20 Best Pizza Restaurants in Williamsburg

“After a late night at Busch gardens, our family of 6 cruised by and was very pleasantly surprised by how DELICIOUS the food was.At first, the service was slow to start, but their amazing mozzarella sticks were impressive to say the least. The generous Prosecco pour was greatly appreciated followed by the from scratch Italian wedding soup which was out of this world.The family enjoyed bruschetta, meatball parm subs, cheesesteak subs, a buffalo chicken pizza, and kids tenders and cheese ravioli which was all absolutely spectacular.I honestly can’t wait to go back to Busch gardens so we can eat here again! Definitely recommend!“

“Was trying to do the survey on line, but it kept telling me it was down, so I'm just going to write a review. Went to Mellow Mushroom for the first time on April 12th and our server was Autumn. She was the best! She had the best personality, very knowledgeable with the menu and very attentive. We loved it so much we returned on April 14th and was very happy to have Autumn again. Thank you Autumn for making my first time a very positive experience. If I'm ever in the area again I will definitely go back and hope to have Autumn again.“

“Exquisite local Italian food. Ingredients were so fresh. Had a great and lively environment. Our server, Chip, was amazing. Our drinks never went empty, our table was cleared promptly, and he was very pleasant. We ordered the mozzarella sticks to start, which we thought were just okay. We would have liked more seasoning on the breadcrumbs. The bread was cold. Salads were average. However, the entrees did not disappoint. The lemon butter chicken pasta was divine. Has just the right amount of lemon taste. The 4 cheese tortellini was delicious as well. The sauce was what made the dish so delicious. However, the chicken parm was the star of the show. Everything about it was perfection. Overall, we would come again. Portions were large enough to split and we were still stuffed. We will have to come back for dessert.“

“Like me you are looking around for some real pizza after a wonderful day in Williamsburg. Your search has ended, just come here. Perfect cheese to sauce to dough ratio. Nice thin slice. Best pizza I've had in a while. I can't speak much about the other shops in town but at Olde Town Pizza you won't be disappointed. Enjoy! Also Balsamic Vinaigrette is special on the salad.“

“I'm late on this review. We went around Christmas time. On the way to Busch Gardens for the Christmas lights. Which I will also review. I have to say that this was the most delicious pizza I have ever eaten in my life. My bf happens to know the owner and has worked on his hvac and refrigeration years ago when they were smaller. There were 4 of us in our group. We shared a large pepperoni pizza. Despite the line out the door that night we got our pizza and we were eating within 30 minutes. Want to warn you if you see a table open have a member of the party grab it lol unless you plan to eat outside on the curb or car. Lol. The bathrooms were surprising clean and well stocked despite the amount of traffic coming thru. I have told everyone I know going in that direction that you absolutely will not be disappointed.“

“We came to Francesco’s tonight not knowing what to expect and by the tone we walked out, we knew we’d be back! Vinny was a gracious server and made us feel extremely welcome. The handmade pastas were to die for! And my daughter really enjoyed the pizza. Whatever you do, don’t skip the excellent desserts.“

“Pizza was pretty good. They have several higher end ingredients for anyone who doesn't want a plain pizza. The person working acted like we were bothering him to be there. ?‍♀️ Didn't rate the atmosphere, this is definitely a to-go spot.“

“The food is fantastic! This was our first time trying! We will definitely be returning! Flavors and seasoning are on point! Value for the money for the portion size I feel are so amazing and so appreciated. Thank You! Also we highly recommend. Thank you so very much for our very generous customer service! We will definitely be returning for delicious food and amazing customer service. Top knots! All the way around!!!!! Thank you again!“

“We live about 90 minutes from the restaurant, but had heard about it. Went for lunch today, and it was delicious. Fantastic pizza and smoked wings. We were celebrating my birthday, so shared the tiramisu. Wonderful. Everyone was so friendly too.“

“We love a slice and a salad here. Great variety and delicious tastes. The owner is a character and is very lively. The seating is at a premium and on a cold day, anywhere close to the door is a chilly prospect, but overall it is a great place to eat.“

“Our server, Jace, was friendly, knowledgeable, efficient and enthusiastic about the food. The burgers were DELICIOUS! Best I've had since moving to Williamsburg. We got the cheese bread appetizer as well (I don't recall the name) and it was good. Loved the texture. I wish there was more flavor in the cheese or seasonings, but the Marinara sauce was flavorful.“

“We stopped after driving by and reading the wonderful reviews. We were NOT disappointed! The pizza was fantastic, the seafood pot pie was delicious, and all 3 of the sweet pies (Chocolate pecan, Bumbleberry, and Key Lime) we tried were amazing! The staff were more than welcoming and friendly. A hidden gem for sure! Most definitely recommend and can't wait to be back!!!“

“We wrapped up Busch Gardens and were absolutely famished! The NCAA Sweet 16 games were on deck, but finding a good family friendly sportsbar in Williamsburg was a but challenging. I honed in on Highway Pizza as it seemed unique with fun decor. Thankfully, it was a great choice!It happened to be bike night so my son enjoyed seeing the bikes outside. Everyone at the establishment was super friendly and helpful. We were immediately seated, and when we asked to put on a hockey game that was on ESPN+, they subscribed to the App so that they could air the game! Now that is customer service!We soon got our drinks and an order of the Speed Bumps (pizza rolls). I highly recommend the Speed Bumps, totally delish! Next we ordered boneless wings with the garlic parmesan and hot buffalo options. Both excellent and cooked perfectly. We went heavy on the wings so we're stuffed after this.If you're in town and want a good sportsbar, look no further than Highway Pizza! Oh, and you have to check out the bathroom.. lol my son got quite a kick out of it!“

“This was a quick service food truck located next to a brewery. They have covered outdoor seating, and it's dog friendly, which is a HUGE plus! Our pup loved getting a treat from the workers and sniffing around while we waited for our food. The only downside was the limited vegetarian options, but we ordered the Gouda Griller, and it was good. Next time, we will have to try the cheese curds.“

“A friend has been telling me about this place for quite a while and I finally made it. It was so delicious! I will definitely be making reoccurring trips to partake in this delightful pizza. I love the variety of options and the service staff are great.“

“Neighborhood take out and we had a small pizza with peperoni and mushroom. The small was large enough for 3 or a modest 4. Peperoni had a little spice, well sprinkled on the pizza and the mushroom were decent slices as opposed to bits on other competitors. The pizza was well cooked and not burned. We had plenty left over for lunch the next door warming in a frying pan with a touch of olive oil. Will order again for take out.“

“Very good pizza! Was traveling through here since I had to make a haul tomorrow morning so I decided to stop in and grab a pizza and beer for myself. The pizza with Pepperoni will be fine, I just wouldn't recommend the Italian sausage on it as it detracts some of the flavor imo. The fried mozzarella sticks were alright, nothing too special.Server and hostess helped answer my questions very well and will definitely be visiting again when I make a haul back around this area again.“

“I was in the Commons as part of a tour for 9th graders from Argentina and New Hampshire. There was an amazing array of all types of food. From oven fire pizza to made to order omelets to a huge salad bar to Brussel sprouts and so much more. Dessert was everything from decadent brownies to fruit to ice cream to cake and more. Our two groups sampled almost everything. All of the offerings were delicious. The servers were all very welcoming and quick. It was very impressive. I'd love to go again.“

“My husband and I love the food at the Gyro Palace. My husband was born in Greece and we both know authentic Greek food. This is it! Casual atmosphere with very tasty Greek food. We've been here numerous times and it is always great and reasonably priced.Parking: Parking is plentiful and right next to the restaurant.“

“Easy to order. Employees are busy but they pay attention to customers coming in the door. Food was prepared properly and was hot when I got it. Glad we have it here in Lightfoot.Parking: You can pull right up out in front of the restaurant which is only a few steps away.“