Food is inconsistent but the prices aren’t. Noticeable change at all locations the past few years.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Jessica Renea Madden
Definitely not what used to be
Jonas Bowersock
Great food and service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tom Patton
This needs to be renamed to the Amsterdam Bar and Grill, it bears no semblance to the original except for the high food prices. Yes, I have been here before, yes, it was busy, but zero excuse for what we paid for tonight. Solo one man band was overly loud, to the point you could not carry on a conversation with someone right next to you. Floors and rugs were slippery, sticky, and dirty. Drink area was a mess and the ice was out. People with take out orders need a waiting area instead of making dine in customers wait for open booths and tables as others needed bussing. OK, so maybe the food will be the normal Amsterdam standard. My black and blue ribeye sandwich was a lot of gristle on an at least 3 day old, dry, stale bun. Crabcake and avocado sandwich was like a miniaturized version of what it used to be. Chicken Alfredo was mostly noodles and was just “OK”. All for almost $95. Did I mention it was loud in there? My ears are still ringing…
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Ashley Couch
Food was good but very slow. We came for lunch and it took 30 minutes to get our apps and 45 to get the entrees.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
John Ponder
The food was great, it did take quite a while to get our food. Worth the wait though.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Chip Scheler
The steak and fried eggs were amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mary Fuller
Decent for lunch. Avoid for dinner. Very hot and stuffy indoors. Limited seating. Food took an hour and a half to come out. Refused to serve any appetizers even if it was your meal.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Ashley Self
This is the dumbest way to run a restaurant. No table service. Order food from one counter. Order drinks from the bar. No room at the bar to order a drink. The food service industry has lost its way. Will not be back.
John Dubois
As a frequent patron of this restaurant, I can say quality has gone downhill. I sat down with my family today for dinner and the food was cold and bland. The chicken on my pesto caprese was ice cold and they didn’t put nearly any balsamic sauce on it, which is not how than how they usually make it. The club sandwich wasn’t any better either, neither my wife nor myself liked the quality of the meat on that sandwich. The worst part of it is, this restaurant deactivated or intentionally limited output of their indoor air conditioning in the hot summer day and it was so miserable and muggy inside. For the money you pay at this restaurant, what you get isn’t worth the money. Neither myself nor my family will be coming back.
I’m at Amsterdam Café this evening, and I just had the best ordering experience I’ve ever had here — all thanks to Josh at the counter. From the moment I walked up, his personality was magnetic. He didn’t just take my order — he engaged with me, asked how I was doing, shared a positive word, and genuinely made the interaction feel personal.
Josh talked about the power of staying positive and brought an energy that was contagious — the kind of vibe that makes your whole evening better. He paid great attention to my order and even brought the food out himself. That level of attentiveness and care is rare these days, and it made a lasting impression.
Give me attentive and engaged staff like this any day — it makes all the difference. Josh, thank you for turning a routine dinner into a standout moment. Your attitude, effort, and kindness truly set this visit apart from any other. Amsterdam Café, you’ve got a great one on your hands!
Marc Johnson
Great working lunch/meeting location.
Chris Piland
Very popular
Ainsley Whittington
Food was just okay to me. Wings weren’t hot at all.
Food is inconsistent but the prices aren’t. Noticeable change at all locations the past few years.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Definitely not what used to be
Great food and service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This needs to be renamed to the Amsterdam Bar and Grill, it bears no semblance to the original except for the high food prices. Yes, I have been here before, yes, it was busy, but zero excuse for what we paid for tonight. Solo one man band was overly loud, to the point you could not carry on a conversation with someone right next to you. Floors and rugs were slippery, sticky, and dirty. Drink area was a mess and the ice was out. People with take out orders need a waiting area instead of making dine in customers wait for open booths and tables as others needed bussing. OK, so maybe the food will be the normal Amsterdam standard. My black and blue ribeye sandwich was a lot of gristle on an at least 3 day old, dry, stale bun. Crabcake and avocado sandwich was like a miniaturized version of what it used to be. Chicken Alfredo was mostly noodles and was just “OK”. All for almost $95. Did I mention it was loud in there? My ears are still ringing…
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Food was good but very slow. We came for lunch and it took 30 minutes to get our apps and 45 to get the entrees.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
The food was great, it did take quite a while to get our food. Worth the wait though.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
The steak and fried eggs were amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Decent for lunch. Avoid for dinner. Very hot and stuffy indoors. Limited seating. Food took an hour and a half to come out. Refused to serve any appetizers even if it was your meal.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
This is the dumbest way to run a restaurant. No table service. Order food from one counter. Order drinks from the bar. No room at the bar to order a drink. The food service industry has lost its way. Will not be back.
As a frequent patron of this restaurant, I can say quality has gone downhill. I sat down with my family today for dinner and the food was cold and bland. The chicken on my pesto caprese was ice cold and they didn’t put nearly any balsamic sauce on it, which is not how than how they usually make it. The club sandwich wasn’t any better either, neither my wife nor myself liked the quality of the meat on that sandwich. The worst part of it is, this restaurant deactivated or intentionally limited output of their indoor air conditioning in the hot summer day and it was so miserable and muggy inside. For the money you pay at this restaurant, what you get isn’t worth the money. Neither myself nor my family will be coming back.
Restaurantji Recommends
Best Service Experience Yet – Thanks Josh!
I’m at Amsterdam Café this evening, and I just had the best ordering experience I’ve ever had here — all thanks to Josh at the counter. From the moment I walked up, his personality was magnetic. He didn’t just take my order — he engaged with me, asked how I was doing, shared a positive word, and genuinely made the interaction feel personal.
Josh talked about the power of staying positive and brought an energy that was contagious — the kind of vibe that makes your whole evening better. He paid great attention to my order and even brought the food out himself. That level of attentiveness and care is rare these days, and it made a lasting impression.
Give me attentive and engaged staff like this any day — it makes all the difference. Josh, thank you for turning a routine dinner into a standout moment. Your attitude, effort, and kindness truly set this visit apart from any other. Amsterdam Café, you’ve got a great one on your hands!
Great working lunch/meeting location.
Very popular
Food was just okay to me. Wings weren’t hot at all.
I wasn't disappointed when I tried it out
Loading...