8 Best Pizza Restaurants in Rahway

“Today was my first visit and the pizza was amazing especially the buffalo chicken pizza. I met Alex and staff very polite. I live in old bridge but the drive was definitely worth it. I believe I found my new go to for pizza. The sitting area was clean overall a great experience.“

“The place is cute and well-decorated. We waited over 45 minutes after ordering for our food, and then the order was incorrect, so had to wait a bit longer for my full meal. Then waited a long time for the check, etc. Ended up spending about 2.5 hrs in there. I appreciated not being rushed, but I went in there extremely hungry and I am a busy medical student, so I did not anticipate spending so long in there.I will say, our server, Caesar, was stellar! very kind, charismatic, and helpful. Chatty when we wanted to chat, and left us alone when that time came, too. Great server.I forgot to take a photo of my food because I was soooooo hungry when I finally got it! Food was delicious and portion sizes were large.“

“This has become my go to place. The pizza is beyond amazing, best pizza I’ve had in New Jersey. I make lasagna completely from scratch and decided to try it from Tony’s, it was the best decision ever!!! The lasagna was so satisfying and filling. I love how big the portions are too. This is definitely the place to go to!“

“I'm a big fan of local old school corner bars and this is one. We had a group of four on a Friday evening, I recommend reservations! Place is not big, bar has about 20 seats, there are about 10 tables (mostly 2 and 4 seaters). We had meatballs, rice ball's, and two large plain pies. All was great. Pizza is definitely thin crust. If you go with a good appetite you can comfortably finish one pie yourself. If I were to give Nancy's any dings it would be the beer selection. In and outside sends the message of old school, but the taps are mostly craft, with pizza I like an old fashion pilsner. Personal preference. I will definitely be back.Parking: Pay parking garage right across the street.“

“I discovered this place one morning when driving around the parking lot of a shopping center on the way to get breakfast. It's about 5 minutes from where I live. I decided to give them a shot later that evening... and man I wish I knew about it years ago! I've been missing out! Highly recommend this spot for their Vodka Pan Pizza. The best I've had in NJ. Garlic knots are also great. This is my 4th time ordering from them and they are always on point.“

“Excellent lamb gyro meal for lunch. Friendly counter staff who took my order. It is self searing after you order. Seats/tables were OK but don’t expect spotlessly clean tables. Bathroom was clean. Good place for lunch.Parking: Next door to Quikchek so you might have to park a little bit away from Quikchek.“

“Moved to Rahway 15 yrs ago and this place was our pizza spot. Moved out 3 yrs ago and we still order from them. I will admit we do order from other pizzerias when we are in the mood for pan pizza. But none can compare. Not the cheapest but not the most expensive. Delivery guys are the best.“

“This is one of my favorite sub places in NJ I like going here because they let you customize veggie subs exactly how you want it… the older guy that works there is a little rude every time that’s only reason I didn’t give it five stars“