Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop

$$ • Sandwich Shops, Burgers, Vegetarian

Hours:
174 5th Ave, New York
(212) 675-5096

Customers' Favorites

Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
4.5 (246)
Restaurantji Rating

A NYC institution. We wanted to experience the Jewish diner atmosphere in the movies and we felt all of that here. We got the egg cream, matzo ball, the lil shonda and chopped liver with beef sandwiches. They all tasted great the lil shonda was a bit burned but we cut those parts out. Egg cream we tried for the 1st time and really liked it. Now the cons: it's a lil pricey (but it's Manhattan) and if you don't get there early in the morning you will have to wait in line for a spot...read full review

Restaurantji Rating

Delicious Rouben sandwich - great proportions of pastrami and sauerkraut. The bread is not an ordinary slice of white bread, but a deliciously toasted and slightly fatty slice. In my and my wife's opinion, one of the best Rouben sandwiches in NY. We will definitely come back at the next opportunity - hopefully as soon as possible.

Restaurantji Rating

Good service, wish they had more space. But over all totally worth the wait, you can order takeout, eat at the bar or sit at a table. The pastrami is really good, sliced 1/4" thick but melts in your mouth. The regular is really good.

More Reviews(246)

Ratings

Menu

Add a Menu
Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop Menu
Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop Menu

Photos

Add a Photo
Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop
Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop
View All Photos

Hours

Monday 8AM - 5PM
Tuesday 8AM - 5PM
Wednesday 8AM - 5PM
Thursday 8AM - 5PM
Friday 8AM - 5PM
Saturday 9AM - 5PM
Sunday 9AM - 5PM
Updated on: