Catfish Island
5319 AR-1 N, Caldwell
(870) 633-1706
Customers' Favorites
Slaw and Your Choice of Baked Potato
Catfish and Shrimp Special
Fried Dill Pickle Spears
Tiny Fisherman Plate
Chicken Monterey
Fried Mushrooms
Cheddar Poppers
Catfish Fillet
Popcorn Shrimp
Catfish Plate
Menu
Photos
+26 photos
+25 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Serendipitously discovered as we were traveling down I-40 and trying to avoid the usual fast food restaurant immediately close to the highway. I'm glad we did. Everything great, as long as you're okay with an atemporal, classic neighborhood restaurant.
I have been to Catfish Island several times over the last year. Customer Service is top level. Many people walk out of the building commenting on how good the fish tastes. This spot is comfortable enough for friendship, family, and more.
Very family friendly atmosphere. The servers are quick and so far have never messed up an order, even when we bring larger groups.It gets crowded some weekends, and that changes the atmosphere with all the extra sounds.
You May Also Like
Mrs. Vernie’s - 4600 AR-1
![]()
Food Trucks
Shebrews Coffee & Pie - 4625 N Washington St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee, Coffee & Tea, Beverage Store
Ho Ho Restaurant - 110 Barrow Hill Rd
![]()
Chinese, Bar