9 Best Pizza Restaurants in Middletown

Avella's Italian take out Italian • $
232 William St, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Old School Sicillian Pizza Pie
Broccoli Rabe & Sausage
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Brocc Rabe & Sausage
Chocalate Chip Cookie
Chicken Italiano
Antipasto Salad
Chicken Cutlet
Dr Melfi Salad
Potato Wedges

“Sal worked with us for my grandsons baptism party. The roast beef was tender and flavorful. Lemon chicken was amazing. Roasted vegetables with hot peppers, WOW! Roasted potatoes, fantastic! Portions are more than expected. Sal is wonderful to work with and you will not be disappointed with the food“

4.8 Superb91 Reviews
2

Mondo

Mondo Pizza • $
10 Main St, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Prosciutto & Arugula Pizza
Traditional Thin Crust
Truffle Honey Pizza
Half Portion Salad
Med Veggie Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Eggplant Fries
Chicken Pesto
Caesar Salad
Mondo Special

“Mondo is the best! I've never had anything there I didn't like! :)“

4.3 Superb141 Reviews
Agapi Med & Pizza Pizza • $
455 E Main St, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Mushroom Pappardelle
Spicy Vegan Pizza
Falafel Wrap
Baklava
Fries
Gyro

“This restaurant opened in a place that had been a happening pizza place, Mario's. After a brief shut down Agapi opened. Their food is such a higher caliber of good! I don't understand why it's not busier. The quality, taste and price are fantastic. We've tried their pizza's, burgers and traditional Greek dishes and will try even more things! Please give it a try.“

4.4 Superb52 Reviews
Illiano's Ristorante and Pizzeria Pizza • $
534 Washington St, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Make Your Own Pasta with Fresh Mozzarella and Meatballs
Make Your Own Pasta with Pesto and Sausage
Chicken Parm Sandwich
Sausage Parm Pizza
Buffalo Chicken
Eggplant Parm
Brócoli Pizza
Grandma Slice
Garlic Rolls
Garlic Bread

“Such good food!! My son and I really enjoyed our pizza! He got pepperoni, and my tastebuds were immensely pleased to have the flavors of the Buffalo chicken AND Mac and cheese pizza dancing around. Absolutely delicious mixture.“

4.3 Superb56 Reviews
Jon's Restaurant Italian • $
825 Saybrook Rd, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Veal Parmigiana Grinder
Chicken Caesar
Italian Combo
Greek Chicken
Small Cheese
Greek Salad
Pizza
Rolls

“Greeted so pleasantly the second we walked in. Seated right away. Delicious garlic knots! Amazing service from start to finish. We got a salad and a wrap, and it was just what we were craving! Finished up with some tea/coffee and cheesecake. Overall really wonderful experience, will definitely be returning!“

4.3 Superb52 Reviews
6

krust

krust Pizza • $$
686 Main St, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Sausage and Marinara
Brussels Pizza
Chicken Wings
Nutella Pizza
Arugula Salad
White Pizza
Smoked Pizza
Brussels
Red Pie

“Can happily recommend almost anything on the menu. I loved the smoked olives the most. Loved the white smoked pizza. Creative and tasty offerings. They say there is a time limit on how long you can be at your table when you make a reservation but we never felt rushed. Fun atmosphere. Big shout out to chef Mike. Try this place. You'll love it.“

4.2 Good88 Reviews
Pizza Palace Middletown Pizza • $
725 S Main St, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

One Topping Pizza
Mozzarella Pizza
Meatballs
Three

“Great food“

4.3 Superb40 Reviews
Sicily Coal Fired Pizza Pizza •
412 Main St, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza with Shrimp
Penne Vodka with Grilled Chicken
Bacon and Black Olive Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Fried Mozzarella
Chicken Parmesan
Eggplant Frites
Whipped Ricotta
Bread Appetizer
Eggplant Stack

“Absolute amazing Pizza and atmosphere“

4.1 Good141 Reviews
Mazzotta's Bakery & Catering Bakery • $
506 Ballfall Rd, Middletown

“Ordered a cheese cake for my vet/staff for Christmas in appreciation for all they do for me and my furkids and Marie did an amazing job from making the cheesecake, decorating it and also went out of her way to deliver it. They all loved it and I was pleasantly surprised on how cute the cheesecake was decorated with a cute pawprint and holiday festive decos on the side. My vet/staff said it was delicious and they all enjoyed it. Thanks Marie for making their day a little sweeter!!!!!“

4.5 Superb11 Reviews