Settlers Bay Lodge

Dinner tonight was excellent.
Our first time here and will be returning.
Marsala steak starter, Cajun fettuccine and chicken cordon blue were amazing with no complaints. Service was great. Our waitress was quick and attentive and price was more then fair for the portions.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The atmosphere is simply amazing and that alone will make me come again. Our service was excellent as well.
I do hope my food is better next time, though. I ordered the seafood mac and cheese, which left a lot to be desired. It was extremely salty (but with no flavor), which was the worst part, and I am someone who likes salty food. This was overwhelming, though, and to be completely honest, the cavatappi did not seem cooked thoroughly, and there was hardly any crab meat. Definitely no chunks. You really had to search for very small bits in the sauce. Also, imitation crab meat was added, which made the dish seem cheap. I don't know why you would add imitation crab meat to a dish that already had real crab meat in it. This made no sense to me.
My husband's steak, however, was amazing. It was tender with lots of flavor and grilled to perfection 👌

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

I had my mom visiting for my wedding this weekend, she wanted to bring me somewhere the next day to celebrate so we suggested Settlers Bay as it's been our go too when family is visiting the last few times, none of us were impressed this time around and I will be going elsewhere in the future. Service was very slow, the calamari appetizer we normally rave to people about had such thick cuts of squid this time around it just wasn't pleasant, though the general flavor was still the same. It took 45 minutes before we even got bread to the table and about an hour or more for the food. I was the only one at my table to get asked for ID which I had forgot (I won't fault you here as it is state law, but come on, I didn't look any younger than anyone else I was with who you served no problem without asking for id's). When we finally did get our entrees they were pretty good, but we were all already ready to leave before even getting the food. It was definitely not the wedding celebration dinner we had hoped for.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 2

Thanksgiving buffet was delicious. Selection was very diverse but included everything I wanted. Food was hot, service was great and it made Thanksgiving wonderful.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Vegetarian options: Where they can they will make adjustments.

Dietary restrictions: Very accommodating for our Dairy Free person

Wheelchair accessibility: Excellent

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Mashed Potatoes, Creme Brûlée, Stuffed Prawns, Ribeye Medium Rare with Vegetables and Potato Salad

The best service! Such friendly staff, amazing food! Management is wonderful! Would recommend to anyone!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Where we had our first date almost 5 years ago and nothing but great experiences since. They even saved our Thanksgiving this year, we are soooo very grateful!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This place is amazing. Their attention to detail is what sets them apart. The food is delicious, and the bacon butter is to die for. The list of mocktails is great for those who want a drink without drinking.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: French Onion Soup, Stuffed Prawns, Ribeye Medium Rare with Vegetables and Potato Salad

Went here with the fam for dinner. Caught the jake Paul vs Mike tyson fight. The events here my relative says are great. I felt like jt was a well done event however by the time I got my food we were very busy with the event itself. Sounds great but for 30$+ for my food I was actually really sad. I got the tempura scalops and shrimp which was breaded with like cornbatter or something weird that wasnt cooked all the way through -_-. Got like 5 big pieces but I was so hungry. The stuffed mushrooms were delicious.. everyone's else's food looked perfect. My French onion was pretty good too, not the best but not bad by any means but good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Cordon Bleu, French Onion Soup, Stuffed Mushrooms

Brittany was amazing! Ribeye and prawns were excellent can’t wait to come back again soon.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Stuffed Prawns, Ribeye Medium Rare with Vegetables and Potato Salad

Casual encounters Catered a 100 person wedding

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Creme Brûlée, King Crab Legs

Great steaks and burgers

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Not up to par with our favorite restaurant in Anchorage, the Crow's Nest. The service, the food, the place: no star quality, but the food prices, through the roof! To think we went on a very special occasion. We went for a change of venue, try out someplace new. Driving an hour to get that special dinner wasn't worth it, it's just was not that enjoyable.The receptionist asked if it was special occassion and we said yes but no added treat. @ Crow's Nest we're given a plate with chocolates drizzled in chocolate or red sweet sonething with a wriitten “Happy Birthday” or “Happy Anniversary” and offered coffee to finish off our tasty meal. None of that @Settlers Bay Lodge. None. Yes, we learned our lesson and we're not returning at all anymore.

We went for my husbands 61st birthday with my son and daughter in law . We loved the music . We have been to the restaurant several times. The food and service is alway great, the live music was a nice addition.

What a great dining experience. The food we excellent, our server, Crystal was attentive but not bothersome, we had an amazing view of the mountains. I would suggest making reservations. The specials they offer are wonderful.