First time visit, I was impressed with the generous toppings! Ordered a super supreme on thick crust. The cheese sticks were delicious. A terrific departure from the fast food pizza chains. I would give it 6 stars if I could.
Da boy Blanked (Loyalist)
The pizza is tasty, I'd eat everything with ranch đ
Janet Watson
We have been in Paxton Pizza's corner for many years. Their Pizza had always been outstanding. However, recently the crust has been a hit and miss and today it was unforgivable. It tasted old and so tough like pie crust when it has been overworked. I asked for extra sauce and extra cheese and didn't detect any extra anything. We are so very disappointed. I hope this will be corrected. 4/21/25 I did call to speak with the manager, but the manager had not made it in. I will try again later on.
4/21/25 The Manager called me back and she was very gracious and understanding. She said she would investigate to determine what happened with the crust in my case. I offered to bring the pizza back (I put it in a zip lock bag in the refrigerator) but she said that was not necessary. In addition, she said I could get a refund or pizza. Like I said we love Paxton pizza so I said we would love another pizza. Because of the way this was handled, I am changing my review score. Thank you very much!
Ken Hasty
Traveling through and got to the town 30 minutes before closing time. Typically when this happens itâs possible to not get the best reception, not the case here. The lady was super nice on the phone and the pizza was amazing. Donât pass up an opportunity to try it, they are not lying when they say they donât skimp on the toppings. Excellent pizza
Resonia Ledbetter
Paxtonâs never disappoints. They are always courteous, food is top tier and I have never saw the restaurant dirty!
Kenny Prince
Great Pizza!!!
Angela Lowery
The team is always very sweet, and the times I have been, very busy. Best advice call in your order vs. going and waiting. Love the flavor of the pizza.
Angela Talley
I tried this place for the first time last night and had an awful experience. I asked for the salad dressing that was left off my order and the guy threw the dressing across the counter at me. I left without getting the dressing. If it wasn't so busy I would have asked for a refund. After getting home with my chief salad and it was was made with spinach leaves, had a little ham and no turkey it was over powered with all the onions. That was my first and last time visiting this establishment.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
William Lowery
They need more people on Friday and Saturday came in to place a order the wait time was 45 minutes but it's more like 1 1/2 .
My favorite place. Every time I'm home we have to get us a pizza, salad and cheese sticks. Also got some of of those cookies and I must say they were delicious. Everything she said about the cookies were accurate. Worth Every bite and penny spent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Justin Hearon
Iâve been eating Paxtonâs pizza for 20+ years, I can say that Iâve never been let down. Family owned. Clean. Delicious. Will never stop coming here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Adrian Keener
This is not my first time coming to Paxton's, but the love and consideration showed to me and my Mom is the reason I keep coming back. ELVIA and GARRET went above and beyond to make sure we were taken care of, even staying late. It's selfless acts from people like them that makes this world a better place. Though people would never think that a selfless act from a "pizza lady" would have such a impact, this shows that anyone can make a difference by showing love! Thank you so much ELVIA and GARRET. GARRET is a very hard and smart worker that would be an asset to any company he chooses to work at. See you both very soon! -Adrian & Theressa
Love this đ pizza
First time visit, I was impressed with the generous toppings! Ordered a super supreme on thick crust. The cheese sticks were delicious. A terrific departure from the fast food pizza chains. I would give it 6 stars if I could.
The pizza is tasty, I'd eat everything with ranch đ
We have been in Paxton Pizza's corner for many years. Their Pizza had always been outstanding. However, recently the crust has been a hit and miss and today it was unforgivable. It tasted old and so tough like pie crust when
it has been overworked. I asked for extra sauce and extra cheese and didn't detect any extra anything. We are so very disappointed. I hope this will be corrected.
4/21/25
I did call to speak with the manager, but the manager had not made it in. I will try again later on.
4/21/25
The Manager called me back and she was very gracious and understanding. She said she would investigate to determine what happened with the crust in my case. I offered to bring the pizza back (I put it in a zip lock bag in the refrigerator) but she said that was not necessary. In addition, she said I could get a refund or pizza. Like I said we love Paxton pizza so I said we would love another pizza.
Because of the way this was handled, I am changing my review score. Thank you very much!
Traveling through and got to the town 30 minutes before closing time. Typically when this happens itâs possible to not get the best reception, not the case here. The lady was super nice on the phone and the pizza was amazing. Donât pass up an opportunity to try it, they are not lying when they say they donât skimp on the toppings. Excellent pizza
Paxtonâs never disappoints. They are always courteous, food is top tier and I have never saw the restaurant dirty!
Great Pizza!!!
The team is always very sweet, and the times I have been, very busy. Best advice call in your order vs. going and waiting.
Love the flavor of the pizza.
I tried this place for the first time last night and had an awful experience. I asked for the salad dressing that was left off my order and the guy threw the dressing across the counter at me. I left without getting the dressing. If it wasn't so busy I would have asked for a refund. After getting home with my chief salad and it was was made with spinach leaves, had a little ham and no turkey it was over powered with all the onions. That was my first and last time visiting this establishment.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
They need more people on Friday and Saturday came in to place a order the wait time was 45 minutes but it's more like 1 1/2 .
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cheeseburger Pizza, Supreme Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
I did not go inside but the food was excellent ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My favorite place. Every time I'm home we have to get us a pizza, salad and cheese sticks. Also got some of of those cookies and I must say they were delicious. Everything she said about the cookies were accurate. Worth Every bite and penny spent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Iâve been eating Paxtonâs pizza for 20+ years, I can say that Iâve never been let down. Family owned. Clean. Delicious. Will never stop coming here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is not my first time coming to Paxton's, but the love and consideration showed to me and my Mom is the reason I keep coming back. ELVIA and GARRET went above and beyond to make sure we were taken care of, even staying late. It's selfless acts from people like them that makes this world a better place. Though people would never think that a selfless act from a "pizza lady" would have such a impact, this shows that anyone can make a difference by showing love! Thank you so much ELVIA and GARRET. GARRET is a very hard and smart worker that would be an asset to any company he chooses to work at. See you both very soon! -Adrian & Theressa
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Meat Lovers
Amazing food good price
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...