This is the best pizza there is in the entire country. It's the first pizza I've tasted in my life and I love it. I wish I lived closer to one of these chains. It's unfortunate that it's so far away but I will get some pizza again soon. Very soon. Probably within a week. Not this location though maybe the one in Stoughton. Yes there's one in Stoughton, isn't that awesome!!! I love it! It so great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
kasey ramsey
Very terrible customer service. was thrown on hold for asking about a coupon. Then they HUNG UP on me when i tried to get the advertised coupon, which turns out was incorrect. TERRIBLE SERVICE. Workers name was Nick Johnson. He should be fired.
Thomas Waller
Chicago style stuffed Deluxe Combo was fantastic. Packed full of ingredients. I'm a big eater, but the two of us ordered a medium and took 3 pieces home!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Jim Ross
Been a many years since we had stuffed pizza from Pizza Extreme but it was as good as I remember. Flaky buttery crust, great fresh tasting sauce and lots of cheese. Will not wait so long to try again.
Tricia C.
Despite the fact that I have been a (practically) life-long Madisonian, this was my first time trying Pizza Pit Extreme. I really enjoyed the pizza! The sauce is delicious, and definitely worth writing home about. We devoured the garlic breadsticks, and I may have had to fight my son over the last one! :) We will definitely be adding Pizza Pit Extreme to our rotation.
JOHN THOMAS
This was the worst pizza.No stars providedDried-up and nasty, throughaway
Julie G-G
Yummy Choc Chip cookie!Also had a 10" hand tossed Hawaiian pizza. Yum.Next time I'm trying the gyros.
Jeffery McGregor
2 Guros, 1 fry, garlic bread and two cans of op $40.. They are painfully slow and disorganized. Got the order wrong. They pulled the gyro meat out of the fridge not cut of the spit as they say. I’d pass
Scott Martin
I ordered a cheese pizza with bacon on it. It was the worst pizza I’ve ever had in my entire life. The entire cheese/bacon slid off the entire slice of dough from lifting it up. I’ve never seen that in my life. The bite I took of the fallen cheese was nasty. The bite I took of the dough was unpleasant. I am over 300 pounds and I threw away this pizza that I ordered. I’ve eaten plenty of pizza throughout the states. I thought back on every single slice and style of pizza I’ve had in my years, and this was the worst. NY style, New Haven style, Greek, Brick Oven, Frozen, English muffin, cold late delivery pizza, Lunchables, etc. are all much better pies.
Coleen Shaw
Do not get the gyros. They were extremely dry and not fresh. Our 10 minute wait was 50+ minutes due to how busy they were. Gyros came out without sauce, but they remedied that quickly. Gyro meat tasted almost freezer burned. Very disappointed. The staff was friendly, which is why I gave it a 2 star review.
Fantastic food and fast staff. Very inviting and professional. The food was fantastic! Thank you! These men need a raise!
Brandi
We went here after a field trip with our students. Only one person was working and not a lot of options. We could only get slices of pizza. The guy was super nice. No complaints about the pizza. If you need a job they're hiring!
Business First
Called around 5:00 for a simple pizza delivery.Scheduled arrival between 30 min to an hour.I call to check after an hour had passed, the guy tells me 15 more minutes. Another 15 minutes after the 15 minutes he tells me and I get a call for the delivery. Didn’t even bother to answer the phone. That much time passing with strangers handling my food gives me the creeps. Keep it.Terrible service. Slow and nonchalant.Do a pick up if anything.
Arthur Hjertstedt
Probably the best pizza you could get for the cost. Rugular pizzas are good and the deep dish is the best thing ever. It works well for a pizza place by the university.
Paul Kim
I had ordered a gyro plate and I had to throw everything out. You guys might want to taste the food before sending it out. It was dry, freezer burned, and bitter.
This is the best pizza there is in the entire country. It's the first pizza I've tasted in my life and I love it. I wish I lived closer to one of these chains. It's unfortunate that it's so far away but I will get some pizza again soon. Very soon. Probably within a week. Not this location though maybe the one in Stoughton. Yes there's one in Stoughton, isn't that awesome!!! I love it! It so great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very terrible customer service. was thrown on hold for asking about a coupon. Then they HUNG UP on me when i tried to get the advertised coupon, which turns out was incorrect. TERRIBLE SERVICE. Workers name was Nick Johnson. He should be fired.
Chicago style stuffed Deluxe Combo was fantastic. Packed full of ingredients. I'm a big eater, but the two of us ordered a medium and took 3 pieces home!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Been a many years since we had stuffed pizza from Pizza Extreme but it was as good as I remember. Flaky buttery crust, great fresh tasting sauce and lots of cheese. Will not wait so long to try again.
Despite the fact that I have been a (practically) life-long Madisonian, this was my first time trying Pizza Pit Extreme. I really enjoyed the pizza! The sauce is delicious, and definitely worth writing home about. We devoured the garlic breadsticks, and I may have had to fight my son over the last one! :) We will definitely be adding Pizza Pit Extreme to our rotation.
This was the worst pizza.No stars providedDried-up and nasty, throughaway
Yummy Choc Chip cookie!Also had a 10" hand tossed Hawaiian pizza. Yum.Next time I'm trying the gyros.
2 Guros, 1 fry, garlic bread and two cans of op $40.. They are painfully slow and disorganized. Got the order wrong. They pulled the gyro meat out of the fridge not cut of the spit as they say. I’d pass
I ordered a cheese pizza with bacon on it. It was the worst pizza I’ve ever had in my entire life. The entire cheese/bacon slid off the entire slice of dough from lifting it up. I’ve never seen that in my life. The bite I took of the fallen cheese was nasty. The bite I took of the dough was unpleasant. I am over 300 pounds and I threw away this pizza that I ordered. I’ve eaten plenty of pizza throughout the states. I thought back on every single slice and style of pizza I’ve had in my years, and this was the worst. NY style, New Haven style, Greek, Brick Oven, Frozen, English muffin, cold late delivery pizza, Lunchables, etc. are all much better pies.
Do not get the gyros. They were extremely dry and not fresh. Our 10 minute wait was 50+ minutes due to how busy they were. Gyros came out without sauce, but they remedied that quickly. Gyro meat tasted almost freezer burned. Very disappointed. The staff was friendly, which is why I gave it a 2 star review.
Restaurantji Recommends
Fantastic food and fast staff. Very inviting and professional. The food was fantastic! Thank you! These men need a raise!
We went here after a field trip with our students. Only one person was working and not a lot of options. We could only get slices of pizza. The guy was super nice. No complaints about the pizza. If you need a job they're hiring!
Called around 5:00 for a simple pizza delivery.Scheduled arrival between 30 min to an hour.I call to check after an hour had passed, the guy tells me 15 more minutes. Another 15 minutes after the 15 minutes he tells me and I get a call for the delivery. Didn’t even bother to answer the phone. That much time passing with strangers handling my food gives me the creeps. Keep it.Terrible service. Slow and nonchalant.Do a pick up if anything.
Probably the best pizza you could get for the cost. Rugular pizzas are good and the deep dish is the best thing ever. It works well for a pizza place by the university.
I had ordered a gyro plate and I had to throw everything out. You guys might want to taste the food before sending it out. It was dry, freezer burned, and bitter.