No more buffet. Biggest mistake they could’ve ever done. Pizza by the slice now. Probably trying to keep up with these crazy prices but now without the buffet that will be harder..
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
abad 619
Great service and the pizza is on point. Personally I think it’s better than Village pizza that it’s across the street from it. Their sister location in Huntsville is just as good. Come try them and support the locals.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Meat Lover Pizza
Paul Green
I enjoyed this place it was the middle of the day so I did not make use of the bar, but it looked like a good one. The pizza on the buffet was more New York style thin crust, but it was all good. The garlic bread nuggets were really
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
ashtonauts
Honestly my favorite pizza buffet. We moved out of town and still stop by any time we want some pizza. Staff is very welcoming and willing to add whatever pizza to the buffet.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cinnamon Rolls, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Pizza, Pizza Buffet and Salad Bar
Danielle Wock
What a disappointment. Came out here excited to try the buffet because we loved the new Huntsville location. But the "buffet" is a joke. Cold crusty pasta. Horrible service. And charged for a baby who ate absolutely nothing. What a waste to drive out here. Will never be back.Parking: Horrible parking
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pizza Buffet and Salad Bar
Dan Marcott
Pizza is excellent. The place is old and not in great shape, but not a big deal if the food it good, and it is. No issue there. However, the owner/manager is unimpressive. I get Mozza coupons in the mail, which helps make the long drive from west Huntsville to Athens worthwhile. However, the owner/manager does not like these coupons. He argues that they are not valid or do not apply, when they clearly do, and then puts restrictions on their use. I understand trying to make a profit and seeing coupons come in the door is not very desirable, but if they get people to come try the pizza (and the pizza sells itself!), they are worthwhile in the long run. The most recent time I was there was the final straw. I had a 5 dollar off a $30 or more purchase. When I checked out, he looked at me with disappointment, then incorrectly argued that the coupon didn't apply. Then finally with a bit of an attitude, took the coupon and appeared to apply it. The total seemed slightly high, but close enough to not argue about. But upon review of the receipt, he only discounted the ticket 4 dollars (I know it's only a dollar, but that's not the point) and also charged a "noncash" fee of 4%. I'd have happily paid with cash if I had known of the 4% credit card fee. Bottom line is the pizza is great, but borderline unethical management will likely keep me away in the future. Maybe the Mozza on Jordan Lane will be worth the drive. Very unfortunate.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
Phillip Allen
Don't go.
Donna Lasseter
I'm self. Deneter. I went there to pick up an order for DoorDash. And deliver to a customer and the atmospheric seems nice. He has needs relaxed and kind of laid back. It's very kind of homey. I guess people are nice. And Fleet smells good and I will go back and definitely hear soon and try out their food. But it smell good and it was a nice staff.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
For The Love Of Noise
Spend basically the same and just eat at Cicis.... if it is too far away, just eat somewhere else.....the pizza makes the stuff at QT and RT gas stations seem luxurious. This buffet should be 5 bucks with how bad it is....or you know, they could just learn how to make good pizza (and by good I mean even school pizza blows this away), wild idea...I know.If you want a great buffet for a little more, head to Chow King in Decatur, it is worth the drive....and even though it isn't a pizza buffet, they always have some...and it is better than this place that specializes in it.
We ate there for the first time and loved it. I grew up in New York and the pizza can't be like New York Pizza because of the water. The ladies that worked there were very nice . We will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Fran Brown
Not going back. spent almost $60 on the buffet for 2 adults one child. Not worth that much.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Alex Peck
Pleasantly Surprised. This location is not the nicest, whatsoever. The buffet did not look very good upon arrival. Though, they constantly were bringing out food for those who showed up and ordered the buffet. We dined-in and ordered, and opted out of the buffet.The location is bare bones, 1 booth. Mexican-restaurant themed interior roofs and bar. Thought that was odd. I didn't expect anything special when it came around to ordering. The menu was loaded, though for an italian place, there was definitely some mexican emphasis on the menu items oddly though.The prices weren't bad at all. A medium can feed 2 people. Good draft beer selection. Just wish had better atmosphere!The pizzas were great, though the house special (fajita style alfredo pizza) was a little bland. For a NY style pizza dough, it was excellent! The zesty ham pizza (ordered out of curiosity) was incredibly good. Overall the place is definitely worth giving a try. I hope this place looks to renovate in the future!I definitely want to come back and try the other non-pizza menu items.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Nancy Steadmon
Went based on the reviews service was great and fresh pizza came out constantly but lacked favor. The garlic knots and cinnamons rolls were great. Drinks are
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cinnamon Rolls, Pizza Buffet and Salad Bar
brandon kohan
They have made something that I've wanted and I have called around town and the only place I could make it was themParking: Parking is located in front of their store I was in and out
There is no salad bar
No more buffet. Biggest mistake they could’ve ever done. Pizza by the slice now. Probably trying to keep up with these crazy prices but now without the buffet that will be harder..
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Great service and the pizza is on point. Personally I think it’s better than Village pizza that it’s across the street from it. Their sister location in Huntsville is just as good. Come try them and support the locals.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Meat Lover Pizza
I enjoyed this place it was the middle of the day so I did not make use of the bar, but it looked like a good one. The pizza on the buffet was more New York style thin crust, but it was all good. The garlic bread nuggets were really
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Honestly my favorite pizza buffet. We moved out of town and still stop by any time we want some pizza. Staff is very welcoming and willing to add whatever pizza to the buffet.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cinnamon Rolls, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Pizza, Pizza Buffet and Salad Bar
What a disappointment. Came out here excited to try the buffet because we loved the new Huntsville location. But the "buffet" is a joke. Cold crusty pasta. Horrible service. And charged for a baby who ate absolutely nothing. What a waste to drive out here. Will never be back.Parking: Horrible parking
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pizza Buffet and Salad Bar
Pizza is excellent. The place is old and not in great shape, but not a big deal if the food it good, and it is. No issue there. However, the owner/manager is unimpressive. I get Mozza coupons in the mail, which helps make the long drive from west Huntsville to Athens worthwhile. However, the owner/manager does not like these coupons. He argues that they are not valid or do not apply, when they clearly do, and then puts restrictions on their use. I understand trying to make a profit and seeing coupons come in the door is not very desirable, but if they get people to come try the pizza (and the pizza sells itself!), they are worthwhile in the long run. The most recent time I was there was the final straw. I had a 5 dollar off a $30 or more purchase. When I checked out, he looked at me with disappointment, then incorrectly argued that the coupon didn't apply. Then finally with a bit of an attitude, took the coupon and appeared to apply it. The total seemed slightly high, but close enough to not argue about. But upon review of the receipt, he only discounted the ticket 4 dollars (I know it's only a dollar, but that's not the point) and also charged a "noncash" fee of 4%. I'd have happily paid with cash if I had known of the 4% credit card fee. Bottom line is the pizza is great, but borderline unethical management will likely keep me away in the future. Maybe the Mozza on Jordan Lane will be worth the drive. Very unfortunate.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
Don't go.
I'm self. Deneter. I went there to pick up an order for DoorDash. And deliver to a customer and the atmospheric seems nice. He has needs relaxed and kind of laid back. It's very kind of homey. I guess people are nice. And Fleet smells good and I will go back and definitely hear soon and try out their food. But it smell good and it was a nice staff.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Spend basically the same and just eat at Cicis.... if it is too far away, just eat somewhere else.....the pizza makes the stuff at QT and RT gas stations seem luxurious. This buffet should be 5 bucks with how bad it is....or you know, they could just learn how to make good pizza (and by good I mean even school pizza blows this away), wild idea...I know.If you want a great buffet for a little more, head to Chow King in Decatur, it is worth the drive....and even though it isn't a pizza buffet, they always have some...and it is better than this place that specializes in it.
Food: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
We ate there for the first time and loved it. I grew up in New York and the pizza can't be like New York Pizza because of the water. The ladies that worked there were very nice . We will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Not going back. spent almost $60 on the buffet for 2 adults one child. Not worth that much.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Pleasantly Surprised. This location is not the nicest, whatsoever. The buffet did not look very good upon arrival. Though, they constantly were bringing out food for those who showed up and ordered the buffet. We dined-in and ordered, and opted out of the buffet.The location is bare bones, 1 booth. Mexican-restaurant themed interior roofs and bar. Thought that was odd. I didn't expect anything special when it came around to ordering. The menu was loaded, though for an italian place, there was definitely some mexican emphasis on the menu items oddly though.The prices weren't bad at all. A medium can feed 2 people. Good draft beer selection. Just wish had better atmosphere!The pizzas were great, though the house special (fajita style alfredo pizza) was a little bland. For a NY style pizza dough, it was excellent! The zesty ham pizza (ordered out of curiosity) was incredibly good. Overall the place is definitely worth giving a try. I hope this place looks to renovate in the future!I definitely want to come back and try the other non-pizza menu items.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Went based on the reviews service was great and fresh pizza came out constantly but lacked favor. The garlic knots and cinnamons rolls were great. Drinks are
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cinnamon Rolls, Pizza Buffet and Salad Bar
They have made something that I've wanted and I have called around town and the only place I could make it was themParking: Parking is located in front of their store I was in and out
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza