21 Best Pizza Restaurants in Elizabeth

“I had to come to a chicken shack when I got to Jersey, IYKYK. I read all the reviews about how good the pizza and chicken were and I had to try because it was close to my hotel plus they are open 24 hours. The cheese pizza was DELICIOUS. the cheese was sliding off with a nice crisp crust, just how I love it. The fried chicken was EVEN BETTER. Just fried to perfection. With perfectly seasoned French fries. Mannnnnn, oh man. It took about 10 minutes, there were tables inside. They all had soda, juice and ice cream for order. You have different options for pizza and chicken options.“

“Stumbled upon this place with my girls on a long layover in EWR. Ambience in the family run joint is perfect. I got to know the history going back to Naples It. Food is outstanding and enough can't be said about the value. a must do while in EWR.“

“excellent food and hospitality“

“I love the service they are very nice. I’m really thankful that is a an open kitchen bc you can see your order being made. And a clean place.Parking: Plenty of spaceKid-friendliness: They are very friendly with kids, kids love them. After school is a marathon at Bruno’s.“

“Great food and a variety of options.“

“Great place for luch“

“Best pizza in Elizabeth New Jersey“

“Menu at hotel states free delivery. DO NOT SCAN THE QRC FOR SLICE. Using slice will add another 8 dollars for the delivery despite claiming to save you 5 percent. Sandwich was very good. Pizza arrived cold so I sent it back. Was promised a replacement. Will opt for pick up tomorrow and edit review if needed.Dropped by store in person to dine. Reception was friendly and pleasant. Highly recommend. Kitchen is clean and open viewing.“

“I’m from Uruguay so stopping by here for pizza and faina is always amazing ? they also have some other great dishes too !!Worth the trip ? BTW, if you don't know what faina (chickpea flour bread) go and try it... your pizza life will never be the same!“

“Ratings were spot on, which is why I wanted to try this pizzeria. 5 stars in my book!“

“One of the best restaurants in Elizabeth! Would go nowhere else but here to get the finest Venezuelan cuisine and pizzas. Endearing and extremely friendly owners and staff, always ready to welcome and prepare fresh and hot food. If I could put 10 stars, I would.“

“My family and I goto Bellas at LEAST 5x a month. At least. I would definetly recommend their garlic knots and homemade marinara sauce!! so delicious! always fresh! my favorite speciality slice is the spinach, chicken, Alfredo speciality slice!!!! definetly worth it!!!!!! best in Elizabeth! owner and staff are super friendly too! :)“

“While working in the area, went to Elizabeth pizza for a pie. It's probably been 25 years since I was here last, and I guess the old man owner from that time has passed. Restaurant was clean, worker was polite and even ran out with the 2 soda's I forgot. Pizza was good, 5 stars !!!“

“Amazing authentic NY pizza. The owner Edgar is super nice and I really enjoyed talking with him. After trying several pizza places over the years when in town, this place has been the best. Taking pizza back home to everyone, they are going to love it!“

“came from mi. pizza and spaghetti was great. the sauce was what I really liked. flavorful.“

“Great food friendly atmosphere. Service is catered to the culture so it's not set up for in and out dinning. Service is purposefully a little slower so you can enjoy the company your with and enjoy your meal. You will not feel rushed which is nice.“

“I order pizza yesterday. The first time I try pizza from Jerusalem Restaurant. The Vegetables pizza is delicious ! It's smells so good and tastes yummy. I'm going today to pick up another one. congratulations !“

“Wow. This is what I call great pizza. I've been meaning to order from this pizza shop for a while now but I always forget they're only open on Friday's, Saturday's, and Sunday's. I got the 1957 which is a thin crust. I got it light golden, which is 7 minutes and probably a minute too long for thin pizza (but that's my fault for not knowing). I added sesame seeds to the crust and chicken, mushrooms, and truffle Parmesan as toppings. The pizza was indeed thin and delicious. I also ordered the Sicilian, also light golden and this crust was perfect. I think this is the star of the menu. I added pepperoni, mushroom and fresh garlic, and sesame on the crust and wow this was my favorite. The ingredients were so fresh and delicious. The sauce had some kind of kick to it and you can see the ingredients. The dough was soft but the edges were crispy so it was a perfect balance. This place is pricey compared to most pizza places but it is worth it. I'll definitely be back to try other varieties and items on the menu.“

“First time ordering from here and I have to say it was great I liked it , my daughter is very picky and from anywhere she only eats one slice and now she ate 2 lol , it’s very delicious . Our new pizza place !!“

“How do you turn a dreary overcast day into a bright and sunny afternoon in Newark, NJ? Chomp on a slice from Tommy’s Pizza & Restaurant in Elizabeth and smile with your mouth full. Sometimes you just know by looking at the three quarters of a pie that’s silently sitting in the window just waiting to be adopted while flashing those puppy-dog pepperoni eyes. Once we took a bite, it was 75.6125% there. But just a little sprinkle of the ol’ lost shaker of salt and…presto! Like waving a magic wand on a wedge. All the tangy pepperoni, ultra rich tomato-y sauce and stringy cheese came to life like a Pinocchio puppet that just wanted to become a real Pizza slice. Really thin crust but sturdy enough to hold the goods. Crispy, but with a fluffy and airy edge. This sucker gets a really good passing grade pre-salting, and a phenomenal gold star of excellence after a little dash of the magic crystals. Worth the trip if you have a layover at Newark. www.pizza-whore.com“

“This had to be one of the best pies I’ve ever eaten. As soon as I took the very first bite, I tasted the flavor in the pizza. The cheese, the sauce, even the toppings. We ordered their #2 special with BBQ wings, pepperoni, meatball, and plain with two sodas and while pricy, it tasted amazing and I will definitely be using this place for pizza and wings going forward!“