We've been to Everett's previously for brunch but we popped over for dinner for the first time, and were extremely disappointed. The service was fantastic - we will say that! However, the food was extremely bland and went unfinished. The seared calamari was extremely bland with little taste. The seafood pasta tasted like watered down milk was poured into a pasta bowl and topped with seafood. Unfortunately to make matters worse, my husband and I who had the seafood pasta both ended up feeling extremely ill hours later. We send a message to Everett's but have not heard anything back. We had heard such great things but understand now why their reviews are turned off on google.
Kerry
We had a great first time experience. The food was really good, the service was good and the atmosphere was nice as well. We will definitely be back.
Lynette
We come here quite frequently and have never had a bad experience. Food is always delicious!
Heather
Beautiful dining experience looking over the lake. The food was delicious, and we enjoyed the atmosphere in the dining room. I had the halibut and it was perfectly cooked.
Melanie
If there is an outside party happening, don't bother dining here. They were so busy fulfilling drink and food orders for the party that it took over an hour for my drink to show. My husband's never did. Conversely, his cup of soup came 30 minutes before my side salad. At least our dinners arrived together but about 1 1/2 hours after we were seated. The dining staff were obviously flustered and kept getting our orders wrong. I've never had such a bad experience here. I'd definitely recommend it as long as there's no extra event happening.
Amanda
Sat outside and enjoyed the sun and some snacks for happy hour. Prompt and courteous service.
Melissa
We had reservations for outdoor, but when we got there they said outdoor would be 40 min. So we were seated in the bar. Our server was really too busy to give the top notch service I have had there in the past. He seemed a little more than just distracted. The duck was delicious, the filet was sup par. I have had so many excellent meals there, Im sure it was a situational issue, but for the prices you expect excellent quality and service.
Teena
This was our first time eating here after hearing good reviews. Our reservation was for 5:30. We arrived 10 minutes early and had 5 people in our party. They didn't have a table available for us outside, which is what our reservation was for. After getting around that, we had moved inside due to weather. Our waitress took our order and after that had only come to our table to bring our food and, maybe, 2 more times. We had to flag her down to get water refills. The food wasn't hot when it arrived to our table but knowing our waitress was non-existent, we ate it anyway. The price we paid for everything, we would not return. We were also charged for a lemonade when our waitress never even brought it to our table. Our fault for not catching that on the receipt until after leaving. Again, we didn't want to prolong our visit any longer waiting for her.
Johnathan
We had a very nice evening of dining and conversation. The staff were very courteous and knowledgeable of the menu, while the cocktails had generous pours.
Nick
Great dinner as always. Everything on the menus is great hardest part is deciding on which thing you want.
It seems the quality of the food has gone down over the last couple years. This was our 3rd time eating there and each time it's just gotten a little more....blah. The special was not very special. It was supposed to be Beef Stroganoff, but they used shells instead of egg noodles, the sauce was not like any stroganoff sauce I have ever had (and not in a good way), and it seems like they dumped an entire can of mushrooms into it. My wife and I ended up switching meals, and she didn't really care for it either. The Fettuccini Alfredo was made with linguini noodles....yet the menu item is literally called FETTUCCINI ALFREDO....it's supposed to be fettuccini noodles...it's in the name! The only things that were actually "good" where the Elijah Craig bourbon and the Peanut butter pie...which was made a local bakery, not Everett's. Top it all off with the fact that the main dining room was about 85 degrees and it made for a very poor experience. But I will say, our servers were great!
Erik
The food is still top-notch and consistent. I have ordered the same thing multiple times, and each time, it matches the original in quality and presentation. We went at mid-afternoon, so it was less busy than I expected, but it was also a rainy day. We typically sit outside, which is one of our favorite environments to eat, looking out over the lake, with music is a nice setting during the summer.
TERI
Amazing food & service!!! We love they also remember us! Definitely worth the nice drive to Wasilla :-)
Cheri
Because of my husband's hearing, or lack there of, I asked if we could sit in the dining room even though it was closed. They asked one of the servers and accommodated us. It made our experience amazing. We were so thankful.
Richard
Good food. Good service, but we did have to wait a little for wait staff to check on us one time.. The dining room was fairly quiet. Will dine here again.
We've been to Everett's previously for brunch but we popped over for dinner for the first time, and were extremely disappointed. The service was fantastic - we will say that! However, the food was extremely bland and went unfinished. The seared calamari was extremely bland with little taste. The seafood pasta tasted like watered down milk was poured into a pasta bowl and topped with seafood. Unfortunately to make matters worse, my husband and I who had the seafood pasta both ended up feeling extremely ill hours later. We send a message to Everett's but have not heard anything back. We had heard such great things but understand now why their reviews are turned off on google.
We had a great first time experience. The food was really good, the service was good and the atmosphere was nice as well. We will definitely be back.
We come here quite frequently and have never had a bad experience. Food is always delicious!
Beautiful dining experience looking over the lake. The food was delicious, and we enjoyed the atmosphere in the dining room. I had the halibut and it was perfectly cooked.
If there is an outside party happening, don't bother dining here. They were so busy fulfilling drink and food orders for the party that it took over an hour for my drink to show. My husband's never did. Conversely, his cup of soup came 30 minutes before my side salad. At least our dinners arrived together but about 1 1/2 hours after we were seated. The dining staff were obviously flustered and kept getting our orders wrong. I've never had such a bad experience here. I'd definitely recommend it as long as there's no extra event happening.
Sat outside and enjoyed the sun and some snacks for happy hour. Prompt and courteous service.
We had reservations for outdoor, but when we got there they said outdoor would be 40 min. So we were seated in the bar. Our server was really too busy to give the top notch service I have had there in the past. He seemed a little more than just distracted. The duck was delicious, the filet was sup par. I have had so many excellent meals there, Im sure it was a situational issue, but for the prices you expect excellent quality and service.
This was our first time eating here after hearing good reviews. Our reservation was for 5:30. We arrived 10 minutes early and had 5 people in our party. They didn't have a table available for us outside, which is what our reservation was for. After getting around that, we had moved inside due to weather. Our waitress took our order and after that had only come to our table to bring our food and, maybe, 2 more times. We had to flag her down to get water refills. The food wasn't hot when it arrived to our table but knowing our waitress was non-existent, we ate it anyway. The price we paid for everything, we would not return. We were also charged for a lemonade when our waitress never even brought it to our table. Our fault for not catching that on the receipt until after leaving. Again, we didn't want to prolong our visit any longer waiting for her.
We had a very nice evening of dining and conversation. The staff were very courteous and knowledgeable of the menu, while the cocktails had generous pours.
Great dinner as always. Everything on the menus is great hardest part is deciding on which thing you want.
Restaurantji Recommends
It seems the quality of the food has gone down over the last couple years. This was our 3rd time eating there and each time it's just gotten a little more....blah. The special was not very special. It was supposed to be Beef Stroganoff, but they used shells instead of egg noodles, the sauce was not like any stroganoff sauce I have ever had (and not in a good way), and it seems like they dumped an entire can of mushrooms into it. My wife and I ended up switching meals, and she didn't really care for it either. The Fettuccini Alfredo was made with linguini noodles....yet the menu item is literally called FETTUCCINI ALFREDO....it's supposed to be fettuccini noodles...it's in the name! The only things that were actually "good" where the Elijah Craig bourbon and the Peanut butter pie...which was made a local bakery, not Everett's. Top it all off with the fact that the main dining room was about 85 degrees and it made for a very poor experience. But I will say, our servers were great!
The food is still top-notch and consistent. I have ordered the same thing multiple times, and each time, it matches the original in quality and presentation. We went at mid-afternoon, so it was less busy than I expected, but it was also a rainy day. We typically sit outside, which is one of our favorite environments to eat, looking out over the lake, with music is a nice setting during the summer.
Amazing food & service!!! We love they also remember us! Definitely worth the nice drive to Wasilla :-)
Because of my husband's hearing, or lack there of, I asked if we could sit in the dining room even though it was closed. They asked one of the servers and accommodated us. It made our experience amazing. We were so thankful.
Good food. Good service, but we did have to wait a little for wait staff to check on us one time.. The dining room was fairly quiet. Will dine here again.
Loading...