Conestoga Steak House
3549 Montgomery Hwy, Dothan
(334) 794-4445
Customers' Favorites
New York Strip Medium Well
Homemade Cheesecake
Slice of Cheesecake
Steaks and Potatoe
Steakhouse Burger
Peanut Butter Pie
Streak and Fries
Home Cut Fries
Shrimp Skewer
Chopped Steak
Menu
Photos
+43 photos
+42 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I was really hoping for a better experience. I don't like to eat the chain restaurants because I like to support local businesses. I ordered a sirloin medium. It was extremely tough. They do not carry sparkling water or club soda. . Their dressings are processed along with the butter they serve. The server never filled my water and it almost seemed like it bothred him to serve a Hispanic. He did ask me several times if I needed anything. The interior of the restaurant needs...
It's like an 80's steak house vibe. Steak was good, salad was good yet basic with homemade ranch as a bonus. Sides- broccoli and baked potato we're about undercooked, yeast rolls were different flavor than I'm used to yeast rolls tasting, kinda dense texture, very sweet. Beer and wine choices.
You May Also Like
Taqueria Y Mariscos El Torito - 1451 Westgate Pkwy
![]()
Mexican, New Mexican Cuisine, Seafood
The Honest Seafood Company - 1461 Westgate Pkwy
![]()
Seafood Markets
The Cellar - 1481 Westgate Pkwy #1
![]()
Butcher, American
My girlfriend and I had a great time here! The steak was flavorful, the sides were on point, and you could tell everything was made fresh. Even though we had to wait about 20–30 minutes for a table, the line moved steadily, and the staff stayed friendly throughout.
The service was consistent, and we appreciated how attentive the team was once we were seated. The atmosphere had a classic steakhouse...