Settlers Bay Lodge

The new specials were awesome we had the duck wings and pork sliders! The squash pasta with chicken was delicious! Service was exceptional from Crystal would highly recommend her to take care of you. We love coming to Settlers Bay for dinner!

I made this reservation for me and my girlfriend. Its our one year anniversary but it was so special to me because she's the one and we're starting a family. You all made the night so wonderful and meaningful. Our server Max was absolutely killer. He was funny, attentive and made sure we had everything we needed or wanted. It was without a doubt one of the best nights I've ever had. Thank you all so much. 🙏🤘♥️

Great German food. Next time it would have been nice to have some decorations up to celebrate Oktoberfest.

Went on a Saturday for our anniversary. The service was great and the duck was cooked perfectly.

We celebrated Father's Day here and were so happy we came back for our daughter's 9th. Birthday. Friendly staff, excellent service and great food!

My boyfriend and I had the best time there last night. We were there celebrating 17 years of being together and they went out of their way to make it a very special evening for us. Even left a little happy anniversary note! The service and our waitress ( I wish I could remember her name, I'm so sorry!) Was incredible. She never let our glasses go empty and was cheerful and had a great personality.
The food was so tasty and perfectly cooked. They gave us a beautiful table by the fireplace with lots of views to enjoy our date and meal.
Thank you all for making this a memorable night out for us!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Settlers Bay has the best pepper steak I ever had. I had three or four there in the last couple of months. I would usually rate that the best in the state, but the one I had last night was the toughest steak I think I’ve had in decades. It was not overcooked, was done just right, I just had to saw through it with the knife then gnaw through each bite. Maybe I just finally got a bad one. Hopefully, that doesn’t become thew norm because they’ve changed suppliers.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The server was amazing. He was friendly helpful and always attentive. Made the visit welcoming and a joy.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cajun Calamari, Escargot and Seafood Artichoke Dip, New York

After enjoying Easter Brunch at Settler's Bay earlier this year, we decided to celebrate our birthdays there as well and it didn't disappoint! I made reservations; however, we were there early for dinner, so it was fairly quiet, which was nice. Service was excellent, our server was jovial and attentive! Cocktails, appetizers, entrees and dessert! We were all beautifully miserable by the time we walked out two hours later! We never felt rushed, and that was a great way to casually celebrate! Easter Brunch will definitely be a new tradition and I wouldn't hesitate to go for dinner throughout the year, especially for a celebration.

My husband and I just celebrated our 20th wedding anniversary, and dinner here was wonderful. Every stage of the meal from appetizers to dessert was excellent and flavorful. The staff paid meaningful attention to our needs, even calling to check on our allergies from our profile in advance of our arrival. The view was spectacular tonight, as the sun was setting over the inlet during our meal around 7 pm. We were able to see the mountains clearly, and the sunset lit up the clouds. The service was also excellent, and our wait staff were very attentive throughout the evening. My husband was provided with a look at their bourbon list, just so he could try something new. My mocktail (alcohol free) was also excellent. The chef here is someone who has assisted with our dining needs before, and he always has creative solutions to adapt standard menu items. His adaptations are always worthy of being the standard menu option. Oh, and we received roses at our table, a sweet card, and a free dessert for our anniversary celebration. (The creme brulee is awesome!) Overall, we highly recommend this dining experience for special occasions, as well as family get togethers. We will definitely be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

A great evening with friends. Food was excellent and perfectly prepared. Service was outstanding! Thank you Settlers Bay Lodge.

I wanted to reach out and say I’m very disappointed with your service. Me and my spouse have 5 children and we rarely get alone time together. We tried to eat at your restaurant August 22nd at 6pm. We had never been there before and were excited to try it for date night. To our surprise we were only given glasses of water when we were seated. We waited an entire hour with all waitresses and bussers intentionally avoiding eye contact and ignoring us. We never received menus. Everyone around us were getting waited on even an older couple behind us.

I feel very let down and discriminated against. I know my spouse and I are in our late 20s, but we still have plenty of generosity when it comes to tipping a communicative and kind waitress.
But we decided to leave as even when we asked for menus we were still ignored…. I cried for an hour after we left because all I wanted was to enjoy time with the person I love at a beautiful restaurant.
Please encourage your staff to treat everyone equally and tend to all the tables customers are seated at so no one has to feel the way I felt. Thanks.

Service: 1

We were celebrating our anniversary and the team at Settler did everything to make the evening special. Well done.

We were visiting family and celebrating my birthday. I am a professional chef and wanted to eat at a nice place. The menu looked wonderful so we decided to come the Lodge for dinner. It did not disappoint! Our dinner was delicious!! Our server Kelsey (hope that’s her name) was amazing! She was very patient with my senior parents and took the time to answer all their questions. She took care of our every need. This was a memorable experience and thank you for having the perfect staff to ensure that expectations are successful.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Beautiful Place, Nice Service! And The Alcoholic Beverages Are Top Tier.