After arriving in the Fairhaven District, the first restaurant we came upon that allowed dogs in their outside seating area was Fat Pie Pizza. We were seated immediately for lunch at a table right in front of the restaurant (great for people watching). Our server was super friendly and attentive, and took our order quickly. I wanted to try one of their pizzas, but there was no way I could eat a whole pie by myself (my wife didn't want pizza for her meal). We ended up getting mac and cheese for my wife and chicken parmesan for me, both of which were very good. Our receipt had a 15% discount at Acme Ice Cream (just next door) valid only today. Of course, we couldn't let that discount go to waste! I can definitely recommend this pizza joint if you're in the area.
Dan Robbins
My bison burger was burned to a crisp, way over well done and when I mentioned this to the waiter he got all weird and sarcastic, the rest of my party got pizza which tasted like it was previously frozen, literally a costco pizza is better. My guess is that they are having a hard time finding good staff so they have resorted to hiring random untrained forest animals such as crows and squirrels to cook the food and the waiters are all bitter because they wish they were at home making Tik Tok videos. We will not be going back. Save yourself and go get some good pizza at Mambo Italiano or La Fiamma, if you want a better burger go anywhere but here. As far as worse restaurants in Bellingham go there is a new heavy hitter in town and its Fat Pie Pizza!
steve s.
We ordered one Chicago pizza, ome Brooklyn Pizza and one large salad to go. When we got there our pizzas were ready, but no salad. We were told they were working on it. After 10 minutes, we asked again and they said, "oh, yeah." And asked for someone to make it. Finally a staff showed up with a salad and asked the hostess...does this look right? I've never made one. We got our order, had to ask for forks and napkins (they gave us 2 napkins for 2 pizzas.) Also, when we left with the food, we never heard a Thank you, or sorry for the delay, just...."Have a good one,". Really? I can't stand to not be thanked for patronizing a store. When we got back to our hotel, we opened the Chicago pizza to find it HAD NOT BEEN CUT! Also, it was totally inedible...absolutely drenched in red sauce. It was an expensive disappointment. The salad was adequate and the Brooklyn pizza was good. But the service was just inexcusable and we will not be going back.
Ashley J.
I was excited to try this small business when I was in Fairhaven, but I was disappointed. I got just a simple cheese Detroit style. While it smelled really good, it lacked flavor. The crust reminds me of Pizza Hut Pan Pizza. You know that super oily almost burnt on the outside crust. There was very minimal sauce to the point I couldn't even really taste or see it. The cheese, was cheese. Overall, it lacked flavor and was just kinda boring.
Lindy Richards Meaders
absolutely best pizza ( and I don't like pizza ) ever eaten. The tomato basil soup and spinach salad delicious! Just wish we had discovered it earlier...
born inbham
Ok so this is the second time we've tired this place and it's just not worth it!! Much better places to spend our money. To be clear great service from the front staff!! But the kitchen not so good! The food was gross the chicken pram was a microwaved piece of chicken with canned sauce over it zero flavor. The bread was old and nasty, I guess it was to soak up the water in my bowl from the spaghetti noodles they didn't drain.. The Mac and cheese was ok not much on flavor took it home and flavored it up. We also ordered a meatball sub got a parm sub than waited to get the right sub. When the right one came, yeah microwaved meatballs with canned sauce.. If I wanted that I'd make it at home!!Absolute waste of money!!
Tom Nelson
very good, great staff...
denise s
Really great food. Love this place. Ironically I've never had their pizza but their salads and sandwiches are amazing. Nice to sit outside on a sunny day.
nriggle
Our teenage son hadn’t eaten here yet since moving to Bellingham so we brought him here to try it. We ordered a Chicago style pizza- I believe it was the Uno - meat only, Fat Mac and a side salad. The salad came first and it was absolutely delicious. They use the good greens, onions, cherry tomatoes, carrots and Parmesan cheese. The Fat Mac was good as well. It’s topped with bacon and breadcrumbs. There are some other restaurants in Bellingham with amazing Mac n cheese so we wanted to compare. We didn’t think this was as good but we were not disappointed either. The pizza was so good and our son absolutely loved it. I prefer veggies on my pizza but our son loves meat and cheese pizzas. The service was slow when we arrived but was better once we ordered our food. They do offer outdoor seating but we opted for indoors because it was a cooler day outside.
Anatoliy Prykhodko
This is unique and absolutely one of the best pizza we ever had. We are pizza lovers, and like to taste pizza in places like this, not chains like. They obviously use high quality cheese for pizzas. We definitely recommend this place.
The service was excellent, however the pizza was pretty awful. They did offer a GF and vegan pizzas but the pizza sauce, especially, needs work.
Scott M.
Tried to order some food to go. Went to thier website and the online ordering system doesn't work, so I called.... 7 times... no answer. Walked across the street to order in person and there was 4 people standing around not busy ( 3pm on a Thursday ) Waited 15 minutes for my order and got home with burnt food. Not a good look at all
Mike Canzoneri
Very cool rooftop seating. The pizza was 7/10, so not too bad for the area with good service.
Debbie P.
Best Chicago style deep dish pizza I have had since I was in Chicago! Amazing crust and toppings too! I will be back!
Curt Schmidt
Great tasting pizza, the Mac and cheese (FatMac) was perfect. Between 2 pm and 5 pm is happy hour with great prices on drinks and apps. Service was friendly and food was brought to the table quickly.
After arriving in the Fairhaven District, the first restaurant we came upon that allowed dogs in their outside seating area was Fat Pie Pizza. We were seated immediately for lunch at a table right in front of the restaurant (great for people watching). Our server was super friendly and attentive, and took our order quickly. I wanted to try one of their pizzas, but there was no way I could eat a whole pie by myself (my wife didn't want pizza for her meal). We ended up getting mac and cheese for my wife and chicken parmesan for me, both of which were very good. Our receipt had a 15% discount at Acme Ice Cream (just next door) valid only today. Of course, we couldn't let that discount go to waste! I can definitely recommend this pizza joint if you're in the area.
My bison burger was burned to a crisp, way over well done and when I mentioned this to the waiter he got all weird and sarcastic, the rest of my party got pizza which tasted like it was previously frozen, literally a costco pizza is better. My guess is that they are having a hard time finding good staff so they have resorted to hiring random untrained forest animals such as crows and squirrels to cook the food and the waiters are all bitter because they wish they were at home making Tik Tok videos. We will not be going back. Save yourself and go get some good pizza at Mambo Italiano or La Fiamma, if you want a better burger go anywhere but here. As far as worse restaurants in Bellingham go there is a new heavy hitter in town and its Fat Pie Pizza!
We ordered one Chicago pizza, ome Brooklyn Pizza and one large salad to go. When we got there our pizzas were ready, but no salad. We were told they were working on it. After 10 minutes, we asked again and they said, "oh, yeah." And asked for someone to make it. Finally a staff showed up with a salad and asked the hostess...does this look right? I've never made one. We got our order, had to ask for forks and napkins (they gave us 2 napkins for 2 pizzas.) Also, when we left with the food, we never heard a Thank you, or sorry for the delay, just...."Have a good one,". Really? I can't stand to not be thanked for patronizing a store. When we got back to our hotel, we opened the Chicago pizza to find it HAD NOT BEEN CUT! Also, it was totally inedible...absolutely drenched in red sauce. It was an expensive disappointment. The salad was adequate and the Brooklyn pizza was good. But the service was just inexcusable and we will not be going back.
I was excited to try this small business when I was in Fairhaven, but I was disappointed. I got just a simple cheese Detroit style. While it smelled really good, it lacked flavor. The crust reminds me of Pizza Hut Pan Pizza. You know that super oily almost burnt on the outside crust. There was very minimal sauce to the point I couldn't even really taste or see it. The cheese, was cheese. Overall, it lacked flavor and was just kinda boring.
absolutely best pizza ( and I don't like pizza ) ever eaten. The tomato basil soup and spinach salad delicious! Just wish we had discovered it earlier...
Ok so this is the second time we've tired this place and it's just not worth it!! Much better places to spend our money. To be clear great service from the front staff!! But the kitchen not so good! The food was gross the chicken pram was a microwaved piece of chicken with canned sauce over it zero flavor. The bread was old and nasty, I guess it was to soak up the water in my bowl from the spaghetti noodles they didn't drain.. The Mac and cheese was ok not much on flavor took it home and flavored it up. We also ordered a meatball sub got a parm sub than waited to get the right sub. When the right one came, yeah microwaved meatballs with canned sauce.. If I wanted that I'd make it at home!!Absolute waste of money!!
very good, great staff...
Really great food. Love this place. Ironically I've never had their pizza but their salads and sandwiches are amazing. Nice to sit outside on a sunny day.
Our teenage son hadn’t eaten here yet since moving to Bellingham so we brought him here to try it. We ordered a Chicago style pizza- I believe it was the Uno - meat only, Fat Mac and a side salad. The salad came first and it was absolutely delicious. They use the good greens, onions, cherry tomatoes, carrots and Parmesan cheese. The Fat Mac was good as well. It’s topped with bacon and breadcrumbs. There are some other restaurants in Bellingham with amazing Mac n cheese so we wanted to compare. We didn’t think this was as good but we were not disappointed either. The pizza was so good and our son absolutely loved it. I prefer veggies on my pizza but our son loves meat and cheese pizzas. The service was slow when we arrived but was better once we ordered our food. They do offer outdoor seating but we opted for indoors because it was a cooler day outside.
This is unique and absolutely one of the best pizza we ever had. We are pizza lovers, and like to taste pizza in places like this, not chains like. They obviously use high quality cheese for pizzas. We definitely recommend this place.
Restaurantji Recommends
The service was excellent, however the pizza was pretty awful. They did offer a GF and vegan pizzas but the pizza sauce, especially, needs work.
Tried to order some food to go. Went to thier website and the online ordering system doesn't work, so I called.... 7 times... no answer. Walked across the street to order in person and there was 4 people standing around not busy ( 3pm on a Thursday ) Waited 15 minutes for my order and got home with burnt food. Not a good look at all
Very cool rooftop seating. The pizza was 7/10, so not too bad for the area with good service.
Best Chicago style deep dish pizza I have had since I was in Chicago! Amazing crust and toppings too! I will be back!
Great tasting pizza, the Mac and cheese (FatMac) was perfect. Between 2 pm and 5 pm is happy hour with great prices on drinks and apps. Service was friendly and food was brought to the table quickly.