50 Best American Restaurants near Valley City

“You know that breakfast joint where you feel like family but it's your first time? Yea, that's Knott's. Honestly, even if the staff wasn't so awesome, I'd keep coming back as the food is just that good. Everything they serve seems to have love baked into it, you can tell they really care about everything they serve. It's why we ended up there multiple times in one week and we'll keep coming back.“

“I recently visited The Wooden Nickel Bar & Grill with a friend and we had a delightful experience. We kicked off our meal with the Mozzarella Moons—an appetizing take on mozzarella sticks. These cheese-filled delights were the perfect start, boasting a deliciously gooey center.For my main course, I chose the Buffalo Chicken Wrap. It was enjoyable, though it didn’t quite dazzle my taste buds as much as I had hoped. However, my friend's BBQ Pulled Pork was a showstopper. After sampling a piece, I can confirm it’s a dish I'll be ordering on my next visit; the flavor was spot-on.The ambiance added to our pleasant dining experience. The Wooden Nickel offers a soothing atmosphere, with an array of TVs for casual viewing without overwhelming noise—great for those who appreciate a laid-back dining environment. Our waitress was attentive, making our visit all the more enjoyable.I’d wholeheartedly recommend The Wooden Nickel Bar & Grill to anyone looking for a new spot to dine. Whether you’re craving a cheesy appetizer or a hearty BBQ dish, this place has got you covered.Parking: I can see it can get hard finding a parking spot when crowdedWheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair friendly“

“Visited on a Saturday evening. Wasn't super busy and were able to be seated immediately. Using other reviews we decided to try the cone of fries. I was a big fan of the spicy ketchup out of the 3 sauces. I had the ultimate western burger and this thing was MASSIVE. I had to take off the onion ring so I could actually take a bite. It was an interesting taste- the pulled pork and burger didn't have any distinctive taste but I had a strong taste of chili. I enjoyed it with the kettle chips! My partner rated his Shepards pie 4.5/5. We sat out on the enclosed patio on a nice evening and really enjoyed our time.“

“The truffle mushroom soup was delicious, and so were the flat bread and the seafood pasta. Jenny, our server was absolutely wonderful! I also tried a jalapeño-mango margarita, suggested by Jenny, and it was great! The person who took my reservation was very friendly, professional and welcoming.“

“. I have stopped several times. Cool little place with limited menu. Food is good and plentiful. Great place to take your kids or basketball teams.Kid-friendliness: Nice dinning area and outdoor patioWheelchair accessibility: Has ramp to front door“

“Beaucoup Bucks at Bucci's. Prices were kinda high for quantity not necessarily for its quality. We had 14 person bday party on a Sunday afternoon. Pretty busy in there. Nice ambiance but really kinda loud probably since it's so tight in there. We had 2 servers, & were great. They let us bring our own cakes in & servers brought it out w/ candles so that was perfect. My Buccis burger was tasty & a large size. It only came w/ chips so I subbed salad for $3 so it was $17 which was a bit steep. The bruschetta was good but the toastinis were super hard - all crunch & no chew so it exploded as you bit it. Not many of us ate them therefore. Others got the French onion soup & calamari which were unfinished so not sure they loved em. The steak was reported good but a pretty penny. My two cousins next to me got 2 apps 2 entrees & 2 sodas and their bill was $90! Wow. Although the kids meal chicken tenders was huge & a great value. Nice place & good food w/ robust prices.“

“My 13 year old son and I stopped in for breakfast together for the 1st time and we waited to be seated for a view minutes. Once seated the server was friendly and explained the menu to us. We enjoyed the food as it was delicious and the portions were perfect for us both. Overall, the price is fair, food is delicious, quality is top notch, atmosphere is fun and clean for every age, and we will for sure be back! Great little gem with wonderful service!“

“Great experience! From the hostess station to our server, Ryan, the service was excellent. We had the sauerkraut balls appetizer at the bar while waiting for our table (delicious!). A couple of delicious burgers downstairs in the pub area finished off a great meal. Well done folks!“

“This is a very interesting and cool place to visit. From the beer selection to the facility it self. Being a brewing company with a wide variety of Ales and IPAs for everyone. We loved the self guided tour you can take. It's just a walk around hallway posted on the walls. It tells you the beginning history of the Fat Head Company and how it landed in Ohio. Yes....we purchased a tin sign for the garage.“

“While the meal and service was spectacular as ever, your handicapped entrance to the dining room was a blessing. We will be able to visit Pomeroy House more often. Thank you so much.“

“If you are looking for some true home cooked meals where you are treated as a human, go here!! Our server treated us like a hungey family member and made sure of beverages were full and we had plenty of napkins. The serving sizes are perfect, and they really have the best cole slaw.“

“Having never been here for lunch. It was a complete delight, joy, and surprise. There were items on the menu that I have not seen in the dinner menu and the prices were very reasonable the portions, outstanding, and the service impeccable. I will be back.“

“Food is always good. Prices are reasonable“

“LOVE Mike's ❤️!! Always GREAT food! Great beer selection! Fast, friendly service. I had the beet burger! It was delicious ?!!! Yes, beet!!! And creamy goat ? cheese. Mmm mmmmVegetarian options: The best BEET ? BURGER!Parking: Street and lot behind“

“We haven’t been here in forever. I believe we will continue to stay away. Sadly my garlic parm wings were overcooked very dry and not much sauce. Not to mention they charged us $2 for it. On the positive side my husband’s fish was good. But that’s about it.“

“First time dining here.Although temperature near or below zero outside, place was warm inside.Staff was friendly and waitress was ambitious with coffee refills.Prices were fair, good daily specials. Food was as expected in taste and actually had more ham in the omelette than I had gotten anywhere else.Decor could use a little more warmth, home feeling for a breakfast place, but it was clean.“

“If you have not tried aces depot do your mouth a real favor and go immediately the food was absolutely amazing everything you order is made fresh and in house had passed this bar and grill for many years and never thought to go try it finally did and if I could give 10 stars I absolutely would best food in the area amongst all other restaurants and bars in the area the bartender was absolutely amazing very on top of everything and would educate you on everything they have or that they can make“

“It came to our attention that bistro on the falls has the best mixologist that makes the best cocktails Ever. Kixksy . Wow she was amazing not only with her cocktails but the way she treats you like family. The food was wonderful. The restaurant is cozy and beautiful. Kixksy Introduce us to the Owner Marcelo what a sweetheart. To us what makes this restaurant was Kixksy and Marcelo thank you for you hospitality. We'll be back to see you both.“

“Last day of a long business trip. Decided to try this place for breakfast after our hotel shut down breakfast earlier than expected.We enjoyed the breakfast flatbread and muffins. Coffee was good. Service was friendly and accommodating. We would definitely stop in again if we get this way.“

“We loved this place.We were a little disappointed because the website said 21 and over after 8pm and there were kids there all evening. I would have brought mine had I known they could stay.The bowling was a bit pricey at $63 per game for 8 people. The go carts were a blast. We liked all the vintage games, and forever jewelry was a nice surprise.“

“First, the beer is amazing. Second, the food is fabulous! I had the pulled pork sandwich, it was the best! My wife had the Mahi Mahi wrap she said it was amazing. We both got the coleslaw as our side and were glad we did. Third the atmosphere and service was great. We will be back.“

“Last weekend, we hosted an unbelievably fun Secret Society Comedy show in the ballroom at Blue Heron where Ben and the staff did everything in their power to make the show a success. Over 200 people came to laugh along with us on a gloomy Friday night, and I'd highly recommend this place if you're looking for somewhere to host your next event.“

“Chris was definitely the highlight of our experience! Took my 3 grandkids ages 8-11 and he was so personable and made going out to dinner fun for them! Don't get out to that area often but definitely planning to be there October 2nd! Thank you Chris for your outstanding service!“

“We love Waffle House. Always go to the one at Sunbury/Delaware exit. First time we've been to this one. Food was just as good, people were nice and friendly. We'll definitely stop when we're in Medina again.Kid-friendliness: They had high chairs.Wheelchair accessibility: Single toilet in a huge bathroom.“

“For the first time since I came to the United States of America, this is the best hot dog I have ever eaten in my life. My wife and I loved it very much. The chef who wears an American flag band on his head is very respectful and the way he dealt with us was excellent and I loved him, and we will do it again as well.“

“We had the best evening with a group of friends and our fantastic waitress, Amy! Unfortunately there were multiple items unavailable but she gave us great other options and kept us laughing the entire time!! We highly recommend dining here and make sure you ask for Amy! She’ll make your entire evening!“

“Updating my lunch review. Came at a time when it was not so busy. Ordered the salad-burger combo. My wife had the salad-chicken sandwich. Both with salad dressing on the side. I have to say their burgers and chicken sandwiches are among the best I've ever had. Service was fast and attentive. Highly recommended!“

“Excellent food. Great friendly staff“

“Our food is always delicious and consistently made well . Their soups awesome. We always can count on pj marleys to deliver fantastic food. You can tell they really care about their customers!! Thanks.“

“Great food!! Ashley is an awesome server. She is so attentive to our needs. She remembers our order every week.“

“We had brunch on Sunday, overall everything was good, except the coffee was not hot and it appeared they had some difficulty coordinating the dishes as the waffles were not hot when they were served, although they were tasty. We had reservations and were told when we arrived that we could either sit at a hightop or sit outside. Since we did have a reservation, I would have expected to have been offered a table especially since one of the members of our party is in her late 80"s. We chose outside although it was warm it was windy, and with the music speaker above our table we had a difficult time conversing with each other, not ideal.“

“I've traveled all across the country and been to hundreds of dives and The Islander is hands down my favorite place to go. The food is great, the steaks are done perfectly and the staff are all very sweet and attentive, even when it's at full capacity. Coco, thank you for the warm welcome the first night I came in there. Brooklyn, Kate and Amanda, y'all made the best team and a great environment on New Year's, the rest of the staff that I don't recall all of your names, all of you have made this the best place ever. To the local crowd, thank you for making a complete stranger feel very welcome and included. If you're new in town, stop in, you'll find many new friends!“

“Great neighborhood place to grab breakfast or lunch. This place is clean and the staff is attentive. I highly recommend the Banana Pecan Pancakes... yum! They must have a good exhaust fan because you don't smell like breakfast when you leave.“

“Restaurant full of happy people enjoying great food served by friendly, knowledgeable staff.Wheelchair accessibility: As with any restaurant with a drive-through, be careful of drivers distracted by opening coffee, unwrapping baked goods, etc.“

“Great place to grab a drink on the Square. The ambiance is nice and the staff was friendly and knowledgeable. Had a few different bourbons from a pretty large selection, just need to get some Angels Envy. Overall it's a great space to relax and soak in the atmosphere.“

“We took our mom here when we were I. Town visiting. And all I can say is WOW. I spoke to one of the cooks after our mean and completed him on the food. In our brief conversation he said he had been there for a while and planned on retiring from there one day. Our waitress was fantastic and she also stated it was the best place ahead of ever worked and would never leave it. She shared a personal story of one of her longtime customers with us as well. And when my mom asked for the bill at the same time I did her reply was fantastic she said” Trivia would not be happy if he knew I gave the bill to a mother”. So that ended the debate on payment. The food was absolutely amazing as well. We can’t wait to go back. Oh and their cannoli is to die for.“

“Tried Herman's with my parents this week. I had the fish and chips. 3 pieces of fish. Cooked well but a little small. My mom had the Pierogi meal and she loved it. Definitely a bigger meal. My dad had the BLT. It was big but a little messy for him. Great service and cool bar area. We sat in the upper lounge area with the pool tables. That was below average seating but the lower bar area looked much better. Very pleasant experience overall. Clean, good food and good service.“

“I came last night and ordered a City Sampler which had beef brisket which was so tender, pulled pork sausage and turkey with baked beans and ,greens and corn pudding. The food was amazing! My family loved it. ? The service was awesome and everyone well was very friendly and made us feel welcomed. The atmosphere was very clean as well. Would definitely come back again.“

“I love this place! The menu is very extensive! The French onion soup is wonderful! Our salads were so fresh! Love, love, love the shepherds pie! The food is definitely like home cooking! Bailey’s cheesecake is divine and you have to have Irish coffee!!!“

“Amazing!! The food the service the shops inside the restaurant!! What a great experience!! Will definitely make another trip!! Oh the Bloody Mary flights perfect!!“

“Old outdated building but where isn’t this the case nowadays? What matters is their French toast and home fries are amazing. Nice and crispy and full of gosh darn amazing flavor. GOTTDAMBrekkie all the way. Never had lunch here tho *shrug*“

“The food is always exceptional when we go here. Then steak has always been prepared just as I had ordered. Their sweet potatoes and regular baked potatoes are very good. They have the charred brussel sprouts with a sweet and spicy sauce that is a favorite of my wifes. They have a great group of young gals that do a wonderful job of waiting on you at your table. They are always friendly and very helpful.“

“My go to place for breakfast most of the time. Great service depends on who you get for a waitress. The younger ones are a little distracted. The hostess and owner is awesome. Very attentive and makes up for the slower young ones who don't know the difference between homefries and hashbrowns because they always ask, "the shredded ones?" And even then, you sometimes get the opposite. However, I love the place for breakfast.“

“This place is FANTASTIC!! Dont miss it! Looks like a speak easy! Very quiet, like it's a secret! But it has the same menue as the winking lizzard! Same food! Great beer and spirits! BUT, no kiddos allowed! So you could say it's a grown ups place? We truly love it!“

“I would have to say this place is one of my favorite restaurants. The food is amazing, service is excellent and has a great atmosphere. I've even called in for a pick up and was impressed! If you haven't tried this place it a must try restaurant on the square!!“

“Quite honestly one of the greatest bars I've ever been to, and I've been to a lot. The owner, the bar staff and all the visitors have been lost excellent. I've been here 5 times in the last week and they continue to exceed expectations.“

“Awesome place for parties“

“Richie and Ashley was sooolo awesome with the customer service and speed. Definitely went above and beyond to make sure I was a happy camper. The atmosphere was great. I was gonna eat in my car but it made me wanna eat inside cause it was so clean and friendly.Vegetarian options: Cornbread which is awesome. Mac n cheese and the hush puppiesare greatParking: Easy accessKid-friendliness: Clean atmosphere nice music.“

“Great food. Especially the Flatbread ck Philly was amazing. Great service also and good prices.“

“Good food, good service, good atmosphere.The Clam Chowder was good. The side salad had the perfect amount of cheese. The Turkey BLT Wrap was good and its fries were amazing. The Skinny Moose Combo was good too with grilled chicken and teriyaki sauce. My only complaint was that I’m almost positive the veggies were frozen and microwaved.They were swamped so even with reservations, there was a bit of a wait. Once we were seated, our server apologized for the chaos and got our orders, got us everything we needed, and spaced things out nicely.The place was well decorated with lots of ornate woodwork and firehouse pieces.We will definitely be back.“