For years, I overlooked Great American Cookies, a cookie shop nestled within the fading Wiregrass Commons Mall. Now, two decades later, I've finally experienced its delights and I'm hooked! These cookies are truly fantastic, boasting a perfect texture that's ideal for dunking in milk (a feat that some cough, Crumbl, cough struggle with due to their buttery richness).
Beyond the delicious cookies, the service is wonderfully friendly and the prices are surprisingly reasonable. In a mall that's seen better days, Great American Cookies and the neighboring pretzel shop are bright spots, offering a sweet escape and a reminder that sometimes hidden gems are worth seeking out.
Parking: Easily accessible
Kid-friendliness: It's a cookie place with many children's options
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies
Reagan Howard
no service at all no one was working the front
Kayla Cook
I went in to get a cookie cake slice. I went to the car and tried it to find it crunchy and slightly stale. When I went back to ask if I can swap Mrs Kathy was so kind and swapped it for me! Not just mine but my fiancé’s also. Great service!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookie Cake by the Slice, Regular Cookies
Brian Lane
The best cookie cakes in Dothan.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Beth Thomas
Last minute birthday cookie!!
Ophelia Smith
the store is very clean ,health score is a 97 GREAT JOB!!!!! NEED TO SEE MORE IN OTHER LOCATIONS,THE CLERK JOSEPH WAS VERY NICE ,CLEAN HIM SELF AS FOR UNIFORM WISE,RESPECTFUL HONEST WHEN I ASKED QUESTIONS.FREINDLY,MOST OF ALL THE COOKIES THE RICH FLAVOR YUMMY
Genesis A
These cookies are delicious ❤️
yellowhell72
Exceptional service from this location on a special cookie for a promotion. The associate took our order over the phone and allowed us to text her a pic of what we needed. She did an outstanding job on the design and it was a hit at our reception. Will definitely purchase from here again for all our party needs!
My sister and I were walking past the shop. Katie was decorating a big cookie but I guess she noticed us out of the corner of her eye and she looked up and said hi. My sister was so impressed that she said that she wanted to buy a cookie just because (the worker before we knew her name) acknowledged us. I had to let Katie know why she made the sale. Also, we appreciate her wearing gloves and a mask.
Jason Friedlander
Blueberry muffin cookies are my new favorite thing!
Amy Richardson
Ordered a cookie cake for my daughter's birthday. I had seen one online and wanted to get it, however, it was not one of their designs. I spoke to several employees and after discussing it with them, they let me know that they COULD do this design for my daughter!! It turned out great and she was so happy with it! I highly recommend them - they were so helpful and went above and beyond!!
Cursewind Xavi
Dem cookies so fly, like sex in mah mouf-hole.
Vez M
The only redeeming quality for this store is the quality of the cookies. Management is rude,and treats the workers terribly. Especially behind closed doors. Personally don't recommend this place unless tour bringing your child to get some treats.
For years, I overlooked Great American Cookies, a cookie shop nestled within the fading Wiregrass Commons Mall. Now, two decades later, I've finally experienced its delights and I'm hooked! These cookies are truly fantastic, boasting a perfect texture that's ideal for dunking in milk (a feat that some cough, Crumbl, cough struggle with due to their buttery richness).
Beyond the delicious cookies, the service is wonderfully friendly and the prices are surprisingly reasonable. In a mall that's seen better days, Great American Cookies and the neighboring pretzel shop are bright spots, offering a sweet escape and a reminder that sometimes hidden gems are worth seeking out.
Parking: Easily accessible
Kid-friendliness: It's a cookie place with many children's options
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies
no service at all no one was working the front
I went in to get a cookie cake slice. I went to the car and tried it to find it crunchy and slightly stale. When I went back to ask if I can swap Mrs Kathy was so kind and swapped it for me! Not just mine but my fiancé’s also. Great service!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookie Cake by the Slice, Regular Cookies
The best cookie cakes in Dothan.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Last minute birthday cookie!!
the store is very clean ,health score is a 97 GREAT JOB!!!!! NEED TO SEE MORE IN OTHER LOCATIONS,THE CLERK JOSEPH WAS VERY NICE ,CLEAN HIM SELF AS FOR UNIFORM WISE,RESPECTFUL HONEST WHEN I ASKED QUESTIONS.FREINDLY,MOST OF ALL THE COOKIES THE RICH FLAVOR YUMMY
These cookies are delicious ❤️
Exceptional service from this location on a special cookie for a promotion. The associate took our order over the phone and allowed us to text her a pic of what we needed. She did an outstanding job on the design and it was a hit at our reception. Will definitely purchase from here again for all our party needs!
Best cooking icing cream filled sandwiches ever
These cookies are delicious ❤️
Restaurantji Recommends
My sister and I were walking past the shop. Katie was decorating a big cookie but I guess she noticed us out of the corner of her eye and she looked up and said hi. My sister was so impressed that she said that she wanted to buy a cookie just because (the worker before we knew her name) acknowledged us. I had to let Katie know why she made the sale. Also, we appreciate her wearing gloves and a mask.
Blueberry muffin cookies are my new favorite thing!
Ordered a cookie cake for my daughter's birthday. I had seen one online and wanted to get it, however, it was not one of their designs. I spoke to several employees and after discussing it with them, they let me know that they COULD do this design for my daughter!! It turned out great and she was so happy with it! I highly recommend them - they were so helpful and went above and beyond!!
Dem cookies so fly, like sex in mah mouf-hole.
The only redeeming quality for this store is the quality of the cookies. Management is rude,and treats the workers terribly. Especially behind closed doors. Personally don't recommend this place unless tour bringing your child to get some treats.
Loading...