11 Best Pizza Restaurants in New Albany

“Amazing food! Had the Rob Deep Dish, my fam got their own pizza and sandwiches they also loved. I asked for a substitution of bacon to replace the ham. They had a mix up and forgot to put the substitution in, which is fine -things happen. Unexpectedly, they comped me the messed up pizza and made me a whole new deep dish! Maybe I’m from an area with crappy restaurants but being left the food AND getting a replacement was a breath of fresh air! Will definitely return to eat some more delicious food“

“Decided to try this place because it was near our hotel. I'm not much of a pizza lover but I got the Deluxe and It was so good I decided to go back a second night to try another kind. 2nd night I got the pulled pork pizza. I was hesitant because of Sriracha BBQ? But it was soooo worth it! Definitely recommend this place and to top it off the staff was wonderful!!!!“

“This place was so fun and we came here on day and time that not much was not going on but yet it was still awesome I can not imagine how cool this place is when everything is open for events or what not. But my boyfriend were looking for a place with good beer and found good pizza and beer plus live music!“

“Best food and service on this side of Louisville. The beer is great and the bartenders are on top of it. Emily at the bar knew exactly what beer to recommend according to my preferences I shared with her. This place has a great history and has great people working for them.“

“This place is a gem, don’t let location fool you.We have been coming here for almost 6 years since moving from California.We’re a bit particular of good food, and every time we dine in here it feels as though the Mimo family cooks just for us.We have our go-tos.Hubby likes the Tomato Basil Pasta. My go to is the Seafood linguini.I personally also think they have the best calamari ever. It’s light. Not overly breaded or greasy.The marinara here is delish, I’ve heard three people tell me they could drink it by the jug >_<Portions are sufficient for one, not family style to share and have all these leftovers, which I personally like.Having worked in a New York-style Pizzeria for approximately 4 years myself, I do opine that their pizza here (at least cheese and cheese + pep options) are 10/10.Prices are also very fair.If you like a clean portion of Italian fare locally, (we’ve tried all the other options around)… we highly recommend Mimo’s.“

“I brought the kids in on early Tuesday afternoon. Are server was Tabby and she was attentive and knowledgeable.Some great news for root beer lovers They brew their own and have many local beers.The place was small but clean.We enjoyed the pretzel bites and they have amazing beer cheese.We ordered a small pepperoni, which was very good. The cheese blend was so flavorful.I did enjoy the calamine as well.Be back!“

“Very polite, accommodating, and punctual service by all the waiters. The food could’ve been slightly hotter but the pizza tastes great as always. The atmosphere in the back of the restaurant is a bit inhibited compared to the nuanced lighting compared to the rest of the restaurant.“

“Domino’s is one of the best and consistently done pies. No matter which location we go to, we have not had a poor experience. This location was a bonus as there was a drive thru window and with rainy weather, it was nice not having to get out. And super friendly guy at the “

“I stopped coming here for a while due to a number of reasons. Decided to give it another try this past Tuesday and I was truly impressed. The atmosphere, service and quality was amazing. I can’t recall the woman’s name, but she was super friendly and accommodating. Although the Chic fil a traffic can be a headache at this location. I will become a regular again. Gourmet vegetarian is my fave!“

“I hadn't been here for a dinner service in a couple years. I had come for the lunch buffet off and on (which is usually great especially for the value) but hadn't sit down for dinner here We got cheese sticks and the mama bearno's special. Both of these were great choices! The mama bearno's can be described as a "supreme" type pizza with a lot of toppings. Each bite had many toppings with a good taste and quality. Additionally I think I have found this place to have possibly the cheapest Guinness draft in the local area. As a Guinness lover this is especially important. Service was efficient even though they were clearly a bit short handed the night I was there.“

“I ordered a pizza earlier this week. It was ready quickly. You don’t even have to get out of your car. You call in and they bring the pizza out when it’s ready. Despite the rain storm, Steven was so attentive and friendly. He made sure that we had everything we needed.“