12 Best Italian Restaurants in Cary

“La Grassa was a very pleasant surprise during my first visit. It won’t be my last! The food was SO delicious! We tried the rigatoni, risotto and fish dinner. All the flavors were excellent! And the fococcia bread was a perfect compliment to the rest of the meal. The atmosphere is lovely and the service was wonderful. We will be back soon!“

“My wife and I had our wedding rehearsal dinner there and was able to have our one year anniversary dinner there yesterday evening. Good food good service“

“We love Salvio’s, but I’m so sad that with the new online ordering system there is no option for roni cups except for on a specialty square pizza. Please add roni cups back to the build your own pizza ☹️ High quality pizza, delicious!“

“If you’re looking for an incredible experience with just as incredible food, Johnny’s is the place to go. As a person who has to eat gluten free, the establishment was able to safely offer options that are typically hard to find. Tony was a delight and informed us of the protocols in place to make sure I could eat. Thank you for taking celiac/gluten intolerant folks into consideration and offering the ability to eat wonderful pizza, subs, and more without fear.“

“Visiting from Buffalo NY with my cousin Beth and I must say the food and service was outstanding! I ordered the homemade pasta with a red cream sauce which was to die for. Even the bread is unbelievably delicious! All 4 of us loved the entire evening of delicious food and wonderful service. I wish Buffalo offered such fabulous food and experience!!!“

“Great experience! Atmosphere, food, and service were superb! Our server, Hudson was phenomenal and made our evening absolutely perfect for my husband’s birthday dinner!“

“This place is amazing! Erin served us, and she was friendly and helpful. I got french onion & minestrone soup, a crepe, and the chocolate espresso mousse; all of it was incredible. Absolutely recommend.Dietary restrictions: Gluten & Dairy Free options“

“Brothers is one our favorite Pizza places around. We have to travel a little distance to get there or would go more often. Pizza and garlic knots are consistently good. Whether it's plain cheese or add your favorite toppings, always delicious.Some if the closest to NY we've had since moving here“

“I love Jet's and Detroit style pizza! It's the most similar that I have found to Buffalo style pizza, which I have accepted is pretty much impossible to find outside of western NY. My go-to is the 4 or 8 corner pizza, and it's always delicious!“

“Absolutely amazing food and service! The presentation was over the top. Emma was our sever. She was so patient with our two grandsons and answered all our questions about the menu. Chef Jharell came out to say hello to us. He is a true artis“

“This is definitely the best pizza in Cary. I left a review a while ago and I'm coming back to let everyone know this pizzeria has only gotten better. I grew up in NJ, outside of NYC, and their pizza is exactly what you'd get there. Get a large pie and ask em to use a medium dough for that extra thinny thin crust- oooh la la! Get a slice in there and you'll be transported to north jersey. Salads are mid, lettuce is fresh. Cannolies are BUSSIN! So good! So fresh! Calzones are great! Wish they had mozz sticks. Buff wings are okay.Everyone that works there is awesome. Eugene is my favorite person in the world outside of my family. Love you guys!“

“I grew up eating at Olive Garden and loved it. I was skeptical to go back after a few poor experiences .my boyfriend and I went and our waitress Mikelle was phenomenal, she was pleasant accurate and checked in perfectly without being annoying . The food was great- he got carbonara , I got the five cheese ziti. The salad was just as I remembered delicious. Thank you Mikelle , many of our experiences have been poor, you made me the experience better“