29 Best Pizza Restaurants near West Jefferson

“Great People / Owners. We were in the mood to try something local after our baseball game. The food was amazing. Deep fried mushrooms were delicious, and the pizza's we ordered was spot on good. It is places like this that makes me as a customer want to come back again and again with my family. The staff was extremely friendly. Definitely a must eat at.“

“The only pizza place we order from! Great prices and even better food. Everyone who works there is nice! The only thing that I don't like is their hours but definitely worth waiting for them to open.Parking: There's a few spots right in front of the shop. A few on the side, but you can park in the back of Shell's Parking lot if you can't find a spot out front“

“We all agreed that we had one of the best pizzas we have ever had tonight at Todd's! It was so good! The crust was thin and crackery crisp, the tomato sauce was mild and delicious! The pepperoni was perfectly mild, with just the right amount spice. Absolutely delicious! We don't live near West Jefferson but cannot wait to get back here! The garlic bread was equally good as was the house salad! The staff was friendly and our server was great! I do not understand why this place was not lined up out the door!“

“A nice surprise. Found this place with a friend for lunch last week. I’ve been back for takeout twice already. Meatball sub has a hold on me! Service is great. Friendly and attentive. Great menu with lots of options. Great atmosphere. I would definitely recommendWheelchair accessibility: There is a ramp“

“We've been to the West Jefferson location twice in 4 months. Exceptional service both times!The same gal took our orders both visits, and she is so kind, helpful, and on point with service.The food is always delicious.The restaurant is always clean and the atmosphere is friendly and comfortable.Great job, West Jeff Flyers!“

“Pulling up to this place really made me feel like I found something special. Everything was enjoyable. All the food we tried needed a little salt. A tiny pinch of flaked finishing salt would really be that final step into flavor town. The patio is enchanting and the people are very kind. They also have great “

“The pizza was so so, but the service was fantastic. I was looking for a new place to try. Galloway Tavern was recommended. I Read great reviews about the pizza here. I had a hard time finding the place as there's no sign out front and the street name is different online then it is on the street. However, it is the only tavern in the area so you can assume. Because I was late picking it up the pizza was no longer hot when I got there. They were kind enough to put it back in the oven for another minute for me.“

“A nice place. Seemed clean and had friendly people working. The place seems to attract locals for their trivia games. My daughter ordered the bbq wings, while her husband had the buffalo wings. I had a 1/4 sub called the pistol without the bun. Everything was good. If you are in the area and want a relaxed, fun place, this is it.“

“My daughter wanted Stromboli instead of pizza for a change, and we found this place online. We were very happy with everything we ordered- Stromboli, lasagna, meatball sub, potato skins, and cheesy garlic bread. Everything tasted great! It was ready for pick up on time, even though they seemed to be short staffed they were making a huge effort to get everyone's food orders out at the time they promised. They work really hard for their customers and it shows.The only suggestion I would make is to maybe pare down the menu a bit. There are a LOT of choices and I think it would benefit them to focus on a theme, like just Italian American food while keeping the Halal versions also available for those who follow that diet (it's awesome that customers have this option. I don't think there are many around Columbus). For instance, the hamburgers stood out on the menu since they dont really fit in with a pizza place. Also, all the different types of pizza and Stromboli and such gets a little repetative. Slimming down the menu could keep both the customers and the staff from getting overwhelmed by too many items.Now that we know Luna is a short drive away, we will be definitely adding it to our restaurant list. The food was tasty and the serving sizes were large. I definitely recommend them.“

“I am boring. I purchased a small cheese pizza. I ordered late Saturday not realizing what time they closed. He happily took my order. I picked it up shortly before closing. I did not take a picture. Upon opening the box the fresh aroma of cheese hit me. The sauce and the cheese was a perfect amount. Usually I have to order extra sauce and cheese. This was perfect. The sauce was perfect. It was not sweet nor spicy. The crust was thin and crispy with a hint it seemed of butter. Almost "crackerish" which was actually very good! I am sick of soggy crusts. I devoured it the minute I got home! I will definitely be going back!“

“Food is always good, plus they have my favorite beer - Ky Bourbon Barrel Ale - on tap. Our waitress did an excellent job, and the support staff stopped by several times. It can get a little loud, they may want to consider adding acoustic tiles in the ceiling to absorb sound“

“Food is good but customer service is not okay. Called to order and the lady on the phone was just not friendly just acted like she hated life and didn’t care about anything“

“This is my second time having it, and my fiancés like 50th ?. He grew up next to it and decided to show me his favorite food from his childhood. Their food is SOOOOO good. Better than any papa johns, donatos, anything, they’re so good and all of the staff is just incredibly sweet. Thank you for amazing food and customer service everytime we’ve visited. We got the sub n crust.“

“I went bowling here with these 5 super hot blondes. I loved it! The workers were very kind and sweet. Owen and Tyson especially showed a lot of kindness. The food was amazing too. Well only I had food. I didn't let the hot blondes get any food cause I didn't want them to ruin their breath!! HAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHA“

“Our group stopped in and got 3 Large double pep pizzas and 1 being half cheese.1st time and I have to say, best pizza I have had in at least 20 years. Current favorite and I can't see this place losing that spot any time soon. It's a shame we live an hour out.“

“Subs and Salads rock! I don't get pizza very often, but I'm always stopping in for a crispy chicken salad.Update: 4 years later, and still regularly here. It's been good!This place is always so clean. I don't question that the owners take pride in their restaurant.“

“Can't believe I haven't reviewed this before, b/c this is our favorite pizza place! The pizza, Strombolis, subs(try the nightmare!) all are delicious! It overtook our previous, Columbus based favorite with their quality & service. The employees are fantastic. Extremely friendly & helpful. I've never had a rude experience. I've only done the pickup window, but there's delivery & walk in pickup too. I can't speak about dine in. Absolutely worth trying if you haven't already.“

“My family liked Cattelmans. The crust is not the best, too crunchy in my opinion, but I really like the sauce. They have great deals on Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday. The service was really good and we didn't wait too long. The place is not the best, for take out only. I'll try it again soon.“

“Like the place very much, friendly neighborhood bar with great friendly service and rotating beer selection. The one star taken away for allowing patrons to vape inside sitting at the bar and not asking them to go on the patio, I really don't enjoy smelling and inhaling this with my beer. Manager should take actions on this!“

“Food has never been better, I prefer this over Olive Garden. The girls who work there are so nice and helpful, you know the food and service is good when you see they're of different race. Although that sounds wrong of me, I've been to other Fazoli's and this is THE best one and that's one of the differences I noticed. Everyone is so nice and understanding unlike other locations. The place is clean and fast regardless of the good amount of people in and out. Never had an issue with the service or the food. Shout out to the girl that recommended the chicken broccoli penne!“

“I had never heard about Youngstown style pizza, much less tried it. I prefer pizza with a lot of sauce and on a whim tried the Brier Hill. Let me tell you…it was everything I hoped for! Awesome crust, perfect sauce (not sweet), and the peppers gave a little heat (I mixed hot and sweet) but were not overpowering. Soooo good!“

“I ordered a pepperoni pizza the pizza was freshly made hot and delicious with pepperoni covering the whole thing will definitely be back!“

“Really amazing service! Our youth hockey team dropped in basically unannounced this Sunday afternoon. One staff member in particular worked incredibly hard to ensure our orders were accurate and timely. And they were so friendly and helpful. Great experience!“

“Sextons doesn't mess around with their pizza. They accomplish this by keeping it simple and don't overdo ingredients. The quality of this pie was exquisite and the taste sublime. I saw a lot of people complaining about the crust being overdone, in my opinion if there's no char it ain't done right! The crust was phenomenal and the sauce uncomplicated in its taste of pure bliss while the cheese danced on top in sheer delight and then across our tongues it waltzed in robust beauty. When a pizza can take away the attention of two grown ups sitting at the bar while a hoard of kids screamed and ran around like it was The Lord of The Flies with no parental care or control over the noise these banshees were making you know how good it must have been! The entire staff were straight quality and the service was down home nice. We'll definitely be back although we'll be more discerning about the time and day as to miss the running of the nose miners next time! I'm going 9.1 on this rating! Well earned, from a great group of people giving excellent service through it all!“

“I ordered a large fry, disappointed at first because the price was $6.44... but then when received the order my mind changed right away. It was a full size plate full of amazing fries that I can’t stop thinking about now lol ? also had halal pepperoni pizza which was very yummy also.“

“My favorite is the taco pizza and chicken pizza. The prices are a little bit pricey but they have really good food. Their chicken subs is also good. The pepperoni pizza is ok, need to go a little bit lighter on the sauce and put more cheese. Good place though and employees are very nice“

“We found zuko's pizza during covid, on a cold snowy winter night. When the idiots tried to shut everything down. We have been a regular customer sense. Joe the owner, and other family members d o a awesome job. Last night I was in the store. A delivery driver came in for an order. They asked what the customers name was, and the individual just held up their phone so the employee can look at the name. That's not there jobs! What kind of idiots are we hiring? It's everywhere we go now.“

“Just moved to the area. Went in tonight with my husband and brother to watch Monday Night Football. Excellent service, awesome food (from Zuko's next door that serves the bar... some of the best pizza and wings I've ever had) and a great atmosphere. I liked the lighting. Sounds weird, but it was really inviting and cozy for a sports bar. We will definitely be back!“

“AHHHHMAZINGG!This is literally my FAVORITE pizza of all time. Sausage and pepperoni with their delicious RANCH. You won't go wrong!!! I pre ordered by calling on the phone. It was ready in time and kept warm. My go-to everytime I'm in Columbus or Michigan.“