5 Best Italian Restaurants near Southampton

“Visited Angelos's on Friday, 9/29/23 for late lunch. Had several out of town Family members (10) and 3 babies with me. Dana was our server. She was very friendly, and excellent waitress. With 3 babies in our group was a little hectic at times. Food as usual was delicious. Some ate Pasta, others had cheese steaks. Food always fresh. Tony is was so great seeing you again. Thanks to Dana for making our dining experience memorable. Always 5 stars, but really should be 10. Will be back again real soon. Sincerely, Carmella Donaghy“

“Being a transplant from northern Jersey I have been hunting for 17 years for a great Brooklyn pie in the area. I've finally found it! Then there's the polenta, omg! You don't see that on many menus so I had to get it. It is simply outstanding!“

“We often order from Southampton Pizzeria. Their food is always consistently delicious, they're generally very quick, & always friendly. Last night one of the items in our order was mixed up & we didn't realize until we came home from picking it up. I called and they were so find & gracious! They apologized (things happen so I was not mad about it). They immediately made my item again fresh, and delivered it to my house. It was so quick & they were extremely caring!“

“I highly recommend using DiCarlo restaurant for catering. The food was delicious, and they provided so much food. We will be using them for every event that we need to have catered.“

“Tom and Dylan are the most personable bartenders. They really make you feel at home. Always at your service and ready to provide you with great help. Really love these guys and will come back. Great service great people over here at Maggios.“