Papaw’s Pizza

1020 E 2nd, DeWitt
(870) 946-0482

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Stfanee Davis

Love it good wings and chills staff I just wish there was a jukebox

Randy Briggs

The food: Personally, I'm not a huge fan of the type of crust they use for their pizza. That being said, they also offer cauliflower based crust, which is great for a keto diet and puts Paw Paw's ahead of the curve when it comes to options. That being said, they also have wings and sandwiches, which to me are the real deal. There may be competitors around the area with their pizza, but Paw Paw's beats them out on sauced wings, and ya know what? This pizza shop knows how to make a mean Philly cheese steak sandwich. They offer a decent variety of sauces for those previously mentioned wings, and they have several dip options as well.
As for the service: I haven't had any issues with them. In fact I called in an order for a keto pizza, which takes them 15 minutes to make, and I was 30 minutes away at the time. They started to make it 15 minutes before I'd arrive as requested, so you can tell the staff are well coordinated.
Atmosphere: It has your standard lunchroom layout with a salad bar in the middle. Getting into the main area is a bit cramped if there are customers at the pay desk, the hallway not being quite wide enough for 2 parties. There is what appears to be a private eating area for events, and such, but I don't know what that looks like on the inside since I've never booked it before.

amber hurst

Good food good service

Nick Phelps

Got a pizza that came out fresh and delicious. It did take a tad bit longer than I would have liked, but they were busy when I went in.

Food: 5

Jamie M Garrett Sturch

Great service, good pizza thick crust without all the grease!

Tammy Chappell

AWESOME!!!

Lisa McGilton

I love this place! Great food! Great service! Bacon chicken ranch pizza is awesome, as is the Philly sandwiches! So much food for a good price. I love they have a pickup window too

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kay Keister

The salad was great and the pizza. Staff was very friendly and fast. We will go back

Parking: Easy parking

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers Pizza, Bread Sticks with Cheese

Katelyne Standiford

My sister and I came by here yesterday to grab a pizza for her 30th birthday. When leaving the wind blew the pizza out of our hand because the top was not closed by them all the way. We returned to get another one and the lady was not understanding at all and made us pay for another one even though we had just left and it was no fault of ours. The older woman with black hair and glasses said multiple times “hang on to this one better” in a very sarcastic tone. Horrible customer service and pizza was definitely not worth $40.

Service: 1

Jamie Bryant

I paid $50 for pretty much just crust i have had pretty good experience with this place but the pizza we got tonight was pitiful the cheese pizzas barely had any cheese on them and the sausage and mushroom didn't look it had any cheese or anything else for that matter i don't believe we will be back.

Monty Johnson

This was some of the best pizza and wings I've ever had, and the service was awesome!!!Everyone that doesn't give the food a 5 star rating needs to go back to eating Little Ceasars because you don't know good pizza.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Manon Dmg

Food and staff were nice.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Matt Graves

This is the best place to eat around. Great service and EXCELLENT food. 3 of us ate there. One got a meat trio sandwich the other got a meatball sandwich and I got the buffalo chicken pizza. Only thing we said to each other was mmmmmm!!!!

Joni Richmond Reed

Great service and great food

Loading...