4 Best Italian Restaurants near Stillwater

“My husband and I came here for Valentine's Day and had a great experience. There aren't many Italian options here in Stillwater, so I honestly came in without great expectations. Our server was friendly, attentive, and on top of things, which made us feel welcome but not overwhelmed. The bread was complimentary and just fine. We ordered the fried calamari, which was nice and crispy, and the marinara sauce was amazing, so I sopped that up with the bread. We also ordered the shrimp diavolo, which was really good and had a hefty amount of seafood. My husband ordered something with sausage and peppers on it, and it was alright, but paled in comparison to the diavolo sauce, which was the star of the show, with the right balance of spicy and salty with a hint of acid. For dessert we had a slice of limoncello cake and it was light and delicious. Will be back to try the rest of the menu.“

“They've got BEERS!!!!!Edit: It's been five years since I last came to this Mazzio's, and it's been too long. They have THE crispiest crust of any thin crust I've ever eaten (when most Mazzio's send me a soggy mess of a pizza).“

“The wait staff was so pleasant and kind. The food was hot and tasty, and the atmosphere was welcoming and cheerful. Good service, attention to cleanliness, and portion sizes. Prices are steep, but that's a consistent feature of this restaurant chain.“

“I enjoy D'Mario's. The pizza is a style that is very different so I like it from time to time. In particular I like the crust. However, I do think it's way overpriced. Once I mentioned it and the employee said it was due to the quality of ingredients but Hideaway's pizza in Stillwater uses quality ingredients and it's cheaper.“