Best of Stone Baked Pizzeria

979 Waterton Ave, Pincher Creek
(403) 904-1014

Recent Reviews

Madge Connon

The food is not all that great. I find is bland and very greasy. There seames to be next to customer's over there.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings

Nick Sullivan

Excellent pizza! Wide variety of pizza toppings for everyone, the stone baked crust is tasty and thin, and the calzone was both massive but also packed!Restaurant is clean and well lit,, with mix of booths and tables. Cozy but not feeling like you’d be seated on top of another group.Service was friendly, but sadly on the slow side for lunch when we were the only people in the restaurant.Dietary restrictions: Gluten free options.Kid-friendliness: Kids menu, ice cream and extensive desert menu.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Stone

Ian Walford

We really enjoyed our pizza at this local restaurant, the crust was delicious and the balance of sauce / cheese / toppings was perfect. We found the service very friendly but it did seem to be on the slow side.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Andrea Jordan

There is currently 20 people in the dining room and no food in front of a single person. Have been in here for an hour. There is even people sitting in the dining room that are waiting for their food that they ordered over an hour ago. Not impressed!! Even had to ask for another drink. Currently have been sitting in the dining room for 50 minutes wow

Jamie May

This place is in serious need of good management. Ordered a steak and had to repeat the word rare at least 6 times before the waitress believed that was what I wanted. once the steak came, I asked for a steak knife and they dont have any steak knives. The steak tasted pretty good, but it wasn't worth the trouble. While the restaurant is practically empty, the bathrooms needed a bit of attention (no toilet paper).The waitress is nice but she simply does not understand anything you say. When I went to order the steak I asked her if they had a 6 or 8 Oz instead of a 10 Oz. She proceeds to list the types of steak they have. I repeat my question. She repeats her answer. I ask a third time, and say I'm asking about the size not the type. She said that's all they had. Ordering anything else wouldn't have been worth it because I couldn't ask the waitress any questions because she hardly understood me.Finally, someone in our party got food poisoning.You guys have a beautiful building. You need to do better if you want to stay in business.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 1

John Oc

Steak was really good, but the chicken Tikka massala and the goat curry is the best I've had! Excellent service and food!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jennifer Parker

Great variety on the menu. Meaty and vegetarian options. In addition to pizza and donairs, they serve very tasty curries.

Wesley Platt

Don’t go here, it’s very dirty inside and the food is overpriced garbage. The flies are rank inside, the water glasses were filthy, and the service is terrible. Never coming back!The Heritage is a great substitute and they’re just a block away!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Clarissa Unruh

I had the Butter Chicken and enjoyed it! The kids loved the cheese pizza. Always a great ambience.

Mattias Daniels

The Awesome Restaurant in Very Small Town. We were so impressed with the quality and taste of the foods. The Quantity and the Price are Very Very Good. We will go back to the place again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Shawarma

Elissar Malaeb

They overcharged us and we realized on our drive away from the restaurant. We called immediately and they assured they would refund the money to the CC. Despite numerous follpw up calls and promises the refund was never returned. It wasn't so much about the money as it was about the principal. No integrity and bad customer service means we will never return to this place and I would not recommend them.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Fries

Ed Yaghi

This outfit overcharged my $6, I called back and was promised a refund. 3 weeks later with no refund with manager never returning my calls. Not so much the money but the principal. Won't return but counting down the days till the manager returns my calls for my refund.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Larry Lauder

Driving back from Waterton and noticed sign with ice cream and Stone Baked Pizza. Rum and raisin was in the display case and ordered that. Went outside on deck to enjoy and decided to try a pizza. Meat storm small size. Waitress assured me that was a good choice. She was right. Nice thin crust baked just right. Lots of meat but the cheese was very light. Sauce was very tasty. The waitress had problems understanding me. She also didn’t bring water to table. Didn’t even ask if I wanted anything to drink. Hence the three stars in service. Restaurant was very clean, washrooms were very clean. Nice decor in restaurant. I will stop in again to try other items on the menu. Or another pizza.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

CM Edmunds

More than just pizza... we had delicious donairs, but were tempted by the curry dishes (such as butter chicken). Food was very good. We enjoyed the patio in September and were allowed to bring our dog on the patio while we had supper.Also baklava and mango cheesecake for dessert.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Manija Shirzad darya

Very delicious food and the staff are very good and helpful we enjoyed our food the service was excellent ?Vegetarian options: The menu have lits to chose fromDietary restrictions: They had gluten free pizzaKid-friendliness: Kid menu is very simple for k8ds to choose

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pineapple Express, Chicken Wings

Load More