Italian Restaurants near Cortland

“The best white pizza around!“

“Excellent authentic Italian food, everything I have ever eaten here is amazing but a few items I can recommend as outstanding , stuffed cabbage (pigs in the Blankets) the plain old spaghetti and Meatballs . The sauce and meatballs are all made fresh from scratch nothing frozen . The sauce tastes so good I could drink it, it's balanced not acidic at all and it's sweet but not overly sweet, you can see the spices and fresh garlic. The pizza is exceptional, the dough is made fresh the signature pizza is the old world brier hill, every pizza comes with green peppers and fresh grated Romano cheese. You can also get traditional pizza with sauce and Mozzarella cheese and of course green peppers . The pizza is cooked in a traditional stone oven. When you walk in you can see the pizza being freshly made in the kitchen and the smell of the fresh Romano and the fresh dough baking makes you hungry instantly. It is definitely old world and delicious and makes you want to try it immediately, they deserve a 5 star rating FOR SURE!!!!“

“We no longer live near Cortland, but every time we're home we make it a point to get to Bellaria pizza. The sauce is wonderful and they don't skimp on sauce, cheese or toppings. Our favorite is the half sheet with sausage, mushrooms, and banana peppers, yummy ?. And the takeout drive thru window is very convenient“

“Everything was amazing, especially the cinnamon rolls. I can’t wait to order again👍😍“

“Clean atmosphere and a great staff. Delicious food. Great wine too.“

“My wife and I went here and enjoyed a wonderful meal. The food was cooked perfectly and our server was fantastic. Definitely worth the trip!“

“We got the 18" stuffed pizza and boy, was it stuffed! The cheese was the first thing I noticed. How real and fresh it tasted, then the delicious red sauce and all the meet. My boyfriend and I had one piece and it was all we could eat. Great, fresh ingredients, good price, and absolutely filling and delicious.“

“Went with my family to celebrate a birthday. Dinner selection was great, amazing pasta and fish choices. Stuffed Halibut and Whitefish were excellent, Veal was delicious as well. We had 6 in our party, seated quickly, service was outstanding and quick. Dinner Salads were a little disappointing... I recommend getting the soups. Generous portions and decent bar service. Prices were an excellent value for the quality of main dish. I'll be back to try the chicken Marsala, which I hear is fantastic.“

“I just picked up 4 fish dinners for my family and it was absolutely delicious!!!! The greens, the fish, the tarter sauce and the perogies were all awesome!!!! The salad dressing is perfect!!!! The homemade bread is the best around!!!!! Do not underestimate this family run business!!!! They don't do100 menu items at 50%, so the menu items they have are done at 120%!!!! Service, food quality are awesome as well! Perfectly consistent execution every time. Thank you Tinos!!!!!“

“Looking for quality food, spirits, service? Look no further. The freshness and quality are top-notch. Try the cucumber martini!! If you are lucky enough to experience the special - garden tomato bisque and specialty grilled cheese then you know it’s a game changer. Please add this to the menu full-time please please please!“

“Tried ordering last night put on hold several times for long periods of time and was treated rudely, if that busy just don’t answer your phone, I love the food but that behavior will force me elsewhere. I do u derstand being busy but it literally takes a minute to take an order . Thx for the ear!.“

“What a great place to meet friends for sone drinks and to eat. The sausage sandwich with hit peppers is delicious and so is everythibg else for that matter. Drinks are cheap and the pours are great. The staff is awesome. They have an outdoor patio for smoking with lots of seating. I meet my friends here all the time when travelling into town.“

“Back to Ohio after living in Florida for 25 years! The Sunrise is still the same as it was then! It looks the same, the food is still delicious and the servers are amazing! We ordered our old favorite, veal Parmesan, and were assured by April , our server, that it was still the same. She was right!! It’s still delicious and the serving is enough for at least two meals. The bread is wonderful too! If you’ve never been you must go! If was a favorite in the past be assured it’s still the same!!“

“Our nonprofit worked with Salvatore's Howland to host a retirement party for our president in their newly renovated banquet hall. It was the perfect size and ambiance for the event. Sal Jr. and the other staff were great to work with from our initial inquiry and meeting to execution of the event and clean up. The food spread was not only delicious but beautifully displayed, and the team went above and beyond to make sure all of our needs were met. We received so many compliments on the entire affair and will certainly keep them in mind for future events we might have. Thank you to Salvatore's and all the staff there for your help in making this a special night for our president and organization overall!“

“great food great service“

“Phenomenal Pizza! This dude puts his heart into his craft and it shows in every bite! Quality ingredients lead to quality pizza. Once I start eating it, I feel it becomes harder to stop with each piece. I cant say that very often but this is true here.“

“Needed to eat after a long, busy day and voting. Decided to try this place. Casual. Music at an ok level. Comfortable booths. Server seated us right away. She is so sweet and friendly. She made it clear she wants you to enjoy your time here. Everything came out quickly. Drinks right away. Cheese sticks right away. She brought pieces of pizza too when we mentioned we has missed lunch. Chicken parm was good - we would order again. More than you can eat. Pizza turnover with real mozzarella, no ricotta. Whatever you like. I got vegetaables rather than fries. Lots of sauce with everything. Busy take out. Worth coming back for the food but definitely for the service.“

“great portions. No suprises when it comes to great flavor. New choices periodically on a (Clean) menu. Reasonable prices for their well-sized portions. Always have friendly waitors/waitresses/greeters. Clean, well designed restrooms.Dietary restrictions: Unfortunately the are few dinner choices for (me) being a diabetic. Broiled fish. chicken breast and a low carb appetisor would be nice. Boring but necessary when out with the family.Wheelchair accessibility: Spouse uses walker and/or wheelchair. All areas including parking area accomodate for her disability.“

“Great Service and Food. Lisa Dawson always takes care of me.“

“Walleye francaise with lemon risotto and asparagus is amazing!!“

“My stromboli and wings are awesome. Lots of flavor and the portions are huge. That's exactly what Gus's is all about. And cheesecake too, you know you want it.Props to the kitchen manager as well, she's hands on and puts in the work, and it shows in the prices. Seriously, it's like having Rambo in your squad. Best owner since the OG.“

“Food's good it has a believable Italian feel which is harder and harder to find the further we get into the twentiesVegetarian options: Several different kinds of ways to make a pizza you don't have to have meat on all of them LOL veggie pizza is delicious normally has cauliflower and broccoli with a creamy Alfredo sauce and a blend of yellow white melty cheese yum yumParking: Plenty of parking nice establishmentKid-friendliness: I think they try to be friendly to everybody lots of Italians are very family-oriented and either grew up in a large tight-knit family or a small well versed family that had a strong moral compass their passion for their life and their food is evident as soon as you walk inWheelchair accessibility: Plenty of room and staff are willing to assist“

“Very nice and clean atmosphere. I was here on a date and they were very friendly and didn’t care that we were there for almost 3 hours. They even checked and asked if we needed anything after we payed the bill. The marghereta flatbread was absolutely excellent! Definitely will come here again!“

“This place has always been on my go-to's, I finally went and I was not disappointed. I went in on a Sunday by myself and had the High Pointe Burger. Holy smokes, it was delicious! I definitely had a full stomach after that. The staff were super friendly and the atmosphere was welcoming!“