35 Best American Restaurants in Youngstown

“Had a standard breakfast of eggs, potatoes, bacon, toast, side of sausage gravy and coffee. Food was very good especially with the price. Lots of waffles and pancakes options I want to try another time. Waitress was very friendly and engaging, and kept my coffee mug full.Parking: Standard parking lot.“

“Vegetables are always fresh. Staff are friendly and service is efficient no matter how busy they are.“

“I went when it first opened and I have to say I am absolutely IN LOVE with the atmosphere. The waitresses are always smiling and happy to help with anything. Specifically my waitress, Missy, was personable, attentive, genuine, and absolutely in tune with her customers! She did an awesome job. Definitely recommend the restaurant, and if you have the privilege of having Missy for your waitress, you’re in for a wonderful evening! Thanks ladies!“

“We stopped in here on a whim. We've heard good things but never bothered to try it... until tonight. First off, let's talk about service. Absolutely phenomenal and I can not stress that enough. Mike and his team absolutely killed it! Our waters were constantly full, our cocktails were delicious and the one on one conversation was excellent and this was on a fairly busy night. Every seat at the bar was full and atleast 3/4 of the dining room was full.DRINKS: All of our cocktails were excellent and their whiskey/bourbon selection is damn near second to none.APPS: Chicken tenders, pretzel, hot peppers, and confit wings were all exceptional.DINNERS: Chicken & Street corn salad, Blueberry chicken sandwich, Portobello melt, and Chicken stir fry were all exquisite.DESSERT: Oreo cheesecake was excellent.We will absolutely be back!“

“The cigar bar is the best! Thursday nights with friends and great service and staff make it the best night of the week.“

“The good. The service. The atmosphere. It’s a solid A+.“

“We had a party of 10. Service was good, food was excellent!!! It is truly a very nice, cozy restaurant. The Thin Mint Martini is delicious!!!“

“First place I ever recommend to anyone new to, or visiting, the area! Fantastic atmosphere, food & service.“

“Finding a good lasagna is hard. These guys nail it! When we are out in the area it's our favorite place to go for Italian food. They have always taken great care of us even the time we looked like ragamuffins and probably should have just done drive thru. They are worth giving a try.“

“Karaoke is awesome. me and my coworkers favorite spot! super cool guy owns the place, and the guy that runs karaoke is phenomenal. plus kim the bartender is like no other. if you neet her you'll understand lol.“

“Family dining. Nice portions. Free veggie of the day. Outstanding deserts.“

“The FOOD especially the Bull chips and extra crispy wings. NOTHING LIKE IT“

“The Landmark restaurant in Youngstown, Ohio is a staple of the Westside. It’s simply one of the best places to get a great breakfast. The portion size for the price is very good. I usually go as soon as they open, not too crowded but it gets busy. You walk in and seat yourself, I usually like to grab a table. The seating options here are table, booths or the counter. I really enjoy the atmosphere here, early morning crowd of people getting ready for work or retired guys just enjoying their coffee. My waitress came over to me quickly, she was very pleasant. She then took my drink & breakfast order. She returned with my bottom-less coffee & water, there was a cup full of creamers on the table that I used to give my coffee the correct consistency. My meal was out a short time later, perfectly prepared, hot & correct. The best part of this place is after you finish your breakfast, you can stroll over to the bakery counter and get some amazing donuts. They make an Apple Fritter & Bear Claw the size of your head!!! They are big and amazing tasty, you simply must try them. They have a whole case of delicious donuts that I know you will enjoy. If you love a proper breakfast & delicious donuts, this is the place for you.“

“Recently attended a concert (Jim Brickman) on this smaller auditorium side. We've attended sold out concerts from this same artist on the larger orchestra side of Powers Auditorium. Definitely a different experience as it was a more intimate concert this time, especially due to the close proximity of basically all the seats on this smaller auditorium side. He said he had used this side for rehearsing during concerts he performed on the Powers Auditorium side, saying he loved performing on the larger, "orchestra " side, but wanted to return to have a concert one day on this stage that he also enjoyed for the close experience he could share with his audience.“

“In from out of town for the Easter Holiday weekend. Met family there Friday and had to have the Battered Fish and Crab Tacos. Absolutely fantastic!! Have not been here in a few years, and was great then, still great now! Service was typical spot on. We sat outside and lots of room. If you have not been here, come!!Parking: Plenty of parking, several open areas even on a Friday Fish Night!Wheelchair accessibility: There is a ramp, wheelchair accessible but probably requires some effort due to angle and door on the side lot. Didn't checkout the accessibility on the other entrance areas.“

“Loved fish night here, wanna come back on wing night. Food was so good.“

“The food is excellent & always cooked fresh as you order it. & I would suggest that newcomers try either the 5 or 10 piece breast strips or the 5 piece or 10 piece wing dings & always ask them to put sauce on everything (The wings, the breast strips, fries & all); That's the locals way. & they also have pretty good fish & rib dinners too. & The burgers are great too, just go see my good friends Big Dre & his brother & they'll hook you right up.“

“A little late on writing reviews so figured I'd start getting caught back up. This bar and grille is a local semi-dive bar with cold beer and terrific food. On this visit, my friend and I sat at the bar as it was busy due to a small work party going on as well. We enjoyed a cold beer while we perused the menu. They are known for their burgers but I was stuck on wanting to order the sausage sangwich and boy I was not disappointed. The sausage patty was absolutely delicious served topped with provolone, peppers and onions on a grilled bun and a side of fries to accompany (Sadly, I forgot to take pics). In asking one of the owner's who was behind the bar, he told me that the sausage is made locally right up the street at DePizzo's sausage. I know this place to have fantastic homemade sausage but a fire at their small facility shut them down a few years ago but they still make it in limited quantities and Shaker's is one of the beneficiaries of this deliciousness. The owner ended up chatting with us for approx. 45-minutes where he bought us a few rounds of beers on top of a few shots since Christmas was right around the corner. Great little spot and I need to get back to try their burgers. I'll update once I've done so.“

“My new favorite hang out! The wings are amazing, the prices are great. Service is wonderful. Plus it's a historic building in Youngstown so why not stop and visit. It's cozy with a laid back atmosphere where you can just relax with friends.“

“I don't like real noisy places that play rap music but I suffered through it to get some wings and a salad. Salad was huge excellent ranch dressing I think they make themselves, and wings I got garlic parmesan? Excellent excellent excellent. Service was okay but the“

“Had a soup n crab cake. Yummy on A cold night, Hit the spot. Hard to believe I was in the Yo- so good, great service too.“

“Very nice and friendly staff. The customers were all cool and you could tell most of them were regulars. We went for a birthday and the whole place customers and employees joined in on us singing Happy Birthday to him. Our waitress was awesome and so sweet. The food was delicious, especially the sweet potato fries with cinnamon butter. Definitely a ‘usual’ for me from here on out.“

“Breakfast was great! The staff was very nice too!“

“Had lunch there today it was absolutely delicious wood recommend this place for lunch“

“Pizza was ok. Wings were on point . We had one server for like 20 minutes, she told us her replacement would be over. He came over 30 minutes later mentions he's leaving and his replacement would be by. The replacement showed up almost 40 minutes after the last one already left. It was nonsense. Next time I'll eat at the bar. Much less confusing and better service.Also, put better descriptions on your online menu. I don't know what any of your sandwiches are if they've got some wacky name.“

“the waitress was pleasant, funny and knew just what needed to be said... the whole team made my morning a good one!“

“Food? Seriously? Well, not for the food. But for the beer, watching Gunsmoke on TV, and pool tables and darts, this is a damn nice joint. Open at 11 or noon every day, well except Mondays. Mondays is hit or miss, depends on if anyone answers the door. I’m kidding! And seriously. Two good bar pool tables. That and the ginger ale (I don’t even drink!) and the folks who patronize the place are why I like it here.“

“EXCELLENT food and service!!!! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5 stars“

“Really good wings! And good prices on beer!“

“This is the best family owned restaurant in town. You get to know the regulars and the staff who are fantastic. We go every weekend and love everything about it. The food is great and the prices are good. I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone who wants a close, family style place to dine.“

“Food was ok service was horrible waited 5 min to be seated with only 12 customer's people were waiting just as long to pay their bill waited half an hour for food to come then my food was barely warm and my dates order was wrong will never return to that store again“

“Great people great fun We always have a good time there“

“the customer service was amazing!!! i was greeted by the owner which is rare. Being in business for 15 years, still knowing the importance of customer service starting with the companys leader was unexpected. The inside of the building is amazing and it makes me feel like I'm in a sculpture I hope to be back asap!! let's not forget how good the food was! I ordered garlic Parmesan with Mac n cheese, very delicious. will definitely be back!“

“The pledge of allegiance was awesome . most customers stood. Protien bowl is the best meal that I have had at a Bob Evans.“

“First timer. Good vibe. Three birthdays that night. Everyone for the most part was masked up. Music was on FIYAH S/O DJ Word. Small but accommodating. Cameras and security. Closed at 10pm so the barmaids were working overtime. They deserved every tip and some.“