Service was great , food was excellent I highly recommend this place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Warm Pita, Htapothi Scharas, Meatballs, Hummus, Grilled Fish
Ilan Goldberg
Amazing food, great service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
MariaL
Excellent Greek food! The menu was slightly limited, but everything we tried was delicious. You must try the Galaktoboureko dessert! I've never had it prepared that way and out was amazing!
mnbnyc
This is a super little place and we enjoyed our Greek Easter meal very much. Great food excellent service and an all around great time. It might be a little off the beaten path but we'll worth the effort.
MariaT2
Amazing restaurant Food was incredible and the setting was casual yet chic Our waiter was friendly,knowledgable and made our evening better with great recommendations Will definitely return when we are back in New York
Manuel Gallardo
Oh god!! Delicious food, nice place and perfect service. If you don’t like Greek food, this place will make you change your mind!
Probably some of the best Greek food we’ve ever had. We are still thinking about it and will definitely be back. Great service, great ambiance.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
S. L.
The best one, until now, among Greek places in New York. Not the usual taverna, very good food. Needs reservation, the sign that it is known around… and is full always!Parking: Hard to find, on street. It’s Manhattan!
Recommended dishes: Warm Pita, Paidakia Galaktos Stin Schara, Yogurt Dessert, Htapothi Scharas, Christos' Towering Galaktobourekakia, Horiatiki, Crisp Fresh Fried Squid, Hummus, Napoleon Me Mousse APO Vissino Kai Yiaourti, Greek Salad
Yingying Zheng
so nice my nail salon next door It's convenient for me to eat Good value for money, great taste, large portion
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
José Francisco Pereira da Silva de Pádua
I would give it 5 if it weren't Michellin and had compatible prices.I ordered scallop on a bed of arugula and beans, grilled octopus with balsamic sauce, roasted potatoes, a kind of moussaka and grilled fish with a pistachio crust and supposedly pistachio pesto sauce.For dessert, chocolate mousse with ouzo.I noticed an acidic flavor throughout the dish.It could be too much lemon or vinegar, I don't know.Good food, but not unforgettable and expensive
Absolutely delicious food! Wonderful service!Wheelchair accessibility: One of our parties was in a scooter and had no problems.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hummus, Greek Salad
francisco7
I would give it 5 if it weren't Michellin and had compatible prices. I ordered scallop on a bed of arugula and beans, grilled octopus with balsamic sauce, roasted potatoes, a kind of moussaka and grilled fish with pistachio crust and supposedly pistachio pesto sauce. For dessert, chocolate mousse with ouzo. I noticed an acidic flavor throughout the dish. It could be too much lemon or vinegar, I don't know. Good food, but not unforgettable and expensive
Phbnyc
We have been coming to Pylos for over 20 years, and it never disappoints. This was the first time in a long while, and it was maybe the best it's ever been! The food and service were outstanding, and the restaurant as pretty as always. I suppose the mesh sheets on the ceiling covering the clay pots are a safety precaution? They do take away from the beauty of the pots but I understand if it's necessary. I can't wait to go back!
SamO
We already had reservations for dinner elsewhere, but weren't really feeling it and decided to search for something else. Landed on Pylos and its many great reviews, so we changed plans... and we're so glad we did! A wonderful dinner experience, and probably the BEST meal we had during our trip! The interior is an upscale but casual and comfortable place. The ceiling is creatively lined with clay pots, and tables were neatly organized throughout the long narrow space. Our server, Tamera (I'm sure I spelled that incorrectly, sorry!) was wonderful! She was patient, knowing it was our first time, and she did a wonderful job of guiding us through the menu and helping us narrow down our choices (because we wanted EVERYTHING!!) We started with the complimentary pita and humus, and we ordered pitakia kaisarias- meat and cheese filled phyllo triangles, saganaki, and grilled octopus (htapothi scharas). Fantastic! I initially wanted to try the lamb chops but decided to go with something lighter since we had all those wonderful appetizers. I chose the grilled branzino with patates psites (Greek lemon potatoes) and my husband chose pastitsio, one of his favorites. Everything was absolutely delicious, and the pastitsio was the best restaurant pastitsio we've ever had. Some places are too heavy on the cinnamon, but this was perfect in that it elevated the flavor without overpowering it. We shared a beautiful bottle of wine from the Greek Macedonian region of Florina. Perfect compliment to the meal. We enjoyed an anniversary dessert of Galaktobourekakia. Miniature version of galaktoboureko. Semolina custard filled phyllo triangles drizzled with honey. So delicious! It's also inspired me to try making this style of mini galaktoboureko myself! Eat here, enjoy it, but don't tell everyone about how great it was... we'd like to still be able to get a reservation here when we return! Efharisto, Pylos!
Sissi Sophia
Friendly service and delicious Greek food. I love lemon potatos. I definitely will come again.
Service was great , food was excellent I highly recommend this place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Warm Pita, Htapothi Scharas, Meatballs, Hummus, Grilled Fish
Amazing food, great service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent Greek food! The menu was slightly limited, but everything we tried was delicious. You must try the Galaktoboureko dessert! I've never had it prepared that way and out was amazing!
This is a super little place and we enjoyed our Greek Easter meal very much. Great food excellent service and an all around great time. It might be a little off the beaten path but we'll worth the effort.
Amazing restaurant Food was incredible and the setting was casual yet chic Our waiter was friendly,knowledgable and made our evening better with great recommendations Will definitely return when we are back in New York
Oh god!! Delicious food, nice place and perfect service. If you don’t like Greek food, this place will make you change your mind!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Paidakia Galaktos Stin Schara, Yogurt Dessert, Christos' Towering Galaktobourekakia, Poikilia, Grilled Fish, Greek Salad
Probably some of the best Greek food we’ve ever had. We are still thinking about it and will definitely be back. Great service, great ambiance.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best one, until now, among Greek places in New York. Not the usual taverna, very good food. Needs reservation, the sign that it is known around… and is full always!Parking: Hard to find, on street. It’s Manhattan!
Recommended dishes: Warm Pita, Paidakia Galaktos Stin Schara, Yogurt Dessert, Htapothi Scharas, Christos' Towering Galaktobourekakia, Horiatiki, Crisp Fresh Fried Squid, Hummus, Napoleon Me Mousse APO Vissino Kai Yiaourti, Greek Salad
so nice my nail salon next door It's convenient for me to eat Good value for money, great taste, large portion
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I would give it 5 if it weren't Michellin and had compatible prices.I ordered scallop on a bed of arugula and beans, grilled octopus with balsamic sauce, roasted potatoes, a kind of moussaka and grilled fish with a pistachio crust and supposedly pistachio pesto sauce.For dessert, chocolate mousse with ouzo.I noticed an acidic flavor throughout the dish.It could be too much lemon or vinegar, I don't know.Good food, but not unforgettable and expensive
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Absolutely delicious food! Wonderful service!Wheelchair accessibility: One of our parties was in a scooter and had no problems.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hummus, Greek Salad
I would give it 5 if it weren't Michellin and had compatible prices. I ordered scallop on a bed of arugula and beans, grilled octopus with balsamic sauce, roasted potatoes, a kind of moussaka and grilled fish with pistachio crust and supposedly pistachio pesto sauce. For dessert, chocolate mousse with ouzo. I noticed an acidic flavor throughout the dish. It could be too much lemon or vinegar, I don't know. Good food, but not unforgettable and expensive
We have been coming to Pylos for over 20 years, and it never disappoints. This was the first time in a long while, and it was maybe the best it's ever been! The food and service were outstanding, and the restaurant as pretty as always. I suppose the mesh sheets on the ceiling covering the clay pots are a safety precaution? They do take away from the beauty of the pots but I understand if it's necessary. I can't wait to go back!
We already had reservations for dinner elsewhere, but weren't really feeling it and decided to search for something else. Landed on Pylos and its many great reviews, so we changed plans... and we're so glad we did! A wonderful dinner experience, and probably the BEST meal we had during our trip! The interior is an upscale but casual and comfortable place. The ceiling is creatively lined with clay pots, and tables were neatly organized throughout the long narrow space. Our server, Tamera (I'm sure I spelled that incorrectly, sorry!) was wonderful! She was patient, knowing it was our first time, and she did a wonderful job of guiding us through the menu and helping us narrow down our choices (because we wanted EVERYTHING!!) We started with the complimentary pita and humus, and we ordered pitakia kaisarias- meat and cheese filled phyllo triangles, saganaki, and grilled octopus (htapothi scharas). Fantastic! I initially wanted to try the lamb chops but decided to go with something lighter since we had all those wonderful appetizers. I chose the grilled branzino with patates psites (Greek lemon potatoes) and my husband chose pastitsio, one of his favorites. Everything was absolutely delicious, and the pastitsio was the best restaurant pastitsio we've ever had. Some places are too heavy on the cinnamon, but this was perfect in that it elevated the flavor without overpowering it. We shared a beautiful bottle of wine from the Greek Macedonian region of Florina. Perfect compliment to the meal. We enjoyed an anniversary dessert of Galaktobourekakia. Miniature version of galaktoboureko. Semolina custard filled phyllo triangles drizzled with honey. So delicious! It's also inspired me to try making this style of mini galaktoboureko myself! Eat here, enjoy it, but don't tell everyone about how great it was... we'd like to still be able to get a reservation here when we return! Efharisto, Pylos!
Friendly service and delicious Greek food. I love lemon potatos. I definitely will come again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5