31 Best Italian Restaurants near Gibsonia

“Silvionis shut down so we were looking for a place that wasn’t the Olive Garden. After checking out the menu online we decided to check it out. Absolute sleeper. You could drive past this place and not even notice it. Our table had the steak hoagie, Italian sausage hoagie, fettuccine alfredo, and chicken with angel hair. The pasta is made fresh and is the read deal. Didn’t try the pizza but want to. Our group loved the food AND service, and we’ll be back!“

“great food, great service, and wine!!! beautiful“

“We had a memorial luncheon there and the food was fantastic! Our waitress was wonderful!!! ☆☆☆☆☆“

“This cafe is great any time of day--everything is homemade and delicious and the menu changes a little every day. The pastries and espresso are great early in the day, and then the arancini, pizza, and pasta are wonderful at dinner. They have a nice selection of drinks, including sangria on-tap! We will definitely be back here regularly to enjoy more of the wonderful food and ambiance.“

“Alta Via is definitely a favorite place of mine now. Tonight was my third time coming, and our server Eddie was absolutely amazing. He saved our night! (We had a horrible experience at another resturaunt, so we left and came to Alta Via in Market Square!) He was so attentive to our needs and really went above and beyond! Food is always delicious, drinks are amazing and the focaccia bread they bring out is to die for. Highly recommend! And ask for Eddie at the Market Square location!“

“my boyfriend and i tried pelegrino’s after we got sent a menu from them in the mail. we each got a pizza, and the cost was INCREDIBLY lower than the other pizza places we’ve ordered from. they deliver as well, which is nice. what i also appreciate about pelegrino’s is the option for online ordering, which allows me to pay & tip so i don’t have to fumble whenever the delivery comes. it takes some time, but it’s always worth the wait; we’ve never been disappointed!! this is our go to pizza spot!!“

“Great food, nice people. Good time“

“Hands down best place to eat in western PA. Bob, owner, is a gem. Feels like family when you go there. He treats my son like his own. Support the locals forever“

“We had a memorial luncheon there and the food was fantastic! Our waitress was wonderful!!! ☆☆☆☆☆“

“Very good restaurant that recommended to anyone who wants to have a fine dinner but sad they closing the doors so please try to support them before they close.“

“I stopped into SIMPLE SUBS today. I CHOSE A CHEESESTEAK SUB. IT WAS DELICIOUS. IF YOU HAVE NEVER STOPPED IN YOU SHOULD TRY IT OUT CUZ IT'S GREAT.“

“Called ahead for a Saturday night reservation on a Saturday morning...got a reservation 15 minutes from requested time and was seated promptly.Read the recent reviews, therefore, did not order fried zucchini, or any appetizer, as thep portions were described as large, and they were!The wedding soup was served steaming hot with tender meatballs; could have used more pepper.Ordered two entrees;Alla pescatore, which contrary to recent reviews, was served with firm, not mushy linguine. Garlickly flavor aand could have been tastier with some red pepper flakes.Neptune, with veal, was one of the few entrees served without pasta. Good flavor and about twice a normal portion.We ate half of each entree, and shared a tiramasu for dessert...delicious!!B.Y.O.B.Classic Italian restaurant that is worth trying!Gigantic portion sizBYOBNeptune, veal,...tender and rich flavor“

“I want to shout-out Pietro’s for excellent customer service. Pietro’s is our favorite pizza place around us and we normally order through Grubhub. We love their variety of pizza and the Sicilian is a family favorite. There was an unfortunate issue today which was not a fault of their own where someone had stolen our order and when the new driver went to pick it up there was no order there. Grubhub rectified the money portion and gave us a credit, but we got a personal call from the restaurant which told us exactly what had happened, and how they wanted to make sure as regulars we weren’t mad at them. Honestly it meant so much to my wife and I and we will be ordering from them very shortly because one the pizza is great but 2, the service is even better.“

“CC's hosted our company luncheon and did a fantastic job! Excellent service and delicious food!“

“We had a wonderful experience. Wayne was our server.. loved him! Fantastic service! I had the gnoccis, sauce was very reminiscent of my grandmothers... in other words, perfect. My husband had the lasagna, he loved it. The complimentary breadsticks were delicious.. the house salad was also great. Highly recommend!“

“The thin and the thick square (sicilian) were excellent! I'm a total pizza snob and tried both and am so glad that I did! This was my 1st time trying as I don't live in this area and I'm totally impressed. Can't wait to order again! The owners were very nice and everything was ready on time and hot!“

“I had a HUGE craving for a chicago style deep dish pizza after watching a review on one. I searched for 'deep dish butler' and got this restaurant! So worth the roughly 30 minute drive. Not only was the deep dish incredible, the garlic knots were the best I've ever had. I got my food to go, but the inside was very cute! Just pay attention to where you pull into the parking lot... they have a HUGE sign that says 'do not enter' but as I was leaving someone tried pulling in and near missed running right into me.“

“Food and service was great! FYI…they add convenience charge if paying with card!“

“We had the Sicilian with sausage and the white pizza with tomato and ricotta. Both of the pizza’s were delicious. The atmosphere was very nice & the staff was friendly and attentive making for an overall great experience!“

“best pizza around. owners are great people also. love to go here when im in the area. a must try pizza“

“The food here is TO DIE FOR!!! And the service is awesome“

“Great food and great service!“

“We stopped in for our first time yesterday, The delicious aroma hits you the instant you open the door. Our waitress was very nice to work with and our pizza was amazing, The crust and fresh toppings left us no room for dessert. We will stop again!“

“The visit to the North Hills Olive Garden Italian Restaurant was outstanding. Food was perfectly done, and the service provided by Megan was great!!!!! It was the perfect place to have a meal of comfort food on a raw cold rainy ? miserable late winter's Saturday night ?. The custom design your own pasta meal is a great feature of the Olive Gardens menu.The only downside item, and it's a minor one,was that there was not enough salad dressing for the salad bowl, and the salad dressing wasn't quite up to the taste standards that I have enjoyed in the past.For instance, the dressing at the Upper St. Clair location in Pittsburgh's south hills.Otherwise, it was a wonderful meal. And again, outstanding service.“

“THANK YOU! I always get pizza delivered, but accidentally hit pick-up last week. I called wondering where my pizza was, only to find out my mistake. I asked if I could switch to delivery and they said yes, it would probably be about 30 minutes…no problem. It was at my door in less than 10 minutes! Great customer service even though I was the one that made a mistake.“

“Nice, cozy place, basic Italian menu, food quality and preparation were pretty good. Service pleasant with a few miscues. One of our party ordered a veal dish that came with mashed potatoes; she asked to substitute some pasta for the potatoes and was charged $9 for the substitution; this seems like gouging.“

“Hands down best place to eat in western PA. Bob, owner, is a gem. Feels like family when you go there. He treats my son like his own. Support the locals forever“

“We enjoyed our visit to this amazing restaurant.If you’re looking for great service, amazing food , at a reasonable price you can find it here.It is literally a step into time where families gather to share a a delicious meal and enjoy the experience.“

“We drove rwo hours to pick up a Facebook marketplace find and had luch at sicilianos- oh my goodness, it was so delcious! We had italian hoagies- the best I’ve ever eaten with a side of broccoli salad that was to die for! This food alone was worth the drive,and all served up by the most friendly and wonderful people-amazing!!?“

“We ordered dinner this evening. My husband had a whole meatball hoagie. He said it was really good and has enough left over for another meal. I had a crispy chicken salad bit had a good variety of veggies and plenty of chicken. I also had a few breadsticks on the side. Everything was delicious.“

“Love this place. Great pizza and atmosphere“