24 Best Italian Restaurants in Toledo

“Wonderful little Italian restaurant in a strip mall in Maumee. We were fortunate to catch live piano playing during our Tuesday evening dinner. Surprisingly good wine list for such an out of the way location. Good food, good service and good atmosphere.“

“Have been going here for along time. First time ordering pizza though. I ordered extra sauce which I did not get and only ate a few slices. I asked to get extra sauce to take home and the waitress said it would cost $2.00 more. But she wasn’t sure. We had to ask again about the sauce after we paid the bill. She said they would not give us extra sauce!! Hmmm!! Really? So for all you that like extra sauce on your pizza… they don’t do that! Also, the waitress never took any of our dirty dishes away.“

“⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ My wife and I celebrated our anniversary dinner there (rainy/blah day), its not a fancy restaurant but the family atmosphere is very comfortable,the food was delicious compared to some more expensive 5 star restaurant. We had their cheese bread and sauce, small pizza, manicotti dinner and mini cannolis to go. Will definitely be our new Italian place.“

“Very plesant little place tucked away from main roads. Small and cosy and on Sunday night was packed with people. Food was great, service prompt and server very attentive. Date night or reunion or if friends come to visit, that would be my first choice.Parking: Free parking around the restorant, safe, well-litKid-friendliness: High chairs“

“Needs a little updating inside but the pizza was pretty good. Our server was kind, helpful and prompt. We'll go back to try another pizza or maybe some pasta.Vegetarian options: Choose your own pizza has several vegetarian options. Egg salad sandwich and typical apps are also vegetarian.“

“Very cozy atmosphere. Interesting & diverse menu. Love everything from their freshly made soups to salads to pizza to pasta to stromboli!! If you just want appetizers & a glass of wine you have LOTZ of unique options!! Good wait staff. Nice neighborhood dining spot.“

“This was a very old Olive Garden Building on the exterior. It told me it has stood the test of time. I ordered carryout for myself, my wife and daughter. We shared with the grandson. The girls got Chicken Alfredo and I did the Tour of Italy. Food was great,hot and fresh. Portions were large and none of us finished everything? We like leftovers so that worked. This store was in Maumee, Ohio a suburb of Toledo. We live in Cincinnati but we're in town for the evening and trusted Olive Garden to serve us great food and they didn't disappoint ???“

“This is undoubtedly the best pizza I have ever had… I could seriously become addicted to this pie!“

“Amazing Detroit style. They're my "go-to" when I have a few extra bucks to splurge. My neighbor recently ordered a supreme, invited me over for a piece I put on my running shoes! Sauce is light won't give you horrible heartburn and the dough is soft and buttery.“

“This is my first time trying your veggie pizza and it is the best I’ve ever had. Thank you for the great experience and the awesome pizza“

“We just visited the location on Monroe Street. Our food was served so quickly and was excellent, but what made our visit extra wonderful was our server Baylee. She was not only attentive to our table and on top of everything we needed without hovering, but listening to her address and serve the other tables around us showed how her personality is what brings customers back.“

“Definitely the place to go to when you're looking for good quality tavern-style pizza. We came here during the weekend during rush hours and were still seated quickly. Customer service is both fast and friendly. The pizza was also delicious, it did take a minute to come out to us, but that's what you should expect when dining at restaurants like these. Pizza was fresh, the ingredients and toppings were soft and hot, and the cheese was to die for. 10/10. Definitely a place to bring the family when you're looking for something a bit different that feeds a lot of people. One large pizza could easily fill 3 people with how thick and filling each slice is. If you haven't been here before, definitely stop by when you have some extra cash on hand! Your price range will start around $35 and shoot up to $100 fast depending on how many guests you bring, so keep that in mind.HOWEVER: Parking will be your biggest hurdle when you get here, spin around the block if you don't find a spot right away. Parking is street-side and has automated meters that you scan a QR code for and pay through your phone. If you can't find any street parking, try the parking garage across the street, though you may have to pay more.Vegetarian options: Ask your wait staff, but most of the menu is vegan friendly besides those that include meat.Dietary restrictions: I would not advise those with dietary restrictions eat from here as this establishment caters more heavy dairy, sauce, and grease. And much of the food is likely to be cooked with it, or around it. Use caution if you are on restrictions and would like to eat here.Parking: Parking is bad here, you will have to fight to get a spot, unless you're lucky enough to find one open like I did. If you can't find a spot, drive around the block. Otherwise, try the parking garage across the street, though you may have to pay more to use it.Kid-friendliness: Kid/Family Friendly atmosphere and restaurant.Wheelchair accessibility: This location is wheelchair accessible.“

“Me and my sister we're here Monday night for a benefit dinner. It has been a while since we have made it here. We had a amazing evening Our server Brandy was Outstanding. Our drinks remained full , tables cleared and she was an absolute pleasure. Our food was amazing as always. Thank you for the amazing service and evening. We will be back“

“Nice ambiance in a historic downtown building. Located within walking distance of the baseball stadium. Since restaurant is downtown, they have no parking other than street or downtown lot parking. Ambiance is very nice. Bar staff was excellent and quick. Since we were a large group, we had a buffet with pizza and salad and food was excellent. A nice dining option in downtown.“

“Great presentation and toppings on the Greek Pizza! 10/10“

“First time there tonight, so good! Ravioli and the strawberry cheesecake were fantastic!“

“I ordered POLLO PICATTA Grilled Chicken Breast, Herb Linguine Pasta, Artichokes, Capers, Prosciutto, Lemon Butter, Della Casa Salad washed down with Forbidden Sour. Friendly courteous service. Cool Cozy atmosphere. Reasonably priced food with good portions ????“

“3/2/24 Heidi was the best server we've had at Spaghetti Warehouse. We've had good server's but she went beyond to make sure we had what we needed. Plus it was the end of the night.Food is always good. Bread and butter, amazing.Sangria is the best I've had in Toledo.I always love coming here because I get 3 meals from my Spaghetti dinner. Yummy!2033 Great food and servers. Love the bread and their seasoned butter. The kids love the decor.“

“Discount for weekday orders. If you order 2 toppings in size XL, you can fill your stomach and eat at the lowest price for 2 or more people.About 13 dollarsThere are 2 tables for dining in the store. Each table can seat 4 people. There is no need to worry about the size. You can eat comfortably.Parking: Lots of seats free“

“hands down the best Gino's in the entire city. if you disagree, I can't trust your judgment on pretty much anything in existence“

“I can't speak for the food/order just yet but the person I spoke to on the phone - Doyle, was excellent. Very friendly and helpful. If I had a business and needed someone to answer customer calls - I would want to hire him! Hoping all goes well tomorrow with the order!!“

“I always get pizzas from Vito's and usually always satisfied other than I ask for them to cut it in squares and they don't so with that being said I live at Collingwood Nebraska and that is not far from South Detroit and they will not deliver I'm disabled do not have a vehicle so there you “

“Delicious pizza & subs, respectable male manager.I am frequent customer sometimes at work or home.My job isn't the best gas station in Toledo.Marcos went over and beyond when I had to warn driver it wasn't safe to deliver my order .Male manager was kind enough to let me have my order the next day ,and deliver it to my home.Highly recommend the Chicken Club sub,ask them to add ranch instead of mayo.Sub is then Chicken bacon ranch with crispy bacon, delicious.“

“I had an order of 4 and on one order was slightly off. The phones were down so in a few days I drove back & told the manager what happen. She politely righted the wrong and I’ve been a happy customer and will continue to keep patronizing this establishment. I love great customer service!“