Custom Cakes in Cincinnati, OH

MAKERS BAKERS Co. Bakery & More Bakery • $
Across from, 1801 Race Street, 122 W Elder St, Cincinnati

Customers` Favorites

Caramel Bourbon Banana Pudding
Hand Rolled Cinnamon Rolls
Pot Pies
Bakery

“I would never patronize an establishment co owned by Jaci Fantetti. Jaci totalled my cadillac down to my license plate three years ago on her third DUI and when given a sobriety test of which she could hardly stand up said, can't we wrap this up? you can see she's fine (me). she has an active warrant for being cited to court and not showing and was still actively bartending after that. no remorse and could have killed us but we weren't in the car that night (it was parked on the street) She also hit my car so hard going 55 in a 25 that she pushed my car into my daughter's SUV and almost totalled hers. she's had a string of evictions as well. on woodbine Ave in cheviot. look it up for yourself.“

4.9 Superb68 Reviews
Grandin Desserts Bakery • $
3670 Erie Ave, Cincinnati

“I cannot speak more highly of Grandin Desserts. Mark has a clear love for people and what he does, and it’s obvious in the respect and way he treats customers. I called more than 10 places trying to find a dessert place that would make a pecan pie on extremely short notice. Mark actually called me back to let me know that they had the ingredients and he would be fine with making it that day for pick up, even though it would put the pick up time well after their closing. Absolutely incredible service!And by the way: yes, the pecan pie is delicious“

4.8 Superb49 Reviews
The Cheesecake Bar a Makers Bakers Co Pop-up Bakery •
Findlay Market, 1801 Race St, Cincinnati

“I would never patronize an establishment co owned by Jaci Fantetti. Jaci totalled my cadillac down to my license plate three years ago on her third DUI and when given a sobriety test of which she could hardly stand up said, can't we wrap this up? you can see she's fine (me). she has an active warrant for being cited to court and not showing and was still actively bartending after that. no remorse and could have killed us but we weren't in the car that night (it was parked on the street) She also hit my car so hard going 55 in a 25 that she pushed my car into my daughter's SUV and almost totalled hers. she's had a string of evictions as well. on woodbine Ave in cheviot. look it up for yourself.“

4.8 Superb19 Reviews
F & Goode Desserts Bakery • $$
517 W 7th St, Newport

“A huge thank you to Stefanie from F&Goode, she was recommended to us for our Wedding Guests Deserts by Alcove By Madtree. What a treat ! I was looking for deserts with a French influence as I'm French and she did such an amazing job. It looked just amazing and was delicious ! Stefanie was very accommodating, we did a tasting of individual cakes and couldn't pick just one so we went for small bites and it was a killing ! Thanks again Stefanie !!3 bites: (wedding cake not included)- Chocolate Eclair- Fraisier- Lemon meringue pie“

5 Superb2 Reviews
Artrageous Desserts Bakery • $$
9799 Prechtel Rd, Cincinnati

“Attended a luncheon where Teri made 2 cakes. Heath Bar and Tiramisu/Black Raspberry Chip. Both outstanding!!!“

5 Superb2 Reviews
Classy Cheesecakes Bakery •
10260 Roberta Dr, Cincinnati
5 Superb1 Reviews
North College Hill Bakery Bakery • $
1807 Galbraith Rd, Cincinnati

Customers` Favorites

Custom Birthday Cheesecake
Celebration Cake
Cinnamon Bread
Birthday Cake
Tea Cookies
Doughnut
Bakery
Rolls

“NCH has become our go to for all our cake needs. Everyone always asks where we get them from and they are thrilled they too have found a new place. This year for my husband's birthday, Stephanie put together a tiered cake, the top was funfetti flavored with vanilla buttercream, and the bottom tier was lemon with vanilla buttercream, both were fresh and fun! Ordering is easy, just call. You can email a photo of what you would like, and they are extremely reasonably priced.Parking: Free parking lot with plenty of space for customers.“

4.5 Superb74 Reviews
Jazzy Cake Supply Cupcakes •
1006 E McMillan St, Cincinnati

“Amazing! I also had a last minute need for a surprise birthday cake for my 22 year old who was celebrating by herself this year. After reviewing her incredibly creative gallery of bakery items Jasmine created the most amazing cake for her! She was so surprised and thrilled and shared the best cake she has ever recieved with all her co-workers! Highly recommend!!“

3 Average1 Reviews
Queen's Bakery Bakery • $
4770 Fields Ertel Rd, Cincinnati

Customers` Favorites

Tiramisu

“5/5 for quality and service. I ordered a fruit cake for my daughter’s birthday. They were quick to respond and very helpful. The cake was a huge hit. One of the kids typically eats around cake frosting and eats just the cake itself, and she couldn’t get enough of this frosting! This wasn’t out first time at Queens Bakery, we’ve gotten some beads and bubble teas several times and they are always amazing. My daughter loves the Mango Milk. Both locations have fantastic service.“

4.4 Superb34 Reviews
Maribelle Cakery Bakery • $$
3704 Cheviot Ave, Cincinnati

“I was so happy with my wedding cake. I gave them a pic I found online and it was exact. It wasn’t an easy one either. Great job“

4.3 Superb18 Reviews

Cincinnati’s Other Flavors