25 Best American Restaurants in Pigeon Forge

“Don't let the exterior fool you, this is as local and fresh a restaurant as you will find. From baking their own bread and burger buns to making the ketchup in-house, Local Goat takes "freshly made" seriously. The fried deviled eggs are killer, each egg perfectly topped with a piece of candied bacon, a few fresh scallions, and a micro-dollup of sriracha. The pimento cheese burger marries the sharper cheese with sweet carmelized onions perfectly. And the hot honey chicken sandwich is as good as you fill find. They have a bar mixing great cocktails and pouring local beers - the Blackberry Mountain Tea is very refreshing. All in all a great experience. Pro tip - contrary to what you may think, the bar is quieter than the main room, significantly so. I would return and bring foodie friends.“

“Awesome place and huge portions.“

“Great experience for my first time! Kids enjoyed it as well!“

“Awesome place and huge portions.“

“The experience was more than I was expecting. When walking in, you get a family photo with the family. Then you're in a waiting area where gentlemen play some music. If you're not joining in with the song, they will call you out on it and make fun of you and tease you, which is hilarious. In the show, there's nonstop action with plenty of laughs and delicious food throughout the evening. A very friendly atmosphere for kids and families of all ages. Highly recommend.Vegetarian options: When ordering tickets you can select If you are vegetarian and they will have meals prepped for you.Dietary restrictions: When ordering tickets you can select if you're dairy free or gluten-free and they will have meals prepped for you.“

“First time visitor. Won't be the last. Had the BBQ bacon burger, wife had the chickjita and our child had the tacoverit. Also had the heath and Caramel shake, the smore and banana pudding shake. All the food and desserts were fantastic. Service was top notch.“

“Great food and friendly staff. I would recommend especially for the kids.“

“Did the tasting with Missy and she was great. Made this so much fun and would recommend everyone to do it.“

“Always the best. Been eating here 25 plus years. Service is second to none“

“This will be our new go-to Pancake House! The restaurant was crowded, but we were seated immediately and received our delicious food quickly! The ladies that greeted us when we arrived were so welcoming and sweet. Our server was so precious and helpful, too!“

“Great food, atmosphere and service!“

“Just left the restaurant. Food was very good..hot and served to order. Good atmosphere, great server. His name was John. Took good care of us, refills, rolls to the table, and checked back frequently. All in all, a great dining experience!“

“The food is the best if all of the dinner shows in the area. Our server cousin Devin was outstanding. Food is served family style and they bring more than enough. Seating for the dinner and show is at tables of 2, 4 or more. Music is fantastic and the show is a comedy. I feel like the food, service and show beats everybody.“

“Puckett’s catered our son’s wedding rehearsal dinner. Food was delivered right on time, set up for us, hot & ready to serve. Plenty of food & everything was delicious! Thanks to Christina!“

“Everything was great food,service. There is a waitresses named Katelynn that was very rude and disrespectful to my senior mother in law and Aunt not just once but three times. we give Everything else 5 stars great place“

“Incredible food and our server CJ was great! Highly recommend!“

“The staff was so friendly. Best hashbrowns anywhere! I don’t have to order them extra crispy because they already come that way!“

“Our server was Mike and he was awesome! He went above and beyond with giving great service and we just loved the way he interacted with us and found out he had previously lived in Florida not far from us. The food was absolutely delicious and in our opinion better than the Savannah restaurant. Thank you Mike for a fun experience!“

“All the food was delicious. The kids loved the experience. I chose applesauce as their side and the portion was underwhelming, but the quality of the main courses was excellent. The game card for the kids was a nice touch. The quality and variety of the games in the arcade was so fun and entertaining. As an OT and mom I appreciate they have a nursing room and calming room for overstimulated kids (or adults!). Great addition to Pigeon Forge!“

“The Old Mill Creamery is a well stocked ice cream shop with a super friendly staff. The stock a large variety of ice cream flavors as well as muffins and other delicious treats. There is also a very nice outdoor seating area with tables and chairs for the use of their customers.Vegetarian options: Very few meat itemsDietary restrictions: Be aware of restrictions before ordering.Parking: Large lot across streetKid-friendliness: Very kid friendlyWheelchair accessibility: Fully accessible“

“The food was very good, but I can’t believe that u should have your dog set on a chair and then let it eat off the table, I love dogs and cats, but there’s a cut off point at some time.“

“Awesome little dive bar on the side of a Mexican restaurant (which we didn’t eat at but is always busy) everyone is super friendly and great service! Its open status is based on weather as all the windows swing open. You can smoke in here - which we don’t smoke and it didn’t bother us at all.“

“Fast service. All our orders were correct. Everyone was friendly. The only reason I'm giving 4 stars is because it had a not so great smell. We were seated close to the restrooms so I'm not sure if that's what it was or something else.“

“You're coming for the vibes. The food is decent and not greasy. The flavor is on par with other options on the strip. The chickens were fun, and the staff was friendly. I'd say this is a great option for families with young children.“

“Best food, and amazing service!! Our server Ashley made us feel very welcome and took great care of us! Good prices! 10/10“