50 Best Pizza Restaurants in Columbus

“I visited Westside Slice for the first time on Sunday. I ordered the chicken, spinach, sundried tomato, with a white garlic sauce and feta cheese. It was Heavenly❤️❣️. In addition, I had the wings with a spicy Chipotle dry rub. Oh, my God, these wings are in my opinion quite Heavenly!! They were flavorful, crispy, and done to the bone. The people working there were so friendly and treated me very special. This is going to be my pizza stop from now on. Although I live North, and they are located out West, it is absolutely worth the drive!!“

“I don't understand why the dj gives up after the caberaet show. It's like they're trying to drive out the crowd so they can pack up early and still get paid a full night. I'm going to assume complacency from being the resident without competition for to many years. Both friday and Saturdays dj's are guilty of this. Ivan (RDJr), I'm told you read comments, pay attention. Your bartenders and VIP hostesses are suffering because of this. Everything else is absolutely amazing. Hate to see Michelle go. Best spot in Columbus period overall. Fix this and get a full nights revenue from that liquor license I'm sure isn't cheap.“

“Excellent food. Great and fast service. Love the atmosphere and staff was super friendly! Definitely recommend.“

“wonderful place and even better folks that work and run the place. Very thankful of the way they helped my wife and I..“

“2 blocks away... I live near high street but was 2 late for the rock stars I'm used ta... boom frigging had no idea! The bacon!!! In mah moufff.... (cheese all over my table) I'll be back sir... ohhhhhh yes. - TRANSLATION - it's very good pizza.Parking: OFF of Indianola... So slow down as you approach, so you can scope the parking. We just parked out front, but it was 2 in the morning (yes they are open that late!)“

“ordered for the first time this evening. and I gotta say the food was amazing. great service and fast delivery. I would highly recommend“

“Very good pizza and bosco sticks, amazing customer service!“

“This restaurant is a must try. Excellent food freindy service and great drinks. It has been 5 years since I have had authentic Mexican. And I thought I would never have such great food ever again. But I have found it. I will most definitely be back.“

“Awesome great food and pizza“

“Honestly I’m mad I just found out about JT’s! I’ve tried the calzone and Italian sub so far and both were excellent! Definitely will be going back for pizza soon. The calzone was crispy and topped with lots of butter & Parmesan cheese. You can tell the veggies are fresh (not those canned mushrooms ?) and the sausage quality is top notch. The sub was delicious, whatever ham they use has some serious flavor. The only thing that I would change would be the sauce. It has great flavor, but it’s not sweet how I like. But that’s just my personal preference! Also, noticed they have daily deals and monthly specials on their website. Definitely will have to stop in for a margarita sometime! 10/10 would recommend ?Parking: It can be challenging getting out of the parking lot…but there’s not much they can do about that issue“

“Amazing staff and food!!“

“This Pizza! The flavor of the cheese and sauce is second to none. The best Pizza in Columbus in my Opinion! The service when you enter the shop is not fast but it is thorough and this food is worth the wait every time. I can't recommend this place enough for pizza. We get the large extra cheese pepperoni and it comes home still piping hot and made fresh and excellent. Very happy with this non acidic sauce also Such a great pizza I think about it while away and unable to find a good pizza shop! Argh, frustrating! Everyone needs to try this pizza you won't believe it. Sooo good!“

“First time ordering from Luna and was not disappointed. Had a Spinach and mushroom Stromboli, Halal pepperoni pizza and the Super Moon minus green peppers.Everything was ready early and just as ordered.The Halal Pepperoni is a must to try for pepperoni lovers. The curled up ends on the pepperoni made it delicious.Prices are reasonable and service was quick. Give Luna a try!“

“The salad was big enough for 4 adults to share & was delicious! We had pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion pizza and it was AMAZING !“

“Me and my wife came here for lunch on Sunday 3/31. This was literally the best Italian food we ever had. Highly recommend!!“

“Ordered the bourbon chicken pizza from here recently and it was incredible. Highly recommend it and I will definitely be ordering from here again soon.“

“I’ve been going to Rubino‘s for about 40 years. The pizzas is great. I love the thin crust and how the store hasn’t changed a bit. Looks just like it did in the 80s.“

“Came from Vegas to celebrate my granddaughters 8th birthday and she wanted to go here for her birthday dinner was EXTREMELY saddened when told they don’t do anything special for birthdays and when my server told me “ we would have to be doing those all the time” it seemed so corporate. I come from the hospitality capital of the world and in my 67 years on the planet have never been so hurt that I couldn’t provide this simple public expression of celebration. The desert they provided did not even come with a candle…this is a policy that needs to change…love the food and environment and the staff just not o fan of corporate policies“

“As soon as you walk in the delicious smells are wonderful. The spaghetti is good and the lasagna is the best I've ever had. Their little roles are always fresh. You get some good food for the money you spend which isn't very much. A recommend this Italian restaurant.“

“Great pizza and excellent service!“

“Great service and food was awesome!“

“Someone recently mentioned this place in a pizza group on FB. I decided to try it today & I'm glad I did. Probably the best non-deep dish pizza in Columbus. The prices were good as well. There's also plenty of nearby parking.“

“I had an issue with a call in order that was part my fault (me not understanding the menu) and part their fault (them misunderstanding my order). I was very frustrated when I called and I just want to give huge kudos to the manager for being so kind and patient with me, even upon realizing part of the mix up was my fault. I will go back for the customer service alone. The pizza is also great.“

“Great food, wonderful service and very nice setting for dinner. We had a group of 7 girls for a bachelorette and they were very accommodating to us. The complimentary strawberry shots were a big plus too! Would highly recommend for a celebratory dinner!!“

“I had all but given up on finding authentic Puerto Rican food in Columbus, until my wife stumbled upon this place. We tried it out on a whim and were blown away. We both got the Pernil with tostones and maduros, and everything was delicious. As a Nuyorican, I can tell you that this food tastes just like home. Highly recommended!“

“We had actually been headed to a different restaurant, but the wait there ended up being longer than expected, so we decided to check out Harvest instead. We ended up going with some burgers and yukon potatoes for takeout. The Rosie burger was excellent, though, as a personal preference, we will probably skip the bacon onion jam next time. The seasoning on the Yukon potatoes was delicious, but they were a little overcooked. Service was friendly, and our order was ready as quoted.“

“We enjoyed their informal Wednesday aftrnoon Bluegrass music. I put some photos at:“

“Bellas is amazing!! we order them a few times a month. always polite and the food is amazing!!!!“

“The staff is attentive, friendly and personable. The Draft House is clean and neat. I ordered one of their sub sandwich and a soda which was tastily. I watched ,Poor Thing's last night and enjoyed it immensely, It was funny, twisted and highly entertaining, I highly recommend this movie. I want to give a shout out to Amy who works at the Draft House and put up with me and my antics.“

“Amazing pizza and wonderful people !!!“

“My family loves Yogi's Hoagies any night of the week! Our favorite is definitely the chicken salad and cheese hoagie, it's our go to and tastes delicious with their toppings which you can add or delete whatever you'd like. The staff is always friendly, helpful and welcoming. We usually pick up to go but every-time I've gone in to pick up, the restaurant is always clean and feels like "home":)“

“AWESOME PIZZA !! LOVE THE CRUST !! GREAT SERVICE !!“

“Ordered carry out on a crappy and super snowy Friday. Pizza was VERY good. Sauce is just right, pepperoni was spicy and delicious, and the crust was flaky, crispy, and cooked to perfection. Italian sub that I ordered was equally excellent! That bread is so good! Finally, I ordered an open face pizza sub. This was the absolute best that I’ve had! Again, bread is awesome, red sauce is fire, and that spicy old world pepperoni was just like it should be! VERY, VERY good! Six out of five stars!!!“

“My husband enjoyed his sausage and peppers pizza. You can see them making it fresh for you. The chicken avocado sandwich is so good. Chicken was seasoned well and everything came together on the bun. It is pricey but I think it is worth it based on the quality of the ingredients. They also sell alcoholic beverages which is a plus!Kid-friendliness: There are many choices for your child such as pizza, grilled cheese, cheese burger..“

“Hands down this place has the best pizza in the State and maybe the country. I watched the Netflix special on the famous pizza makers in America, they missed this one!!!! It is perfect! Stromboli’s and calzones kick it up a notch as well! Great food, great customer service. I drove by 15 or more pizza places to great here. No reason not to!!!“

“great food! quick service!“

“I have w been eating their food my whole life, it’s still the best!! Thank you for continuing to deliver top notch food!!“

“We went on Friday for lunch—it had been a while since I’ve been there. I will be going more often—the pasta and sauce were excellent. Very friendly and the service was awesome. Thanks for a great experience!!!“

“The pizza was phenomenal. A 10/10. The staff was great too. We drove 80 miles to try it. Worth the drive.“

“Great food and people would Definitely go back“

“It's always good and hot and fresh we love getting their pizzas and subs we always get the destroyer and we put 1/4 of it with mushrooms a fourth of a pepperoni and fourth of a sausage and a four and a half of it with pineapple and it's always delicious“

“Amazing buffalo chicken pizza! A must try!!“

“I love coming here. I’ve frequented this place for years and the staff is amazing. They see you walk in and have your drink ready and waiting once they know you! It’s like my own personal “cheers”! The food is delicious and consistent! Clean restrooms and diverse crowd. 10/10 would recommend!“

“Went for trivia night with some friends and had a great time! The host for trivia was super fun and engaging. I ordered the pickle pizza, and it was really good. It did take a while to come out, but it was super busy, so it's totally understandable, and it was worth the wait.“

“Stopped at Minelli’s after getting into town. Very courteous friendly staff that kept my children’s attention during pickup. Great tasting pizza, Kids loved the cheese pizza and went with my favorite pepperoni and sausage.“

“A true Clintonville Gem. So happy that they are open once more. Pat is an amazing person and a fabulous pizza maker.“

“Always a pleasant experience. A place where “everyone knows your name”. Great pizza and great staff.“

“I just moved up here, so I had to reset all my stores and my fav pizza place.. Then my brother and i happened to stumbled on to this gem, we were INSTANTLY IN LOVE!I've gone back twice since then! ACTUALLY,I just a few days ago! Their pizza is off the chart in the delicious factor sooo good! My dad drove across town to see me and i took him here. their subs this is my new“

“Lovely location with friendly helpful staff and delicious food. The parking lot can be a little confusing to get in to. Reasonably priced at approx $10 a pizza (each pizza is good for 1-2 people) and a lot of customization options. Pizzas are all a lovely thin crust style with just the right amount of char. Highly recommend stopping by if you're in the mood for a pizza“

“The hospitality we were shown this weekend was unmatched. It was a cold evening and we were wanting to feed our 6 and 8 year olds before going to a concert. The wait was well over an hour and half for a table. The staff and owner not only gave my children free drinks but they found us a spot out of the way so my children could eat pizza without waiting. I can’t tell you how much that meant to this momma. Thank you so much!“