18 Best Pizza Restaurants in Sheboygan

“This is amazing pizza. We have tried at least 8 different kinds and they are all so great.“

“The food is so good. Wonderful Smokehouse, great menu with plenty of selections and weekly specials. We were there on a Tuesday and had AYCE Ribs.The service is superb. Like most restaurants, they are understaffed, but they never made us feel rushed. Everyone was polite and professional.When you stop in, you have try one of their many varied Bloody Mary's.I personally prefer Bloody Maria's (tequila instead)We have been to their locations in Sheboygan and Green Bay. We will definitely be going back.“

“Great place with delicious food! The pizza and pasta are awesome.“

“My mom and I were in town for a short getaway. We stopped in for dinner and had the best time! The food was amazing and the service provided by Joey was outstanding. We’ll be back when we come back to town. Thank you for the authentic food and service!“

“Awesome place, would go back!“

“Pizza is amazing! Definitely recommend!!“

“Great food and service. kid friendly. Big booths and comfortable atmosphere.“

“Great pizza love the thin crust !! Thanks“

“My go to place for pizza. It’s the cheapest baked pizza with ok quality in town. Could use more ingredients we ask for at times. Example, a back pizza should be covering at least 75% of the pizza? I still think it’s better than Little Cesar and it’s baked fresh and cheaper to buy than P P apa John’s. I only wish they deliver. Also if you’re ordering here and want a great pizza, ask to make your pizza “Seasoned Crust”. It’s not on the menu I don’t think but it makes the pizza a little greasier. Would I eat here again? Yes.“

“We had a friendly greeting and great service from Arizona when we arrived. She was very patient with us because it was our first time at Toppers.We enjoyed a medium thin crust pepperoni and black olive pizza and a half pound of boneless chicken wings with BBQ sauce on the side (special price of $7.99 each) and 2 20 oz. sodas.Everything was delicious (especially considering the price). We will definitely be returning again soon!!Thank you Arizona and Blake for the wonderful dinner and service!!“

“First, I'm from New England where real pizza is made. So, cheese heads, pay attention!This is probably one of the best and closest thing to east coast pizza I've ever had in Wisconsin. This mini pizza was delicious, and a perfect size for a husky guy like me on a diet (after I already ate some chicken fried rice from the farmer's market... honestly I just wanted pizza).Excellent sauce to cheese to crust ratio.Caution: the "spicy" sausage isn't spicey by east coast standards, so i was both let down and happy that I wouldn't be coughing and trying to clear my throat going back to work. There wasnt any cheddar cheese (pizza should never come with cheddar... so they know something!), and I don't understand why green peppers are so popular instead of red peppers. Oh well.This Peobody's special was packed with flavor, cooked fast (12 minutes when I was told 15), and very affordable. I'd give it 4 stars, but the guy was friendly and this is Wisconsin, so it gets 5.But my taste buds are now salivating for the reviews of their taco pizza. I'll be back!“

“Great pizza. First time trying it today and it’s great! Delivery came fast and the delivery driver even left the dog some treats!!!“

“Recently discovered this terrific neighborhood bar and restaurant. The owner (Dayton) is a very friendly guy and experienced chef. His premium pub style fare is delish and exceptionally well priced. Excellent craft beer selection, drink specials every night, brisket nachos etc during Packer games, the bartenders (Gail and Lisa) are fun, enthusiastic, and talented cooks. It's become a new favorite spot in town for my gal and myself. Plenty of pool / darts / games etc for additional entertainment. Pro Tip: Try the Double Time burger with curry mayo and ghost pepper cheese on a pretzel bun. It can't be beat!“

“I came in for a set of darts after calling. I called one bar, which directed me to this one. I found a cozy little nock and a friendly environment with the guy at the bar being very helpful and informative. I'll stop by to shoot some darts soon!“

“It was much better than the first time I was there a few years ago. Service was OUTSTANDING. I had the grilled spicy shrimp tacos. I liked them. It's not as good as others I've had. I think the ratio of coleslaw is too high. There was just something missing. The best shrimp tacos are Time Out in Manitowoc. I wish somewhere local could create them.“

“Pizza was good, tables and eating area were very clean. But the manager was very rude and short temper, I was told not to come back.“

“Been a long time since I've been to a Pizza Ranch. Think the last time was pre-covid. This place exceeded my expectations. My husband & I are traveling right now & he said he wanted to go. So this one was closest stop on the way. This was around the typical dinner rush time. None of the workers were standing around. Always refilling the stations, picking up dishes at tables, cleaning up tables when people left. Food was hot & fresh. We were pleased with service, food, cleanliness & selections available. Thank You.“