Coffee Mafia

414 S Gay St, Auburn
(334) 728-7588

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Hannah Yarborough

Coffee Mafia has a really chill vibe that's necessary in the busyness of college. Parking is hard to find, but if you do, it's a nice place just off campus

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Victoria Springer

Cheap good coffee

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joshua Brinkerhoff

Used to go here back when this is mama mocha’s while I was still an undergrad. The name is change, but the coffee still flows good as they use mama mocha’s beans. They have a lot of unique and different flavors for latte or if you just want good quality espresso they know how to do that well one of my go two stops when visiting Auburn.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chase Childers

Male barista was pretty rude and coffee was mediocre. Do not plan on returning.

Bridgette Walton

I visit Auburn periodically for work and I lucked out finding this spot!! Upon reviewing the website, I knew this place was hard!! I like my coffee tuff, like it might try to fight me later. I got tickled reading some of the other reviews… this place is called Coffee Mafia, not rainbows and sunshine. You’re going to get an authentic experience of their brand. I’ve always received great service. I’ve met nice people while waiting in line. I purchased a growler and I bring it with me for refills of one of their signature drinks “iced crack.” My favorite drink is the iced crack with salted caramel (half sweet). This coffee shop has so much personality. If I lived in the area, I would def be a permanent fixture on one of their eclectic couches. Thank you for serving up strong coffee with an authentic style!! I’ll see you next time I come through.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amanda Januchowski

This is my favorote coffee shop in Auburn. The selection is amazing and so many flavor profile choices, including sugar free and alternative milk options. When I cannot decide, I give them the bare bones of what I want (hot, sugar free, almond milk) and they will make something delicious. I have only had their food twice (avo toast and bagel sandwhich) and both were great. The atmosphere is eclectic and very fitting for the vibe. Love this place and it is a must visit when I am in town.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Nitin Singh

My favorite coffee place near AU campus. I am here almost everyday :)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kristin E. Olsen

First and foremost-the regular cappuccino was excellent. It’s a big space that could use more intimate seating/decor-the vibe is progressive, so not appealing to perhaps a majority-I have to agree with other reviews-that this establishment is not super clean particularly if you are going to opt to sit on the couches. I think if you choose to have fabric furnishings, they will need to be cleaned multiple times throughout the day-with a hand vac or fabric brush-the side tables were full of crumbs from the previous day (s)-might not pass health inspection….would go back-but just for the coffee not the atmosphere-

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 4

Emily Shaw

My husband and I went in for a coffee, I love coffee so much so I like to try new places whenever I can, this place has like 4.7 stars so I thought Yay! A good coffee place! But it was awful, everything about it, atmosphere right when you walk in feels cold and off putting, the staff was not welcoming at all, they made me feel like they didn't want me in there, and the coffee was disgusting, I took 2 drinks and threw it away, same for my husband, I ordered the drink called the volcano it was supposedly caramel with cayane pepper flakes. But it tasted like half and half with watered down dirty coffee beans and there was definitely no pepper kick, Super disappointing, also got it iced and i think there were maybe 5 ice cubes in it. So I do not recommend this place at all.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

B Anders

Place has been here for years and the coffee right now, in November 2024, is the best it has been. Great coffee. Obviously inside could use a refresh but that’s not why you should go. Kind staff

Parking: Parking right out front, somewhat limited, and a large lot next to church. They don’t seem to mind you parking there unless it’s Sunday or a gameday.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 3

Jennifer Martin

Went here for the first time this weekend. The business is very dirty and furnishings are in varying degrees of ruin. The limited amount of space to set drinks/food down were dirty (food crumbs, sticky, dog hair) and trash piled up at the door. The music at the counter area was "screamo-type" metal music. We were missing a food item we ordered (ordered for 5 people) and when I brought my ticket to say I was missing a breakfast sandwich was met with an employee saying they personally put the food in the bag (as if I were not telling the truth). I was polite, said I'm sorry we don't have it, and the employee seemed frustrated when I gave them the ticket. The sandwich was made again and tossed on the counter to me.

Coffee Mafia isn't a place to go if you are networking for business, wanting an environment that presents calm and welcome, or if you want your food order to be met with excellence. Has great potential, but missing the mark. I realize I could have been confused with the name of the business. I will take students elsewhere when visiting.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Georgiana Nightingall

I live overseas and had been wanting to come here for the longest time now. As a queer and non binary person from Alabama, this coffeeshop was so nice to come to. It made me so happy to find a queer and BIPoC friendly space. Really good coffee too!! The people that worked there were super friendly. Will definitely come again.

Jonathan Jensen

Good coffee

Atmosphere: 3

Service: 4

Mika LaDoux

Cool spot! I wish the hours on google were correct. Closing at 1 is slightly early especially if you are planning to do work there. I felt like there could also be more actual tables to do work at. A lot of the seating was couches. I enjoyed the coffee and food though! Everybody was nice.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ronald James

bohemian heaven!! comfy couches, tables and chairs, clean floors, pleasing art installations, great service, tasty drinks, generous food menu.... diamond in Auburn,

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...