20 Best Pizza Restaurants near Hayes

“Most authentic Italian food for miles. 10/10“

“We ordered the ultimate cheese lovers pizza and added bacon. So DELICIOUS! Perfect amount of blended cheeses made with Alfredo sauce! The wings were not what I expected but they were good too. We ordered the bone out wings, they look like popcorn chicken but they are wings I guess, either way they were a hit. They deliver to Yogi Bear Campground Resort, you just have to pick up your order from the ranger station, we liked that they called when they were here so we weren't left wondering if the pizza was delivered. You are able to pay a tip ahead of time as well making delivery contactless. Delivery was fast. We will definitely order from them again on our next camp stay.“

“In my opinion, Papa Johns is the best take-out pizza chain. I have always found these pizzas to be made better than most other Papa Johns locations. I placed an online order for a specific pickup time, but arrived early. The staff here saw this and made my pizzas fresh such that I did not have to keep waiting. As I had my baby son with me, they even offered to carry my order to my car.“

“it was not good at all. it was hard and cold. It tasted like old food. it is too expensive for the food to be like that.“

“Been eating this pizza for 30 years, since they were originally in NYC to now and it’s STILL the best pie in town. So glad they came here!“

“We made a special trip to give these a try and they did not disappoint. The donuts were gigantic (the size of my toddlers head!), soft dough and our selection was flavorful. We tried the coconut cream and strawberry glaze.“

“One of the best if not the BEST Italian restaurant in Virginia. My friend and I were in total awe. After living in Italy for 4 years I can say, I felt like I was back. The restaurant is owned by a Sicilian family, and you could taste that with every bite you took of the absolutely scrumptious food. It was so wonderful. The location of the restaurant is in a shopping center but don’t be deceived by that once you walk in your back in Italy. Many little restaurants like this there!!! I can’t wait to go back. You won’t be disappointed. ❤️❤️“

“Food was fresh and delicious! Customer Service was phenomenal! The guy that delivered my food was very friendly and patient. This is my new spot. Please stay in business at this location forever. You guys rock! Thank You so much! Keep It Up! Great Customer Service still does exist!“

“We just happened to stop in and I'm happy we did. We had the pizza lunch special. Yes big NY slices and they was delicous. And we also tried their own special seasoning..also delicous. Lisa the staff that was helping us was great. Very attentive and informative. Her customer service made dining there a plus. I will definitely return.“

“The service and food were exceptional; excellent, fresh, hot homemade with so many choices! Our group is returning tomorrow & my family has also raved about the food choices, preparation, & service! It’s truly authentic & has such a variety beyond the usual Italian restaurants!“

“I ordered food to be delivered. The order was promptly made and quickly arrived. The fries are cooked perfectly, not a fan of the ranch at all. The burger was great with fresh ingredients. I wish there was more of a description of the food in the app because I didn’t know it came with tomatoes. The mozzarella sticks are crispy and fat with cheese! Not a fan of the marina sauce, a bit too watery for me. Next time I will try their pizza.“

“All around great place to order from the online went smooth and even had a worker. Call and confirm to check with an order that had doubled to make sure that it wasn’t ordered twice very nice. Excellent customer service and food was hot and fresh when we got it hands-down best pizza delivery place, keep up the good “

“Warm and welcoming restaurant. The food is genuinely fresh and very good, the chef is really very good. The pizza is absolutely phenomenal. the service is very excellent, polite, serious and very professional staff, a fantastic experience. highly recommended“

“Food is pretty much always fresh, (hot and ready). The staff are all polite well mannered and helpful. Most of all patient, their was an elderly man in front of me in line the last time I came in to pick up a pizza. He was clearly somewhat confused about his order, and seemed slightly overwhelmed. Cause by this time the line had grown to around 8 customers. He started to say nevermind and leave, not wanting to hold everyone up, I assume. The young man behind the counter politely pulled the gentleman aside while another employee stepped up to take my order. After I already told them to take their time with the gentleman who was first. I could wait the extra few minutes. I was glad to see young men showing an elderly man respect and patience. By not letting him get flustered and give up.I couldn't recommend this establishment more. It's obvious they take pride in their work as well as their interaction with the public.“

“So many times we have ordered and every time the pizza has been delicious and the staff has been lovely. We ordered tonight, the night before Thanksgiving. Despite it being a hectic night for them with only one driver on staff, they got our pizza to us as quickly as possible with amazing customer service!“

“Great pizzas and calzones. This is one of two go-to Italian restaurants in the VA middle peninsula. Restaurant is clean and comfortable.Servers can be a little inattentive (Eg Not checking in after food is delivered) but nothing that can’t be improved with training or a friendly reminder from management.“

“Delicious Baked Ziti. They did a wonderful job on it. It was busy but I got a salad with the wrong dressing and it was a while until I got the dressing corrected. I had to ask twice. They were very nice and I'm sure this won't be a typical problem. Next time I'm going to order the garlic knots!?Parking: This restaurant is located in a strip shopping center so there is plenty of parking.“

“This was my first time eating here. I ordered a large Stromboli and was amazed at how big it was. I was thinking around 12 inches but it was way bigger, and loaded with what toppings were ordered. Now i see why people recommend them; I will definitely be going back.“

“I would've given 5 stars, but 4 is more reasonable. Came in to get food for pickup. When we pull up, lobby is BARE! 1 folding chair and that's it. We ordered our food, lady was nice about it. Food is reasonably priced. Fiance ordered a pizza with ham, black olive, pepperoni. Instead of black olive, he got mushroom. He called the restaurant to fix it. Since it was a pickup, they wanted us to come back to pick it up. Mind you, we live about 6 miles away. So instead, we got a $15 store credit. We will come back as it is good. Check your food before leaving though“

“I placed an online order for 2 pizzas tonight, one gluten free and one regular…. had a slight issue with them but it was immediately resolved upon calling the store. The manager Joe was absolutely incredible and very attentive, he was quick to offer solutions to my concerns. The whole staff was very kind and polite when I entered the store. I would 100% recommend this store and company.“