5 Best Italian Restaurants near Islamorada

“Food is so authentic and delicious! Service is excellent! I would definitely try this restaurant if you are in the area!“

“Very friendly, salad was amazing, fast service with old school pricing... or at least better pricing than most places, especially for the portions! 80's nostalgia all over including an original Atari with joysticks and other nostalgia that could've came straight from my bedroom. Pinball machines & video games adorn the place. It was crowded on a Tuesday night so you know people must be loyal for a long time. Would go back and would recommend“

“First off Rick the manager was so great to work with. We had a big group of 25 people and they gave us a table outside by the water that we could all sit at. He saved us parking spots as we had 18 separate cars as it was a car rally down to Islamorada for lunch. The food was amazing and the waiter was amazing. The view from the table was amazing. We appreciate all Island Grill and Rick did for us and we all had a great time.Parking: We had 18 cars and there was parking for all. There were plenty of others cars there as well so there were plenty of parking spots.“

“After 6 days at Cheeca Lodge ate at Mia Cucina our last night. Wish we had done it sooner. The homemade pasta was superb, as was the laid back atmosphere. Our server Gary was simply the best server we had in the keys period - and a great representative of the “Cheeca way”.“

“Totally Disappointed, I would have to think really hard if I would be willing to return. My Yellow fin tuna was JUST plain ok, nothing great.The diet cola in my cocktails (both even after I complained about it to Michelle) was FLAT...probably generic...that would be ok if carbonated CORRECTLY. I ordered a rum & diet cola DOUBLE TALL, what I got was a medium glass, not my tall but when in Rome, so I accept ...A weak pour...so being a smaller glass than what I'm used to. A double pour should have been strong....NOT the case...I may have to go back up the street To CAPTAIN CRAIGS.“