The Cookie Cottage Bakery

N Randolph Ave, Eufaula

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Bryndon Howell

Amazing service and cookies. I normally deliver to them on my Amazon route, and they offered me cookies. I chose the blueberry cheesecake and wow. I sat in my delivery van for 30 minutes in disbelief at how good those 2 cookies were. I cannot wait to go back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Elizabeth Cobb

Some of the best cookies I have ever had!!

•linds•

The snickerdoodle cookies are to die for!! Staff was super nice as well!

Shaquita Sheppard

Very rude. Will not return.

Hatzlacha

We stopped by for a mid-afternoon cookie fix. Very glad we did. Probably the best were the brownies. Very moist with perfect texture. Next best were either the white chocolate oatmeal cranberry (yes, a lot going on, but tasty!) or the classic chocolate chip cookies. Tried the only cupcake option they had, lemon with filling. A little sweet for my taste, but they got the cupcake part right. I think their lack of cupcake options was a bit shocking, but maybe they will grow into it. Ate some of the pinwheels (ham and cheese) which were good but not as good as the desserts. So, I'd say they're in prime-time with all their many (far more than just these two) cookie options and should expand the cupcakes. I suspect they'd make a really excellent cake, since the skills are there. Friendly service and fair prices. Street parking is a breeze. I'd go weekly if I lived in the area!

Loading...

The Cookie Cottage Bakery

N Randolph Ave, Eufaula, AL 36027