14 Best Ice Cream Shops near Sheffield Lake

“Our first time trying here and it did not disappoint ! Friendly staff, clean establishment and yummy icecream! We can’t wait to come back.“

“My son loved these cookies and used to purchase them every week as a special treat. He was a police officer who passed away last year, and so to honor his memory on the anniversary of his death last month, I purchased several boxes of Crumbl cookies from the Amherst location to take to my son's police department, as well as several other departments. I ordered online, which was super simple, and I picked them up to deliver them the next day. This put a smile on my face and on the faces of the officers who received them. Thank you for helping me to turn a terrible day into a positive one“

“Best ice cream in the area.“

“Some of the best ice cream around. Milkshakes are great too. I only have 2 complaints, 1 is they are almost always busy(which is a good sign) but they do get through the line quick while being friendly. And 2, the milkshake only come in one size. Overall would highly recommend stopping in to get some “

“great options, great ice cream, good value“

“These are the best cookies I have ever had“

“Best ice cream in the area.“

“So I'll start by saying that I went here probably 10yrs ago and it wasn't great.. Recently a friend and I decided to give it another shot, and I'm glad we did!! The service was excellent, attentive and friendly. They also let me sample the chicken paprikas sauce, which is really good!! However, we decided we wanted burgers and onion rings for lunch. My friend had the Sammy Say burger that was comparable to an OH BOY burger (if you're from around here you probably know what that is) and she said it was really good. I had the mushroom swiss burger and I have to say, it was one of THE BEST MUSHROOM SWISS BURGERS I'VE EVER HAD!! The onion rings were also fantastic!! The atmosphere was relaxing and laid back, the other patrons were all friendly and personable as well.. We had a great experience here and we will definitely be going back!! 5⭐Kid-friendliness: There's also ice cream for the kidsWheelchair accessibility: Easy wheelchair access“

“This is such an incredible little place! Very family friendly and super fun space to be in. The workers were incredible, and super patient with my indecisive kiddos! She was also very kind about one of child's nut allergies, and went out of her way to clean the scoop in the back and was helping recommend ice creams with no cross contamination! Also, so happy with the price. I got ice cream for five for under 20 dollars, that's so unheard of! And it was quality ice cream too, so totally worth it. If your in the area, definitely consider a visit.“

“Nice people and awesome ice cream“

“We went to Railroad Brewing Company for lunch and went over to Coco’s for a gelato dessert. The gelato was excellent. I had raspberry and my husband and daughter had the strawberry cheesecake. It was $5 for a decent size cup. I would definitely recommend.“

“This is a great place for ice cream. Nicely paved parking lot with plenty of spaces, great variety of ice cream dishes, and a kids play area right next door. A nice drive for the family or stop by if you're out on a walk. Keep in mind this place can get busy pretty quick. Also there are picnic tables and the kids play area that have attached solar lights. Something I haven't seen before.Kid-friendliness: Playground area right next door.“

“Upon entering, I was warmly welcomed by a smiling staff member who guided me to the counter. However, I noticed a worker that during busy times, impatience can sometimes manifest in short responses to customers or a hurried demeanor. While she strives to maintain efficiency, her impatience can sometimes overshadow the friendly atmosphere that Fenik prides itself on.“

“In all honesty…I was out with my dad shopping and we stopped in for some ice cream. I, watching my fat intake and full from lunch still, was not really up for dessert yet…I did order a small scoop of salted Carmel chocolate truffle. My good peeps that have made it this far…if at all you are looking for some great creamy sugary deliciousness in a fall fashion that is not just pumpkin, get it. It is rich, strong in flavor and the chocolate truffle bites though large are perfect. My dad ordered butter pecan and just loved the way the nuts were still crispy with great flavor though he would tell you that the ice cream itself was lacking the great flavor of Howard Johnson’s had in their ice cream. Great visit. Good people.“