The Craftsman American Tavern

We went there with a group of 10 couples. They were very rude and said they could not accommodate us. The restaurant was empty at the time. The waitress was very nice and tried to help, but the manager told us to go elsewhere.

Wonderful service, wonderful food.
Love all the different beer selections and samplers. Food was totally awesome!

Parking: There is a free parking lot on North side of building. During peak season it fills fast and you will probably need to find street parking.

Kid-friendliness: Very kind friendly. However wait can get long during peak summer days.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Tipsy Pig, The Craftsman 2 0, Tater Tots

Such a great spot for supper! We popped in on a later Friday afternoon. Everything was amazing. They did say they were understaffed and getting a table might take a minute, we didn’t mind, we were just happy to be there! All of the design and decor added to a welcoming and rustic atmosphere. Once we got seated, it didn’t take more than 5 minutes, we had drinks right away. I had the love, Stella. It was super smooth. The cheese curds with the raspberry sauce was amazing. For supper we both had burgers! Everything was great! Our server was Brittney and she was so kind! I would 100% recommend anybody to go here and grab a bite to eat!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: The 1848, Amber Ale Cheese Curds

Outstanding lunch. Modern-vibe lunch spot in the heart of Eagle River. Stopped in here based on the good reviews and we weren't disappointed. From the top notch cocktails to the fresh ingredients in the food, this place knocked it out of the park. Plump, juicy burgers and loaded sandwiches, not to mention the largest portion of cheese curds I've ever seen as an appetizer! Excellent service, friendly and attentive but not overbearing. Even a proper shuffleboard available for a bit of fun. Would definitely recommend eating here if you're in town.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We got there on a Friday, right when they opened at 11:00. I was thankful, because the place filled up quickly. The decor is cool but it was very loud and hard to hear and have a conversation over lunch.

Great craft (strong) cocktails.

There were 3 in our group. Everything was delicious and flavorful! The only downside was the cost ... We had a gluten free burger with chips, the Friday fish fry with coleslaw and tater tots, The tacos with a side salad, 3 waters and 1 drink. Our bill was $76 (plus tip! ) Granted -everything tasted great, but I'm my opinion, it was a lot for lunch.

There was a ping pong table, a pool table, and a shuffle board to keep busy while you were waiting for your food.

Lots of street parking. The bathrooms were clean ( and beautiful).

Dietary restrictions: The gluten-free options are clearly marked on the menu and they were very knowledgeable. Dedicated fryer. The cups and tater tots were also gluten free.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

We had a hamberger with prime rib on it ( craftsman 2.0) it was the best Berger we have ever had; would highly recommend this restaurant ❤️❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We had a great time, and always do whenever we frequent TCAT. Beautiful on the inside, a true work of craftsmanship (pun intended). The staff is more than hospitable and have always been since our first time visiting a few years back. As locals, we appreciate a family friendly establishment. How refreshing to see the owners behind the bar?! 10/10 every time. The restaurant is blessed to have a great front house member, Danny, who goes above and beyond to make our dine-in experience incredible. My daughter requested Parmesan cheese for her pizza and he went back into the kitchen and grated it himself!!! Phenomenal. The bar staff are very talented as well. As someone who does not drink alcohol Tony and Andrew have always been willing to whip up NA drinks. Again, how refreshing. I employee anyone local or visiting the area to check this place out.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

There a so many things to say about this place Im not sure where to start. Right out of the gate... Free pool, darts, and ping pong. My gosh, what a joy. Drinks are pretty pricey but, it is a beautiful bar. Check it out. You be the judge.

We love coming to this place. Kid-friendly, great service, excellent food and cocktails (gf options).

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nicest spot in Eagle River but subpar service and food. Had a great espresso martini (their “vodka espresso”) the first time I visited, but they were out of espresso the next 3 times I visited. Not the best waitress but the male bartender with a beard wa phenomenal. Has great potential but only gets customers because of their nicer vibe/atmosphere - it’s one of the only nicer/classier establishments in the area and it seems like the servers know this so they don’t try as hard or seem to care.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 3

Food was fantastic! Service was thorough and efficient. Great with food allergies.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Everything way expensive, the cook has no idea. Drinks, well you need 2 jobs to eat here.

A win all the way around. Indoor and outdoor seating option was great. We had lunch and there was a great selection of burgers, salads and flat breads.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Checked in with the front and was told there would be an hour and a half wait, so we thanked them and came back the next day. Service was as quick as possible, under the circumstances, and the drinks were excellent. Food was decent and the atmosphere was interesting. Kind of felt like being in a steam punk version of Old Yankee Workshop. Would definitely go there again.

Kid-friendliness: Mocktails and shuffleboard.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Grilled Chicken Sandwich, Flatbread Pizza

Amazing experience on Saturday with some girlfriends. We had the loaded tots, pork belly bites, turkey melt, fig and prosciutto flatbread and the original smash burger. Presentation was amazing, the food was so delicious and our cocktails were great as well. Highly recommend the outdoor patio as it has great ambience. Can’t wait to go back!