50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Bexley

“harvest is so yummy! friendly and fast service as well. they have great pizzas and their lunch special is great, a pizza and a salad for $13! they have fake meat as well which is great for someone like me who does not eat meat. their s'mores brownie dessert was very yummy. will be going back!!“

“Wow. House Favorite slice is amazing. Moving day, just looking for good pizza, this is a quintessential pizzeria lil' place on a small college campus, sooo good. The vibe is young & fun, been around forever, antique ovens cranking out solid no fuss 'za. What a balm to my hunger on a more-than busy day! Thanks Anthony's for healing my soul!!“

“I don't understand why the dj gives up after the caberaet show. It's like they're trying to drive out the crowd so they can pack up early and still get paid a full night. I'm going to assume complacency from being the resident without competition for to many years. Both friday and Saturdays dj's are guilty of this. Ivan (RDJr), I'm told you read comments, pay attention. Your bartenders and VIP hostesses are suffering because of this. Everything else is absolutely amazing. Hate to see Michelle go. Best spot in Columbus period overall. Fix this and get a full nights revenue from that liquor license I'm sure isn't cheap.“

“wonderful place and even better folks that work and run the place. Very thankful of the way they helped my wife and I..“

“We called at about 7pm on a Friday evening to inquire about bringing our girls soccer team in at about 8pm. We ended up with close to 50 people, and the staff and management of Little Italy were amazing. We sat on the patio, which was nice because the girls could be obnoxious and it didn't have a negative impact on any other customer's dining experience. The food was served fast and was absolutely delicious. It's the only time in 3 years of taking this group places that we have had ZERO issues, bills were correct, food was correct, and the service was top notch. We have a new go-to place for our team.“

“Excellent food. Great and fast service. Love the atmosphere and staff was super friendly! Definitely recommend.“

“This restaurant is a must try. Excellent food freindy service and great drinks. It has been 5 years since I have had authentic Mexican. And I thought I would never have such great food ever again. But I have found it. I will most definitely be back.“

“2 blocks away... I live near high street but was 2 late for the rock stars I'm used ta... boom frigging had no idea! The bacon!!! In mah moufff.... (cheese all over my table) I'll be back sir... ohhhhhh yes. - TRANSLATION - it's very good pizza.Parking: OFF of Indianola... So slow down as you approach, so you can scope the parking. We just parked out front, but it was 2 in the morning (yes they are open that late!)“

“ordered for the first time this evening. and I gotta say the food was amazing. great service and fast delivery. I would highly recommend“

“Exceptional pizza! The service was friendly and we had no complaints about anything. My wife and had have been to multiple pizza restaurants in the greater Columbus area, but Stadz is definitely in the top five places for us. We will most definitely be there again and again!“

“Very good pizza and bosco sticks, amazing customer service!“

“Honestly I’m mad I just found out about JT’s! I’ve tried the calzone and Italian sub so far and both were excellent! Definitely will be going back for pizza soon. The calzone was crispy and topped with lots of butter & Parmesan cheese. You can tell the veggies are fresh (not those canned mushrooms ?) and the sausage quality is top notch. The sub was delicious, whatever ham they use has some serious flavor. The only thing that I would change would be the sauce. It has great flavor, but it’s not sweet how I like. But that’s just my personal preference! Also, noticed they have daily deals and monthly specials on their website. Definitely will have to stop in for a margarita sometime! 10/10 would recommend ?Parking: It can be challenging getting out of the parking lot…but there’s not much they can do about that issue“

“This Pizza! The flavor of the cheese and sauce is second to none. The best Pizza in Columbus in my Opinion! The service when you enter the shop is not fast but it is thorough and this food is worth the wait every time. I can't recommend this place enough for pizza. We get the large extra cheese pepperoni and it comes home still piping hot and made fresh and excellent. Very happy with this non acidic sauce also Such a great pizza I think about it while away and unable to find a good pizza shop! Argh, frustrating! Everyone needs to try this pizza you won't believe it. Sooo good!“

“Amazing staff and food!!“

“First time ordering from Luna and was not disappointed. Had a Spinach and mushroom Stromboli, Halal pepperoni pizza and the Super Moon minus green peppers.Everything was ready early and just as ordered.The Halal Pepperoni is a must to try for pepperoni lovers. The curled up ends on the pepperoni made it delicious.Prices are reasonable and service was quick. Give Luna a try!“

“Had my husband run down to Eagles and grab a pizza to bring home. We ordered a small taco pizza. More than enough for two people. Im wishy washy about many items from Eagles... However, IMO, Eagles has the BEST taco pizza in Columbus. So, that's what we got-- but it needs to be done a certain way for it to be the best! (tip coming at you...): you need to order the small and you need to ask for it to be cut pie shaped (aka triangularly). The pizza toppings for this size of pizza just work perfectly. Large sized never gets the right topping ratio. When cut in the large... lettuce falls everywhere, and if in squares it is too messy. Its a true advantage to hold it by the "crust". Tip#2. Ask for extra sour cream and hot sauce... these two toppings are key to getting the right flavor. Tonight's pizza was probably the BEST pizza Ive ever had from there. It was the taco pizza (how shocking, right?). It wasnt greasy. The crust was cooked perfectly, they had really good ratios of all the items on the pizza. I was stuffed after two pieces but gluttonly ate a third. (There are eight triangular, good sized pieces in a small) We have ordered other types of pizza from there. I must admit, I dislike their sausage. Its the crumbly type, its super greasy. I personally prefer big chunky clusters of sausage which isnt what Eagles uses, so sausage from here isnt my fave. The pepperoni is good Cheese has a good pull but can be kind of greasy and tbo its not a sure thing like the taco pizza. We also really like the veggie or mushroom:onion but there are better places for that. They also have subs, wings and spaghetti and homemade meatballs. The meatball sub is excellent. Price points are excellent here. You should give it a try. They even have a nice dining room for in house dining.“

“Ordered the bourbon chicken pizza from here recently and it was incredible. Highly recommend it and I will definitely be ordering from here again soon.“

“Me and my wife came here for lunch on Sunday 3/31. This was literally the best Italian food we ever had. Highly recommend!!“

“had a wonderful time and look forward to going back. despite being completely packed, our waiter bobby was attentive and we got our food and drinks quickly, while also never feeling rushed. the happy hour deal is definitely the best in the city!“

“Decided today was a pizza day. Headed down to Bazemore Pizza Co. They're located inside of the Pointe Tavern. I ordered a Ezzo's Pepperoni and Mushrooms pizza. Went down a back hallway where the kitchen is and met with the owners, Billy Bazemore and Todd Crow. Watched as they created my pizza. They only make dough for about 80 pizzas so they provide only the freshest ingredients for your pizza. They use a nice tomato sauce with SURPRISE actual tomatoes in it. So tasty. The cheese was perfectly balanced on the pizza, not just making a solid layer across it but a nice tomato cheese layering. The pepperoni and mushrooms were placed perfectly over the pie. Decided I had to have a slice before I left. OMG!!! The flavor of the ingredients were so fresh. The passion of these two guys surely shines through in their product. They also have wings that have a phenomenal taste to them, dip them in some ranch dressing and you will be amazed on how great they are. So if you want to taste the best pizza out there, come check Billy/Todd out. They're the real deal!!!“

“Great pizza and excellent service!“

“We've now been to Di Romas at least 4 times and everything we've ordered has been simply delicious! The owners are so friendly you kind of feel like family. Portions are large and prices are excellent. Stop in and try some homemade goodness, you won't regret it.“

“I had an issue with a call in order that was part my fault (me not understanding the menu) and part their fault (them misunderstanding my order). I was very frustrated when I called and I just want to give huge kudos to the manager for being so kind and patient with me, even upon realizing part of the mix up was my fault. I will go back for the customer service alone. The pizza is also great.“

“I’ve been going to Rubino‘s for about 40 years. The pizzas is great. I love the thin crust and how the store hasn’t changed a bit. Looks just like it did in the 80s.“

“Awesome great food and pizza“

“Great service and food was awesome!“

“Someone recently mentioned this place in a pizza group on FB. I decided to try it today & I'm glad I did. Probably the best non-deep dish pizza in Columbus. The prices were good as well. There's also plenty of nearby parking.“

“Best deli in Columbus! Everything like brown bag deli is too weird this is the perfect classic deli with great options. Decided to stop in and the guys working were super nice and got the DELICIOUS affordable super sub and Reuben. The breads were so fresh and everything was so tasty.Will definitely be back.“

“I had all but given up on finding authentic Puerto Rican food in Columbus, until my wife stumbled upon this place. We tried it out on a whim and were blown away. We both got the Pernil with tostones and maduros, and everything was delicious. As a Nuyorican, I can tell you that this food tastes just like home. Highly recommended!“

“Best pizza in the entire WORLD“

“Yesterday we had a pizza party at my home. I ordered a 17" half and half with a square cut. 1st half was a Don Corleone, the 2nd half was a Porky Fig. They made a mistake in the cut, so I had to wait 8 minutes while they baked a new pie. Then while I was waiting they gave me a gift card for their mistake. This I totally was not expecting. The pizza was awesome. The Porky Fig had a nice sweetness from the fig jam. The Don Corleone had just the right spice from the meat. Deweys has always had my favor taste buds, with variety of pizza option. Their salads are tasty also. Thanks DeweysParking: Curbside pickup was easy access.“

“We had actually been headed to a different restaurant, but the wait there ended up being longer than expected, so we decided to check out Harvest instead. We ended up going with some burgers and yukon potatoes for takeout. The Rosie burger was excellent, though, as a personal preference, we will probably skip the bacon onion jam next time. The seasoning on the Yukon potatoes was delicious, but they were a little overcooked. Service was friendly, and our order was ready as quoted.“

“I love the Veg Out Pizza on the Cauliflower crust. The Cheesy Breadsticks are amazing and the dough is melt-in-your mouth. Also the best cookies I've ever tasted, still a little chewy in the middle - just perfect. The toppings are fresh and you don't feel like you're doing something bad for your health when you eat the pizza because everything tastes so real and wholesome!“

“We enjoyed their informal Wednesday aftrnoon Bluegrass music. I put some photos at:“

“If you live close to this place and haven't tried it, shame on you!! We were looking for pizza and pasta for lunch from somewhere we had never been before. That is always a little scary!! We fortunately picked Pasquales. We ordered the garlic knots. They are Huge, Crispy where they need to be and chewy not doughy. And so cheap!! We decided to try the Meat Lovers Pizza and the Penne and Meatball too. Neither dish disappointed. The crust is so thin and crispy but not burnt at all and the amount of toppings was very generous. We have a lot of leftovers to take home. We both decided we would make the 45 min drive to eat here again and again. The server Makayla (sp?) was very friendly and the speed of service was Great!! Then there is the dessert case. We brought home a cannoli, a cream puff , a cinnamon roll and the peanut butter cookie sandwich with chocolate. So excited to try them too!“

“Amazing pizza and wonderful people !!!“

“I have nothing but good things to say about this establishment. The owner of this place is amazing He takes care of his customers when I came to him and asked for the patio for my going away. He said, of course don’t worry about it no charge staff is amazing. This place is very family oriented has good live music and overall just a good feeling. This is the best bar in Gahanna and I do recommend getting their amazing pizza. I 100% recommend coming here if you wanna have a good time or if you just wanna chill and have a drink!“

“Firstly, it's adorable and tiny. You walk in and it smells of fresh pastries and pizza, there's beautiful loaves of bread on display, dough getting loved on and pizzas being slung in the brick ovens. Everybody was very nice and there were samples to try and let me tell you...one nibble of the chocolate croissant and it was love at first bite; flakey, warm and decadent so naturally I bought two. Just when I thought I found my one and only I tasted the cream cheese danish....boom my pastry soul mate was right before my eyes. No debate the best pastry I have ever eaten; creamy, light, rich and voluptuous so naturally I bought two. Now for the calzone and pizza I can lump them together since they are similar by design. The dough is absolutely spectacular! Charred, crisp and chewy, really reminded me of my trip to New Haven. Undercarriage is to die for; leaves a little black char on your fingers. Cartoon esq. cheese pull, peps were crispy, sauce was fresh and vibrant. Tighten up the middle a bit and it's a 9+. This is a drive an hour to try it spot easy. From a guy who's eaten pizza in Chicago, New Haven, New York and about 75% of places in central Ohio. Chocolate croissant-8.9, Cream cheese danish-9.4, calzone-8.6, pizza-8.8“

“The staff is attentive, friendly and personable. The Draft House is clean and neat. I ordered one of their sub sandwich and a soda which was tastily. I watched ,Poor Thing's last night and enjoyed it immensely, It was funny, twisted and highly entertaining, I highly recommend this movie. I want to give a shout out to Amy who works at the Draft House and put up with me and my antics.“

“Ordered carry out on a crappy and super snowy Friday. Pizza was VERY good. Sauce is just right, pepperoni was spicy and delicious, and the crust was flaky, crispy, and cooked to perfection. Italian sub that I ordered was equally excellent! That bread is so good! Finally, I ordered an open face pizza sub. This was the absolute best that I’ve had! Again, bread is awesome, red sauce is fire, and that spicy old world pepperoni was just like it should be! VERY, VERY good! Six out of five stars!!!“

“AWESOME PIZZA !! LOVE THE CRUST !! GREAT SERVICE !!“

“My husband enjoyed his sausage and peppers pizza. You can see them making it fresh for you. The chicken avocado sandwich is so good. Chicken was seasoned well and everything came together on the bun. It is pricey but I think it is worth it based on the quality of the ingredients. They also sell alcoholic beverages which is a plus!Kid-friendliness: There are many choices for your child such as pizza, grilled cheese, cheese burger..“

“Hands down this place has the best pizza in the State and maybe the country. I watched the Netflix special on the famous pizza makers in America, they missed this one!!!! It is perfect! Stromboli’s and calzones kick it up a notch as well! Great food, great customer service. I drove by 15 or more pizza places to great here. No reason not to!!!“

“great food! quick service!“

“I have w been eating their food my whole life, it’s still the best!! Thank you for continuing to deliver top notch food!!“

“We went on Friday for lunch—it had been a while since I’ve been there. I will be going more often—the pasta and sauce were excellent. Very friendly and the service was awesome. Thanks for a great experience!!!“

“The pizza was phenomenal. A 10/10. The staff was great too. We drove 80 miles to try it. Worth the drive.“

“Great food and people would Definitely go back“

“Got family dinner deal with Fettuccine Alfredo, and upgraded the other entree to the Baked Spaghetti with Meatballs. And it came with bread sticks. Ordered it for take out. Food was ready when we arrived, hot, and tasted very good! Fast, friendly service.Parking: Large parking lot with plenty of spaces. Also has Drive-thru/drive up window.Kid-friendliness: (From previous observations) They bring food to the table, which is especially good for families or parents who have children with them. They have typical crayons and worksheets/coloring pages for kids to keep them occupied.“

“My family loves Yogi's Hoagies any night of the week! Our favorite is definitely the chicken salad and cheese hoagie, it's our go to and tastes delicious with their toppings which you can add or delete whatever you'd like. The staff is always friendly, helpful and welcoming. We usually pick up to go but every-time I've gone in to pick up, the restaurant is always clean and feels like "home":)“