7 Best Pizza Restaurants in Newburgh

“Awesome pizza! Great price, fast and friendly service.“

“We have Fat Boys at least once a week. Tuesday sandwiches can not be beat! My guy look forward to his ham & cheese, that otherwise would be a no no, I love the Fat Boy. We had a very minor mishap on our order tonight & without question that made it right! Great owner & great team of employees“

“Great place to go and have a bite to eat before hitting the cinema or the arcade. The restaurant area has many choices. The fish and chips, burgers and pizza are all really good. The food comes out fast, and the the service is great. The arcade has many options to choose from for all age groups, all the way to virtual reality games. Don't forget about the bowling alley.“

“Let me start off by saying I've never had any bad experiences with this location. The last time I ordered there was a mix up and I was delivered the wrong pizza, stuff happens, the pizza was hot so that was no issue at all. I absolutely hate complaining or saying negative things like this but tonight I ordered a pizza for me and my son because it's friday, I'm a working mom and I'm feeling lazy. The pizza was hot and delicious, I ordered a cheese with extra pineapple. It's my sons favorite and I don't really like meat so it's a nice texture change. I bit into whatever this was. I kept chewing but it wasn't breaking apart. I spit it out and looked at it and i was like oh this is just cheese...but why is it so chewy??? I'm a little worried now and hope this wasn't something not meant for consumption. 4 stars because I don't want to be a j*** about this. Things happen, but i am a little concerned as I can't identify what this is.“

“Ordered Godfathers pizza over the phone and when I got to the store they had part of the order wrong. It was all good though because Makayla, Jason, the manager and the rest of the staff were amazing. They rectified the situation quickly and were apologetic the whole time. I wasn't upset about the miscommunication at all but this crew is really on top of things. Great customer service all around. I love coming here and I'll definitely be back.“

“Been here a few times and it's a very casual environment. The employees treat you like family! Last night, my husband brought home the Supreme Pizza and OMGSH it is definitely in my top list of favorites!!! Sooo delicious ?. If you haven't tried it yet, you're missing out! Absolutely delicious! Loaded with toppings and a lot of delicious mozzarella cheese!!!“

“Great little local bar and restaurant!Very friendly and helpful staff!Great food with pastas, pizzas, sandwiches and soup and home style meals like country fried steak and meatloaf.To be completely honest, the front of the house seating is a little open and cold and there's a front seating section of like six booths that has walls around it and it feels like you're in an office building, it's kind of weird but, all the action and all the great service is in the bar of the restaurant.Parking: Very large parking lot.“