Conestoga Steak House
3549 Montgomery Hwy, Dothan
(334) 794-4445
Customers' Favorites
New York Strip Medium Well
Slice of Cheesecake
Homemade Cheesecake
Steaks and Potatoe
Steakhouse Burger
Peanut Butter Pie
Streak and Fries
Home Cut Fries
Shrimp Skewer
Baked Potato
Menu
Photos
+47 photos
+46 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Was not impressed , no longer the restaurant I grew up eating at.ordered steak and fries. Steak came out cooked all right but fries once again were cold. Mother in law ordered surf and turf and grilled shrimp off skewers was ice cold not even a little bit warm. This winds up me ever eating here again. They seem to have problem either cooking and keeping your food hot. To expensive to keep having that kind of service.
First and foremost, we had a awesome waitress: Erin, you were wonderful. First time eating at Conestoga Steak House and it didn't disappoint at all. The food was amazing and delicious. I would recommend Conestoga Steak house to anyone. I will add photos the next time I visit, which will be very soon. Go by and see them soon.
We stopped here for dinner a few nights ago. My wife had the chopped steak burger. I had a steak and baked potato. The sides were good. My wife enjoyed the burger. The steak, It was cooked well, had an ok flavor. Nothing great. I have paid less for better. If they would use a quality meat like Jenkins Farm dry aged Angus Beef out of FL, or another of similar quality, you wouldn't find a seat in the house. The service was great. The Atmosphere is ok, but has that 90s dimmed...
You May Also Like
Taqueria Y Mariscos El Torito - 1451 Westgate Pkwy
![]()
Mexican, New Mexican Cuisine, Seafood
The Honest Seafood Company - 1461 Westgate Pkwy
![]()
Seafood Markets
The Cellar - 1481 Westgate Pkwy #1
![]()
Butcher, American