Food and drinks were great. We arrived at 4:30 and didn't have reservations, so we had to sit at the bar, which was pleasant. We found it odd that there were plenty of tables available during our entire visit, but we weren't able to get a table. The bar was completely filled with customers when we left. I recommend making reservations.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Custom Detroit Pizza
Daniel Ricci
Great food and a cool spot for dinner. Portions are HUGE. My wife and I order the truffle fries to start and they came out in what to me looked like a spaghetti bowl lol. They easily could have fed minimum 6 people. Pizza was great as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tara Ambrosia
One of my favorite places.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dominique Fricano
Our server suggested the Calabrian pizza... so amazing. The peppers were perfect spicy, had amazing flavor. She was so understanding on my friend and I taking longer due to catching up. It was amazing. The drinks were perfectly made as well. I'll definitely be going
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Custom Detroit Pizza
Matthew Kofahl
Pizza here is out of this world. Cocktails are also great. Out new favorite night out in Lewiston.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Custom Detroit Pizza
Melody Whyte
Bruschetta pizza to the Hungarian pepper pizza to the Detroit pepperoni pizza. I can not say enough about how good it was. Thankyou, 5 plus stars!!
Food: 5
Bob H.
Crispy chicken Caesar and pecan Brussels were so good. Had the best espresso martini with my dinner. Very excited to return here again!
kathys
Great Detroit style pizza and cocktails. Small but open dining room with history.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Custom Detroit Pizza
Kelly S.
We tried this place yesterday evening for the first time. It was wonderful! It is a beautiful restaurant, very cozy on a snowy night. We had the Detroit style cup and char pizza (I agree with previous reviewers to add extra cup and char), and the chargrilled wings. We were so happy with all of our food. My fiancé had 3.5 pieces of pizza. This is highly unusual behavior! He was so happy with the food. Madison was a great server. Friendly and just the right amount of attentive. We will definitely be back and will be recommending it to friends as well.
Came here on a whim while visiting a local friend and was REALLY pleased with the experience.The drinks... tried a few of the on-menu cocktails and invented a variant of one when they were out of their homemade fruit syrup. All drinks were OUTSTANDING with the exception of one which was heavy on lemon and light on all the rest.The truffle fries were good, but what totally blew me away was the pizza! Fresh ingredients, ample cheese, a hint of fennel noticed at the end, and ooooh that crisp cheeeesy thick edge crust. (See pic)Coupled with a lovely atmosphere...Yay!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Laura Chenault
We went for dinner and drinks. The cocktails were on point, the food was delicious and our server was charming ?
This review is not only for those who are considering checking out Hustler's in Lewiston, but also for its owner, whose own employees are undermining his efforts to remain open in a part of the village where many others have failed. i've frequented this establishment for the last time. The main reasons are two employees who may or not be playing will a full deck and could care less if paying customers return or not. The first employee, a barmaid named Brooke, may be the worst bartender in WNY. Not only is she unnecessarily aggressive and confrontational, even when she's in the wrong, but acts as if she's doing you a favor every time she serves you a drink. The time i was in with my two cousins they swore they'd never return because of the unpleasant experience. One of them said, "This bartender should be bagging groceries at Tops." Does Brooke care if my cousins never come back? Obviously not and this should concern the owner, who likely does. The second reason is the unhinged cook, who sent us home with a burnt pizza that was inedible. Of course, he knew he burned it, but he tossed it in a box anyway, not caring if we returned or not. As for me, it's not, and that should concern the owner, who has an uphill battle making it where Hustler's is located, especially when his employees behave in a such a way that makes customers not want to return. Last summer, me and my friends watched in disbelief as the crazy cook threw a temper tantrum that would have embarrassed a toddler, slamming and banging things for a good fifteen minutes. Have no idea what set him off, but he certainly was pissed. It went on for so long it became comical, like live entertainment but the bartender looked legitimately frightened. Does he care if customers return or not? Obviously not. FYI: The first time i was in Hustler's i sat at the bar for about an hour or so, working up an appetite and planning to take a pizza home. The place closes at 10pm and was mostly empty. About 15 minutes before closing about two dozen people piled into the place. There was a festival that day in the other part of the village and they were overflow from the other bars. The barmaid (young brunette, late 20s, maybe 30) obviously had made plans for the evening and quickly closed the place down, costing the owner a tidy sum. Does she care if Hustler's makes it or not? Obviously not. To the owner of Hustler's: The odds of your business succeeding in the village are against you, especially on the wrong outskirts of town. But if your employees are, consciously or not, working against you, Hustler's has little chance of lasting for very long. i hope i'm wrong and these employees are the exception rather than the rule but every time i'm in your place, one of the employees has made me not want to come back. The burnt pizza was the last straw. Consider taking a good look at your staff and definitely spend more time keeping an eye on your employees. i've not seen anyone that looks remotely like an owner or manager when i've been there and when nobody is looking over their shoulders, your staff conduct themselves as if they'd been hired by a rival restauranteur who sent them to destroy your business.
FMG Productions
Wow amazing pizza great salad definitely recommend the spicy crispy chicken Caesar salad. It was excellent. We had a Detroit style pizza and a New York style pizza with mushrooms delectable. They also have a wide range of wines to choose from. If you’re in the Lewiston area and looking for the best pizza around hustlers, Tavern is a place to be hustlers have an also has a lot of historical references so it could be a fun cool place to visit as well. If this review is helpful, feel free to tip on cash app. $Flamentco
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kelly Dragone
Loved the meat and cheese platter! Great variety and generous portion. The pizza was delicious too! Great service, comfortable seating and warm, beautiful atmosphere!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat and Cheese Board, Margarita Pizza
Food and drinks were great. We arrived at 4:30 and didn't have reservations, so we had to sit at the bar, which was pleasant. We found it odd that there were plenty of tables available during our entire visit, but we weren't able to get a table. The bar was completely filled with customers when we left. I recommend making reservations.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Custom Detroit Pizza
Great food and a cool spot for dinner. Portions are HUGE. My wife and I order the truffle fries to start and they came out in what to me looked like a spaghetti bowl lol. They easily could have fed minimum 6 people. Pizza was great as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of my favorite places.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our server suggested the Calabrian pizza... so amazing. The peppers were perfect spicy, had amazing flavor. She was so understanding on my friend and I taking longer due to catching up. It was amazing. The drinks were perfectly made as well. I'll definitely be going
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Custom Detroit Pizza
Pizza here is out of this world. Cocktails are also great. Out new favorite night out in Lewiston.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Custom Detroit Pizza
Bruschetta pizza to the Hungarian pepper pizza to the Detroit pepperoni pizza. I can not say enough about how good it was. Thankyou, 5 plus stars!!
Food: 5
Crispy chicken Caesar and pecan Brussels were so good. Had the best espresso martini with my dinner. Very excited to return here again!
Great Detroit style pizza and cocktails. Small but open dining room with history.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Custom Detroit Pizza
We tried this place yesterday evening for the first time. It was wonderful! It is a beautiful restaurant, very cozy on a snowy night. We had the Detroit style cup and char pizza (I agree with previous reviewers to add extra cup and char), and the chargrilled wings. We were so happy with all of our food. My fiancé had 3.5 pieces of pizza. This is highly unusual behavior! He was so happy with the food. Madison was a great server. Friendly and just the right amount of attentive. We will definitely be back and will be recommending it to friends as well.
Delicious food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Came here on a whim while visiting a local friend and was REALLY pleased with the experience.The drinks... tried a few of the on-menu cocktails and invented a variant of one when they were out of their homemade fruit syrup. All drinks were OUTSTANDING with the exception of one which was heavy on lemon and light on all the rest.The truffle fries were good, but what totally blew me away was the pizza! Fresh ingredients, ample cheese, a hint of fennel noticed at the end, and ooooh that crisp cheeeesy thick edge crust. (See pic)Coupled with a lovely atmosphere...Yay!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We went for dinner and drinks. The cocktails were on point, the food was delicious and our server was charming ?
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes: Beet & Goat Cheese, Rosemary Truffle Fries
This review is not only for those who are considering checking out Hustler's in Lewiston, but also for its owner, whose own employees are undermining his efforts to remain open in a part of the village where many others have failed. i've frequented this establishment for the last time. The main reasons are two employees who may or not be playing will a full deck and could care less if paying customers return or not. The first employee, a barmaid named Brooke, may be the worst bartender in WNY. Not only is she unnecessarily aggressive and confrontational, even when she's in the wrong, but acts as if she's doing you a favor every time she serves you a drink. The time i was in with my two cousins they swore they'd never return because of the unpleasant experience. One of them said, "This bartender should be bagging groceries at Tops." Does Brooke care if my cousins never come back? Obviously not and this should concern the owner, who likely does. The second reason is the unhinged cook, who sent us home with a burnt pizza that was inedible. Of course, he knew he burned it, but he tossed it in a box anyway, not caring if we returned or not. As for me, it's not, and that should concern the owner, who has an uphill battle making it where Hustler's is located, especially when his employees behave in a such a way that makes customers not want to return. Last summer, me and my friends watched in disbelief as the crazy cook threw a temper tantrum that would have embarrassed a toddler, slamming and banging things for a good fifteen minutes. Have no idea what set him off, but he certainly was pissed. It went on for so long it became comical, like live entertainment but the bartender looked legitimately frightened. Does he care if customers return or not? Obviously not. FYI: The first time i was in Hustler's i sat at the bar for about an hour or so, working up an appetite and planning to take a pizza home. The place closes at 10pm and was mostly empty. About 15 minutes before closing about two dozen people piled into the place. There was a festival that day in the other part of the village and they were overflow from the other bars. The barmaid (young brunette, late 20s, maybe 30) obviously had made plans for the evening and quickly closed the place down, costing the owner a tidy sum. Does she care if Hustler's makes it or not? Obviously not. To the owner of Hustler's: The odds of your business succeeding in the village are against you, especially on the wrong outskirts of town. But if your employees are, consciously or not, working against you, Hustler's has little chance of lasting for very long. i hope i'm wrong and these employees are the exception rather than the rule but every time i'm in your place, one of the employees has made me not want to come back. The burnt pizza was the last straw. Consider taking a good look at your staff and definitely spend more time keeping an eye on your employees. i've not seen anyone that looks remotely like an owner or manager when i've been there and when nobody is looking over their shoulders, your staff conduct themselves as if they'd been hired by a rival restauranteur who sent them to destroy your business.
Wow amazing pizza great salad definitely recommend the spicy crispy chicken Caesar salad. It was excellent. We had a Detroit style pizza and a New York style pizza with mushrooms delectable. They also have a wide range of wines to choose from. If you’re in the Lewiston area and looking for the best pizza around hustlers, Tavern is a place to be hustlers have an also has a lot of historical references so it could be a fun cool place to visit as well. If this review is helpful, feel free to tip on cash app. $Flamentco
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loved the meat and cheese platter! Great variety and generous portion. The pizza was delicious too! Great service, comfortable seating and warm, beautiful atmosphere!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat and Cheese Board, Margarita Pizza