24 Best Pizza Restaurants in Cary

“Great Food. Excellent Host.“

“Great experience! Atmosphere, food, and service were superb! Our server, Hudson was phenomenal and made our evening absolutely perfect for my husband’s birthday dinner!“

“Food was awesome ! Had the hawian wings delish! Pizza was thin and crispy just the way I like it! Great staff!“

“We love Salvio’s, but I’m so sad that with the new online ordering system there is no option for roni cups except for on a specialty square pizza. Please add roni cups back to the build your own pizza ☹️ High quality pizza, delicious!“

“If you’re looking for an incredible experience with just as incredible food, Johnny’s is the place to go. As a person who has to eat gluten free, the establishment was able to safely offer options that are typically hard to find. Tony was a delight and informed us of the protocols in place to make sure I could eat. Thank you for taking celiac/gluten intolerant folks into consideration and offering the ability to eat wonderful pizza, subs, and more without fear.“

“The pizza is delicious and coming from NJ, I know good pizza. I grew up eating NY style pizza and the pizza here is a very close second and a nice small friendly place to take your family for a quick bite to eat during the week when you can’t decide what to cook at home.“

“The food was great! The atmosphere was comfortable, casual and fun! The service was incredibly friendly and made the entire experience even better than we expected! We really enjoyed ourselves! The "slice" is huge! The quesadilla was outstanding and the giant basket of onion rings were crispy and delicious!“

“Bar none, the best pizza in RTP. On the off chance that you already ate pizza this week, try the lunch sandwiches. Or, just stop by for a drink: the limited edition Sakura Machino Vermouth merits taking home a few bottles.Vegetarian options: Vegetarian sandwiches and pizzas available“

“Great beer and liquor options, too.“

“Brothers is one our favorite Pizza places around. We have to travel a little distance to get there or would go more often. Pizza and garlic knots are consistently good. Whether it's plain cheese or add your favorite toppings, always delicious.Some if the closest to NY we've had since moving here“

“I love Jet's and Detroit style pizza! It's the most similar that I have found to Buffalo style pizza, which I have accepted is pretty much impossible to find outside of western NY. My go-to is the 4 or 8 corner pizza, and it's always delicious!“

“I enjoyed Romeo’s pizza, I got the eight boneless wings and a medium meatball pizza last Friday. While many reviews seem to say the sauce is sweet, I actually enjoyed it and think it’s better than many other places however that’s my preference. Of course it’s up to your own opinion. Customer service is pretty good, I definitely could tell at the moment they’re short staffed but they make it up for it ensuring when you’re able to get your food it’s what exactly you paid for. Ultimately if you’re interested in ordering from here I would try it out and then see how you like it.“

“Great beer and liquor options, too.“

“My son is an extremely picky eater and we usually pick "safe" places to eat but NY style pizza can be hit or miss because of the size of the slice; a wonderful gentleman cut my son's pizza into smaller bite-sized pieces ?They also have some of the BEST stuffed pizza I've ever had ?“

“Me and my family visited this location for the first time this past weekend and the customer service here was great! Our servers made sure to constantly refill our drinks and also ask if we needed anything. All of our food came out fresh and hot.“

“This is definitely the best pizza in Cary. I left a review a while ago and I'm coming back to let everyone know this pizzeria has only gotten better. I grew up in NJ, outside of NYC, and their pizza is exactly what you'd get there. Get a large pie and ask em to use a medium dough for that extra thinny thin crust- oooh la la! Get a slice in there and you'll be transported to north jersey. Salads are mid, lettuce is fresh. Cannolies are BUSSIN! So good! So fresh! Calzones are great! Wish they had mozz sticks. Buff wings are okay.Everyone that works there is awesome. Eugene is my favorite person in the world outside of my family. Love you guys!“

“Absolutely amazing food and service! The presentation was over the top. Emma was our sever. She was so patient with our two grandsons and answered all our questions about the menu. Chef Jharell came out to say hello to us. He is a true artis“

“Incredible service and PERFECT pizza! Not to mention, the owner was one of the nicest people I've ever met. My husband and son just had a cheese pizza and I had no idea something so simple could be so delicious. From the homemade sauce to the perfect seasoning and even the tasty crust, this pizza has it all. Fully recommended and we will certainly be back.“

“I had a wonderful experience this evening and had to share! I called less than 10 minutes before close expecting to be told it was too late to put in a pick up order, but they were happy to accommodate me. When I arrived 2 minutes before close, everyone was so kind and didn’t make me feel any kind of way. I know it’s been a hard hiring climate for businesses lately, and I just need to give a big round of applause for the quality of employees who served me this evening!! Thanks for my delicious pizza!!“

“Cici used to be everywhere. Not sure why there are few and far between now, but this place was extremely budget friendly for me in college. My go to now is this one in Cary, Smithfield, Burlington, and Colonial Heights. My old suite mate at UNC used to manage this one. The food hasn't changed, my kid loves the arcade. Any type of pizza you want here. The buffet is managed well. I wished the salad bar had bacos, but to be able to get a salad, soup, pizza, brownies, spaghetti, dessert pizza, and drinks, for my family at less than $35 is a family friendly budget. The store is usually clean. It's in a great location, Don't see what you want, ask! They are more than happy to make it, but try some of the off the beaten path creations. You'll find you like some more than you thought. Music can be a bit loud at times. The arcade is nice because my kid can go play games while my wife and I finish eating. Don't feel like a buffet? Then order A la carte. They've got wings and other options not on the buffet. Restrooms are clean. Although they've asked customers to bus there own table. At the price point, that's cool. So go support this restaurant and enjoy good pizza. The chicken noodle soup is amazing!Vegetarian options: It has a complete salad bar.“

“Extremely friendly staff, everyone was great to deal with and so helpful. Will definitely return! Pizza and wings were amazing.“

“First time to visit this restaurant. The counter services offers a variety as well as make it yourself options. I chose vegetarian with a balsamic glaze. The choices were all fresh and enticing. The chief had excellent customer skills and helpful suggestions. The pizza is cooked in a wood fired oven. It is an excellent meal.“

“DiFara Pizza Tavern is a true standout! The owners are incredibly accommodating and have a heart for the community, especially rescue dogs. Not only is their dedication heartwarming, but their pizza is out of this world. The flavors are a masterpiece (especially if you get a pie with calabrian chilis!), and the staff is friendly and welcoming.“

“Edit: Things have improved a lot now. Blaze continues (Holly Springs) to suck as usualI and family are a regular here and prefer over Blaze but lately they seem to be running out of toppings frequently. Can't enjoy a pizza when your favorite toppings are missing. Will probably move back to blaze.At least we get what we want.“