Paul's Fifth Avenue

1565 W 5th Ave, Columbus
(614) 481-8848

Recent Reviews

Leah I.

Delicious food, right price, and great service. Food was delivered quickly. Have that good staple diner feel.

Hannah D.

The service was outstanding. I was with a group of 15 people. Our server was very friendly and got all our orders accurately. We received our food amazingly fast. The food was also very good. If I lived closer, I'd be back all the time.

Jay Graf

Great breakfast. Fast and delicious

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Holly Blain

I visited a friend in Ohio and we went to Paul's for breakfast and I had the best scrambled eggs with cheese i had ever had. They were excellent! If you are ever in Ohio, find this "gem" and enjoy!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brendan Ritz

French toast ????????

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

William M.

It's bn a minute since I've bn there! But the food is still down home, service is good ol' southern hospitality! Like everything else prices have gone up, but it's better than the other national chain that is on the farm!!

Suchita S.

Gets the job done with efficiency and good food. It's a classic diner space with zero frills. I would say this place is perfect for a standard American breakfast. The prices are also good. They do serve alcohol and have heard their mimosas are particularly strong/good. This place is one of my coworkers go to after working night shifts because it's open early, has drinks, and a good warm meal before going to sleep.

Darren Amberger

Live the Reuben. Phenomenal corned beef??

Mike Munson

Susie is the best waitress. Always try to sit in her section.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sausage Gravy, Tater Tots, Build Your Own Omelet

Gary Yurco

Not fancy. Omelet huge and very flavorful. Enjoyable visit.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Andrew King

Best dang omelets pancakes and waffles by a wide

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Curtis Fiatoa

Classic diner atmosphere, love it. Their Sausage Gravy is worth a trip on its own lol.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: The Dennis Sandwich, Sausage Gravy

Mark K.

I'm tempted to go five stars, but while very good it wasn't amazing, and there are places with better service and food. But- and a big but- it is very good food, fairly cheap, with good service. And fast. Say 4.5 stars. I stopped in for breakfast. There were a few other parties and only one waitress, but she checked on me several times and the food was out pretty quickly. Friendly staff all around. Pretty standard menu. I got the Billy, which is two eggs, sausage, sausage gravy, biscuit, home fries. All done perfectly. Good sausage, under a mound of eggs and gravy. Good gravy, seems homemade, thick and tasty. Good sturdy biscuit to hold things up, but soft enough and flaky. Home fries- best I've had in years. And perfectly cooked eggs. Which leads me to two little things that really made me love this place. First, a list on the menu of how you can get your eggs done. They can do that anywhere, but most don't offer all the options, and don't seem to know how to do much beyond scrambled and over easy. These folks know. And two hot sauces on the table. I usually have to ask for one. Plus, the places where you have to ask, well, you need them. This place has them, but they were unnecessary because the food is well seasoned. A little pricey, like everything else nowadays, but appropriate for the quantity and quality. Nice place, not fancy but comfy, and a big patio for warmer weather. Wish I'd come here sooner, and will keep it in mind for when I'm nearby.

Dan Santry

Didn't know that the sale several years ago didn't go through...was excited to learn that it was still open. Went there for the first time since. Great food and quality, just as I remembered.Now for the issues with our service. Although our waitress was nice...we put our drink and food order in at the same time because we had already decided what we wanted. In the roughly 15 minutes (maybe longer), our waitress went to the bathroom, got herself something to drink, was doing who knows what else in between....I had to approach her, tell her she still hadn't gotten us our drinks and she made up some excuse about silverware to cover for the fact that she hadn't gotten our drinks. She was nice and fairly on top of things after that....Parking: Very small lot, aisles (or traveling lanes) in parking lot are narrow and corners are tight to maneuver, but that's common in several places in the area.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

Paul Marquardt

Perfect place for breakfast or lunch.Get the banana bread but get it grilled.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More