined in and gotten take out on a consistent basis since Brooklyn Brothers opened. Tonight we ordered pizza and my son ordered Spaghetti and Meatballs. The pizza was excellent, but the pasta barely had any sauce. I spoke to the server about it and she brought a small ramekin of sauce. When we got our bill, I found she charged us 85 cents for the sauce. It’s not the 85 cents, it’s the principle. I’m disappointed our server didn’t discuss this with me. I would have gladly taken this up with the manager had I been informed. I normally tip 25-30% of the taxes total. I was not as generous this evening and Brooklyn Brothers has lost a consistent customer over 85 cents.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Really good quality. Dough was delish and service was kind and attentive.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
We've been going to BBP for a few years now. I love pizza. I grew up in an Italian pizzeria in the nnk called Ninos where I learned the art of pizza making from nino himself. Once i moved to Northern Va, i searched and searched for great pizza, and I just never could find that authentic taste. Then I discovered BBP. BEST PIZZA for miles IMO. We don't live anywhere near there but when it's pizza night it's BROOKLYN BROS for the win????????
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Inside the restaurant looks appealing. Like a pizza restaurant should look like. The food is top notch. We had the Brooklyn Supreme which was amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Place honestly just isn't good, all the food wasn't hot, it was luke warm, the pizzas tasted like they were sitting out for like 20 minutes, there was no cheese pull, the taste wasn't bad but pizza should be hot and fresh when eaten like everything, I don't pay for a pizza that has been sitting out that's not hot. The chicken tenders were pretty good, hot and fresh, honestly, some of the best I've ever had. The Calzone was the worst Calzone I've ever had, we got the basic calzone, cheese and rigolta, aka (ricotta) it was like 90 percent cheese, the cheese was so tough and dry, it was almost like eating gum, when the calzone first came out it wasn't hot either. Food is meant to be hot and fresh when eaten. People don't pay for food to be old and not hot. Everything was pretty bad. The service was pretty good. I guess nothing exceptional, no complaints, though. The atmosphere is terrible. They had weird old guy walking all around the restaurant, like he was having a panic attack, he was doing weird movements , tlaking weird, acting very intense, he was just really weird and making my family uncomfortable. They had a Pac-Man machine, but it didn't even work. The place is clean though, mainly the old guy just made it feel weird, I think he may have been on some type of drugs or was drinking I don't know, but he was weird. Prices also just aren't worth the terrible food and risking your life around some crazy weird old man that might just snap. NEVER COMING BACK.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 4
You can never go wrong going to Brooklyn Brothers Pizza! Everything is great. Servers could be more attentive, (slow) but nothing that would prevent me from returning.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Cozy place to try out pizza. The place reminds you of the old restaurant that was built back in the days. A nice place to eat and drink!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cozy place to try out pizza. The place reminds you of the old restaurant that was built back in the days. A nice place to eat and drink!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
You can never go wrong going to Brooklyn Brothers Pizza! Everything is great. Servers could be more attentive, (slow) but nothing that would prevent me from returning.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3