Eatin' in the Attic

117 Main St W, Hartselle
(256) 502-9017

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Don Norrell

My wife and I drove there from Hamilton Alabama which is about an hour and a half away. This place was recommended to Us by someone who who lived in the area.
When you walk in it's like a plethora of oddities. It really is almost like walking into someone's attic because you see things here and there. We both my wife and I had the same thing and we split a hot dog. The food was fantastic and it came out pretty quickly. The only setback is some of the chairs are metal and they do get kind of irritating to sit in after about 45 minutes. So when you come in and look for a table with cushion seats and not the tin chairs. I would recommend this place to anyone who's passing through just because of the nostalgia of it. The city has done a really good job of keeping people in the old buildings in downtown and making the place look fantastic. Go by and support this place it's worth every dollar that you spend in every mile that you drive. They also have these mystery dinner theater is going on there. We and I think that would be fantastic.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Debra Mays

nice restaurant in Hartselle Alabama. Unique decor. The food was excellent and the menu offered choices for everyone. The staff was great!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Derriel J. Theriot

This place is a blast from the past. The decor is vintage and elicits a feel of nostalgia the moment you walk in the door. From the old fashioned CocaCola signs to the seasonal Halloween decor, it has a nice vibe. The food is delicious and southern. I recommend the fried green tomatoes.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Disney Mom

The decor is eclectic and a bit crazy! But really fun! The food was very homey and delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brigette Pinkard

When you're looking for a quirky, eccentric restaurant with excellent food and impeccable service in Hartselle, Alabama, this is the place. Every experience I've had here has been exceptional. This trip i tried the chicken cordon blue with fried green beans, my husband had the rueben sandwich on rye and my daughter had a big thick juicy hamburger. All meals were delicious and yes I tried them all! We had a HUGE slice of chocolate cake too which tasted like devils food and chocolate mousse. Even their water is delicious! The only upset I had was that they're always out of their strawberry lemonade cake which I've been wanting to try, but the chocolate cake was a good substitute!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cindy Field

Tonight was our first time eating there a friend had suggested it to us and oh boy was a good!! Definitely going back and going to spread the word ..

Felicia Tidwell

A unique dining experience in small town America! Family atmosphere! No smoking. Outdoor section and plenty to look at. The food is always fresh and yummy

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The Duke of New York A#1

I wish this place was in the shoals so we could go there all the time. REAL burgers that aren't smashed sad things. So much to look at and keep you entertained. Our waitress was a super worker and sweetie pie. 5/5 candelabras. 🕯️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Miranda Kershaw

We had so much fun there! Ellie was super sweet, we never needed anything. I would recommend this restaurant a hundred times over.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

TRACY DIX

Well, walked in first time there told me to sit where I wanted to, both my husband and I were in awe of the decorations sat down waited 20 mins for a waitress she finally came took our drink order and never came back, after sitting there for over 35 mins, we walked out.... No food, no service!
I've placed this place on my do not revisit list.
Workers too busy serving themselves!

Terrible! 😞

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 1

Liz Butler

Unique

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

brandie clemons

They play games on different nights. Good food and atmosphere

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Julea Moats

Best Reuben sandwich EVER! The wait staff were excellent also. Highly recommend!

Heavenly Laster

Great food and great service!

Ari Adler

Fun if not a bit overwhelming place to check out all kinds of historic memorabilia and eat decent food. The menu has a good variety of choices.

My wife and I both had the Fried Green Tomatoes BLT, hers with a side of onion rings and mine with the baked Mac n Cheese. The sandwiches were tasty even though our bacon was nearly burned and in small pieces rather than strips.

It was a busy night and we suspect the staff was a bit overwhelmed. Perhaps that's why service was slow and the food took forever to arrive. (And why my Mac n Cheese was warm, not hot.)

We were with some locals who said the food and service were usually better so that's why I didn't remove another full star overall. Every restaurant can have an off night.

I'd like to try again when they aren't so busy, and to check out other items on the menu. For example, one person at our table had a patty melt that looked really good.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 2

Loading...