50 Best American Restaurants in Toledo

“Lovely restaurant! We went on a Saturday and had to go on a waitlist. Wait was about an hour, went to another bar then came back. The food was good! But it wasn't the best steak I've ever had. I really enjoyed the spinach dip and they brought some more chips for us to be able to finish it up.“

“I had the most unusual experience. I've never actually had a situation like this before. It was something almost out of a movie, a romcom I'd imagine. I guess that made me John Cusack or Jack Black?My friends made a reservation and had the screen shot of it as proof even, but when we got there they didn't have our reservation or even know about it. They made it right by seating the four of us promptly at the MAIN table, a table for 8-10 people. It was very nice to have the extra space and a bit more light.The atmosphere is very quaint, almost like a speak easy. Lots of wood, a large bar for a small area, and very simply decorated. It can get a little loud in there, but that might just have been the table of ladies in the corner that wanted to be heard by the politician sitting with his wife across the room.We ordered appetizers, stuffed mushrooms and the beef tips. Both came out in a reasonable amount of time. The beef tips were amazing, tender and the "gravey" was thin and almost felt healthy. The mushrooms were ok. The stuffing in them had an obvious vegetable presence, corn and something else, something leafy. Not too much flavor maybe, very light as well. The issue was, on maybe my third or fourth mushroom, all of which I cut in half, I had what I thought was an under-cooked leafy vegetable. I couldn't rip it apart in my mouth, but I started to flatten it out, unroll it on my tongue. Growing as I unraveled it, I had to pull it out of my mouth, because part of it started to go down my throat. To my party's shock, as I pulled it out, I probably looked like I was a bad clown entertainer. It seemed bigger in my mouth, no jokes please, but it turned out to be a sheet of plastic! Balled up, clear plastic, like you would find shrink wrapped around a quart of mushrooms at the store. I don't think I swallowed any, at least not in that mushroom. I'd eaten enough, and they were good, so I ate the last one, very cautiously, probing like, and cut up, even after my discovery. Clean plate club I admit. We told the waitress, so that they could troubleshoot to make sure no other customers would have the same issue.We proceeded with dinner. My apple salad was good, different then what I have had elsewhere, not better, not worse, unique. I liked it. My salmon was great! Just not enough. The best part was the vegetables that came with it. Brussel sprouts and a mixture of a couple additional vegetables. If there was any problem with my main course, it would have just been the, maybe 3 oz piece of salmon. Everything tasted great. I had a local micro brew beer, and my friend had a couple over priced cocktails, our wives had wine.The chef/owner? Is a very nice and polite man. He came out and apologized in person for the plastic wrap. He also said that he comped our appetizers and my drinks. Everyone was so nice about the situation I felt bad when I actually had brought a Foody Card for a bit off my bill. I didn't feel bad when I saw that my wife and I still had a large bill though. I didn't know the price and portions going into the restaurant, that was my bad. I definitely didn't expect to find a surprise in my appetizer, that was their bad. The place is nice and we had great food, sans my surprise ingredient. It just seemed not right, spending that much after getting so much discounted and then having to go home and eat some frozen pizza slices because I was still hungry. I'd suggest more salmon on the PL8, or at least a lot more of those tasty vegetables.I'll probably go again, because the food WAS great. I just hope this was an odd, one-off occurrence, and that there is no sequel to my romcom movie.“

“Brittany was a great server. She was on top of everything! Never had to ask for anything as she was very attentive to the needs of the table.“

“We had a great waiter name Joey“

“Casual atmosphere, good tunes, wonderful food.“

“amazing food, environment, and service!“

“We had Staci that’s always there waitress ? she was excellent. This was the first time here and we loved all The food we ordered and Def will be going back.“

“We've been to Mancy's several times and have always has phenomenal experiences there. From A-Z this place has it all the ambiance, the professional wait staff, and top notch chef's. If you are looking to go somewhere that is heads and shoulders above the rest, this is the place to go. We literally were treated like royalty from the minute we walked in from the time we left... We will be back .... WORTH EVERY PENNY !!“

“Visited this lil gem for the first time, and it didn’t disappoint! Fast service, good food, great prices and lively environment! ❤️ Definitely worth stopping in!“

“Eddie Lee's is the best restaurant. The service is great and the food outstanding. The owner is more than professional and is a kind - hearted soul. I have been dining there for over 30 years.“

“excellent food excellent service it was my first time in the restaurant and I will be back“

“Absolutely confused why they closed the location on Reynolds Road near Maumee a few years ago. Loved that one and missed it dearly. Visited this location hoping it was still a home run and my goodness it’s even better!! The Memphis Mac is a 10/10 must have and they have bottomless fries!! $13.99 for a huge delicious packed grilled cheese and bottomless fries is incredible!! Only suggestion I would make is please open more locations because this place is too good!! The service was fast and friendly!!“

“Love ideal hotdog! Best chili Mac hands down! Staff is the best here! Clean place awesome food.Great chili dogs! Great omelets! Great everything. Looking for a classic diner with great food stop in. Been around forever. They need to sell ideal hotdog merch. One of the best restaurants in Toledo.“

“The food, wine, atmosphere, music and customer service is always top tier. I love everything about this place!“

“Traveling from out of town and wanted soul food. Google lead us here!!! Baked chicken, fried chicken, fish, yams, greens, Mac and cheese and okra all was amazing!I will be back when passing through. Oh how could I forget the customer service was on point!“

“Myles was awesome from the beginning. First time here the ribs were the best I've had at a restaurant in a long time. The cornbread also amazing. Everything was so good. I ended up getting the chopped salad and Ala carte ribs best decision ever. I'm from Florida next time I'm up in toledo I'll swing on by thank you!!!“

“This place fired in all cylinders and and all the food was super fresh the cooks and servers were all on the same page and definitely delivered exceptionally. Drove about 50 minutes for this and it was worth every second especially since the pricing was amazing although high prices are hitting in all walks of life today, this is still the best option in receiving great customer service, awesome food Quality, and a cool and collected environment to enjoy a late night or an early bird special.“

“Best cheeseburger in Toledo. The smoked turkey sandwich is also one of the best I've ever had.“

“Great food! Love the atmosphere! Give it a try if you haven’t yet Recommend the rack of Lamb and Brussels Sprouts and Chicken Drumettes as an appetizer“

“Absolute loved the burgers! Can’t wait to go back to try the pancakes I saw someone have with cinnamon roll topping! Nice people & I thought reasonably priced. Big burger! Used to be King’s Taste in the 80’s and did not disappoint! 1st time back here in decades! Love!!“

“I had the pleasure of dining at The Brim House in downtown Toledo at the Renaissance restaurant, and I must say, it was an exceptional experience from start to finish.From the moment we walked up to the restaurant, we were greeted by a very friendly face, despite arriving late and potentially going over their closing time. Paul, our host, warmly welcomed us and escorted us to our table, offering us drinks along the way.While it was dark when we arrived, we truly appreciated the ambience the following morning during breakfast. The restaurant boasts a stunning view of the river and the bridge, creating a picturesque setting. The overall atmosphere of The Brim House is warm, inviting, and exudes a sense of hospitality. Friendly faces were everywhere, making us feel immediately comfortable.Our waiter, Connor, greeted us with a genuine smile and proceeded to guide us through the specials of the day. He took the time to explain the origin of the wine we ordered, as it was from France. It was refreshing to have a server who went beyond the basics and provided us with interesting details. Connor's recommendations for our meal were spot-on, and we decided to order everything he suggested. It was clear that he had a deep knowledge and passion for the food.The quality of the food at The Brim House exceeded our expectations. We didn't anticipate such remarkable flavors and attention to detail in a restaurant located inside a hotel. Each dish was cooked to perfection, with the right temperature and an exquisite blend of flavors. The price we paid for such outstanding quality was truly a bargain. In fact, I would have gladly paid a higher price for the level of taste and presentation we experienced.The customer service at The Brim House was second to none. This dining experience ranks among the best we have had in Toledo and many other places we have visited. The staff treated us with the utmost respect and made us feel welcomed and valued throughout our entire meal. Their friendly and welcoming demeanor added an extra layer of enjoyment to our dining experience.In conclusion, I highly recommend The Brim House at the Renaissance restaurant in downtown Toledo. The food quality, the reasonable prices, and the exceptional customer service make it a standout choice. Whether you're a local or a visitor, The Brim House is a must-visit destination for a memorable dining experience in Toledo.“

“We came here for dinner and sat in the bar. The server we had was excellent and the burgers were perfectly cooked. Love the cold slaw too. However there was a shrieking kid behind us and I wasn't aware that children were allowed in the bar. The evening would have been more pleasant without him. We are here for a long weekend and the hotel recommended that we come here.“

“Awesome pizza!! Service was super fast. The first time we were there we asked a lot of questions and he patiently answered any and all questions. It Is a bit of a drive for us but we will definitely be going back!! Pizza, Sub, and cinnamon sticks we had were all yummy!!“

“Went with a few people on a Saturday evening for dinner. The food was awesome. Tried the bruschetta, Pierogies for appetizers. Was really good. I had the fried chicken sandwich. I have to say it was probably one of the best chicken sandwiches I’ve ever eaten. I had a Manhattan and it was on point. Very good. It was really crowded. I guess that’s a testament to how good it is. The service was good considering how busy it was. I would recommend to try this place out.Parking: There’s a parking lot on the premises. Seems to be plenty of parking. And seems secure.“

“Affordable, Fast, and Attentive Service. Enjoyed a Chili Dog & Burger with a fries with a Red Cream Soda. Comfortable, casual, authentic.“

“A great downtown Toledo restaurant! Reasonable prices for top quality food and drinks, and desserts. Excellent service and very friendly staff. We had a party of 3 and were in the mood to “party/celebrate” .. had a wonderful time.So you may not spend as much as we did, but it was worth it.Vegetarian options: Several vegetarian dishes.Parking: On street parking at meters free after 6 nearby and paid parking garages as well.“

“Nice atmosphere. prices are decent and portions are also. Great food, great service! you can't go wrong stopping by here.“

“I had a great experience here for my birthday! The food was great, the show was great, and the drinks were strong! It was a super-fun atmosphere. I can't wait to go back.“

“We ordered carryout for our work lunch and were very satisfied with the portions and speedy turnaround. Katie was very pleasant and made sure our orders were correct. The food tasted excellent and the provided condiments were perfect. We will be ordering again! Thanks!“

“Had breakfast there. It was delicious. Waitresses were very nice too. I will go back.“

“I've been here numerous times and I've never had a bad experience from the friendly front of the house staff to the great chicken and beef dishes. Most recently, I had the chicken and broccoli lunch special with a ln additional shrimp spring roll. No complaints at all.“

“OMG... just left so stuffed. Went with my grandson and his girl and the food was beyond amazing everything was so good. We will definitely be back. Went to Maumee Bay Brewing last week with them and it cost almost twice as much and we actually had to have them well you can read the review on there if you want to go look. This was so much better incredible“

“A Night of Royalty at the Peacock Cafe**As a Detroit native, stepping onto the stage of the renowned Peacock Cafe in Toledo was a dream come true. From the moment I arrived, I was treated like royalty by every member of the staff – from the owner to the curator, the host, and even the bartender.The atmosphere of the Peacock Cafe was electric, buzzing with excitement and anticipation. As I took the stage, I felt a rush of adrenaline unlike any other performance. The audience was receptive and engaged, hanging onto every word and note I delivered.The owner's hospitality was exceptional, ensuring that every detail of my experience was perfect. The curator's attention to detail in selecting performers truly showcased their dedication to providing top-tier entertainment. The host's warmth and energy set the stage for an unforgettable evening, while the bartender's skill in crafting cocktails added an extra layer of sophistication to the experience.Performing at the Peacock Cafe was not just a gig – it was a transformative experience. The support and appreciation shown by the staff and audience alike left an indelible mark on me as an artist. I cannot wait for the opportunity to return to this esteemed venue and once again bask in its regal ambiance.“

“Great food. Friendly staff. Relaxing atmosphere.“

“EVERYTHING!!!! GREAT FOOD& AWESOME STAFF“

“Great service, kind server and a menu with about 13 offerings. Coffee was always refilled and hot. $5.00 breakfast!!!“

“Good friend good people to talk to the bartenders are very nice and it’s a good place to hang out“

“Had a great dinner on 8/9/23. Our server Rain was great!! Everything was perfect!“

“Papapalooza is amazing so many bands!!...“

“Very crowded on a Friday evening, still found a table without having to wait. A nice people watching spot along a sidewall. A lively somewhat older crown. Did not wait long for someone to take our orders. My drinks were generously strong .The appetizer pretzels were soft,and the beer cheese tasty. My Jack Daniel's burger was perfectly done and very juicy the fries crunchy and salty. My daughters BLT was enormous and she said was very good. Great experience. Looking forward to coming back during the week and trying thier prime rib special.“

“Reservation was a breeze on a Saturday night, though they were packed. Promptly seated, server was very attentive and knowledgeable. We had bread for starters, lobster bisque and french onion soup. Of course we gotta try the steaks.. we ordered three 16 oz ribeye steaks cooked to medium rare perfection, well seasoned with onions and mushrooms on the side. NY strip steak was tender as well.. The Chilean Sea Bass was delish! The meals were satisfying and filling we didn't have room for crème brûlée.. perhaps next time. Happy tummy once again!“

“Our go-to brunch spot in Toledo.Seasonal menu always has great new flavors, everything is fresh and flavorful. Service is great. Recommend using the app to get in line on the weekend.Vegetarian options: A few vegetarian options - could be more, but there are always choices.“

“I LOVE diners. And this one ticks all the right boxes for me: clean, inexpensive, tasty, and friendly.The owner is the chef and one gets to watch him create magic in a well-choreographed routine at the grill. There's limited seating (about 6 stools and 3 two-top tables) and a relaxed atmosphere, so don't think you'll get seated fast or served quickly. There are phone orders galore.They take only cash.The staff are as busy as the chef, but during the whole time we were there (about 1½ hours) the atmosphere was relaxed and everyone was cheerful and interactive. Lots of laughter. So different from places where everyone is on screen, and no eye contact.Kid-friendliness: Don't“

“Vegan food finally! Food is sooo good and the non alcoholic options are awesome too bartenders are sweethearts“

“Everything is amazing!!! Try the wings, Greek salad, chicken hummus or chicken soup.“

“We supported them during Covid and better food than fast food . Friendly and the owners are great it’s great to walk in and they know your name and know what you drink and know what you are going to order and no complains here. Will continue to go to our favorite restaurant ❤️“

“Good friend good people to talk to the bartenders are very nice and it’s a good place to hang out“

“First let me say that I was skeptical about this place. I've driven by it many times and never thought to go inside then one day I decided and I was impressed, by the food not the actual inside of the place. The sandwiches are huge and each of them comes with fries. The chili sauce is meh but I'm from Detroit so I could definitely be bias. They never answer the phone but the service is quick even if you want in and place your order.“

“In honor of Pi Day, I figured I should check out why other Yelpers have been raving about Jo Jo's... They're something to rave about or at least their small meats pizza is rave worthy. The serve was quick and the ambience gave me a oldies "OG." I would totally return for another pizza Pi.“

“Brie has done a fantastic job turning the place around, and making the necessary changes needed for success! The products they serve are delicious, and the property/building are evolving as well! This family knows how to feed you delicious food. And it looks like it’s Bries turn to add frozen desserts to that bill. Congratulations Briean!“