Custom Cakes in Pittsburgh, PA

“Amy's bakery is a staple in Mount Lebanon. Whenever I am in the area, I find myself stopping by to try something new. The pastries and desserts are not only delicious, but unique and authentic. I appreciate that the bakery items are not too sweet, yet still packed with flavor. You can taste the soulfulness in each bite! The cherry on top is the welcoming atmosphere and friendly service.“

“Started going to this place last year and it's become a favorite for some ice cream on a nice day. ☀️ The inside is nothing special but they have a large variety of different flavors and the prices are pretty reasonable. Great spot!“

“Their cakes are delicious and everyone that works there is helpful, friendly and accommodating. Highly recommend the carrot cake -- they made me a walnut-free version at my request. I have loved everything I have tried from here!“

“We absolutely loved our vegan wedding cake from The Butterwood Bake Consortium for our Summer 2023 wedding. The team at Butterwood Bake Consortium was kind and communicative. Our two-tiered orange olive oil cake with vanilla semi-naked buttercream was so delicious and the florals were the perfect touch for our wedding theme! I highly recommend for all your wedding cake needs!!! Photography: @nicoleviews photography“

“I ordered a Neapolitan pastry and it was fantastic. A very refreshing and surprisingly light breakfast.The staff was very familial and treats their regulars with great care. If I'm ever back in the area I will definitely stop by again to sample some more. Strawberries seemed fresh and the cream was wonderful.“

“Always great ice cream and the girl serving was very kind and hard-working!“

“Easy pre-ordering. Friendly staff. Lots of parking. Clean store. Lots of variety. Reasonable prices compared to other local ice cream shops. My cake was very tasty. The only things is less of a complaint and more of a suggestion but the custom cakes are sort of plain. Nothing that really makes the cakes stand out amongst the rest but it sure was delicious!“

“Absolutely excellent service, the person there was very kind and helpful and absolutely made a stressful night a bit better. We had an ice shake (new to us) and a milkshake, and it was great.Vegetarian options: They had vegan ice cream available.“

“I ordered a custom cake (serving 40) and it was DELICIOUS!! Loved that they wrote the message in different font. The cake was fresh moist, not over the top sweet, just perfectly sweet, and buttercream frosting ?. They were sold out of the burnt almond torte, but I bought a single serving of it, really GOOD!“